2025 SESSION
HOUSE SUBSTITUTE
INTRODUCED
25105148D25102252D
HOUSE BILL NO. 1642
AMENDMENT IN THE NATURE OF A SUBSTITUTE
Offered January 13, 2025
Prefiled January 3, 2025
A BILL to amend the Code of Virginia by adding in Title 19.2 a chapter numbered 1.3, consisting of sections numbered 19.2-11.14 and 19.2-11.15, relating to criminal justice risk assessments; human oversight.
—————
Patrons—Hayes, Clark, Cousins, Henson and Keys-Gamarra
—————
(ProposedReferred by the Houseto Committee for Courts of Justice
on January 17, 2025)
(Patron Prior to Substitute—Delegate Hayes)
A BILL to amend the Code of Virginia by adding in Title 19.2 a chapter numbered 1.3, consisting of a section numbered 19.2-11.14, relating to use of artificial intelligence-based tool for criminal justice purpose.
—————
Be it enacted by the General Assembly of Virginia:
1. That the Code of Virginia is amended by adding in Title 19.2 a chapter numbered 1.3, consisting of a sectionsections numbered 19.2-11.14 and 19.2-11.15, as follows:
CHAPTER 1.3.
ARTIFICIAL INTELLENCE-BASED TOOLS FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE PURPOSES .
§ 19.2-11.14. Use of artificial intelligence-based tool for criminal justice purpose .
A. As used in this section :
CRIMINAL JUSTICE RISK ASSESSMENTS.
§ 19.2-11.14. Definitions .
As used in this chapter , unless the context requires a different meaning :
"Artificial intelligence-based t oolools" means any software systems or algorithms, including machine learning models, predictive analyti c s, and decision support systems, that analyze data and generate recommendations or predictions used to inform criminal justice decisions.
" Criminal justice purpose " means any activity related to pretrial detention or release, prosecution, adjudication, probation, parole, correctional supervision , or rehabilitation of criminal offenders .
B. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the recommendations or predictions provided by any artificial intelligence-based tool utilized for any criminal justice purpose shall not be the sole basis for any decision related to such criminal justice purpose . However, t he results of any artificial intelligence-based tool may be used in informing a final decision, provided that any such final decision is made by a human.
"Human o versight" means the process by which a qualified human decision maker reviews and approves the outputs or recommendations of an artificial intelligence-based tool prior to its use in making or informing a final decision.
§ 19.2-11.15. Criminal justice risk assessments; human oversigh t .
Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the recommendations or predictions provided by any artificial intelligence-based tool utilized for criminal justice purposes, including recommendations or predictions related to p retrial release, sentencing, probation, or parole , shall be reviewed and approved by a qualified human decision maker prior to using any such recommendations or predictions in making or informing a final decision. No decision related to pretrial release, sentencing, probation, or parole may rely solely on the recommendation of an artificial intelligence -based tool without documented human oversight. Documentation of such human oversight shall include the artificial intelligence-generated recommendation or prediction and the rationale for its acceptance, modification, or rejection by the qualified human decision maker.