Enrolled
El texto subrayado se agregaría a la ley vigente. El texto tachado se eliminaría.
| H.B. No. 5560 |
| AN ACT | ||
| relating to penalties in certain suits involving a groundwater | ||
| conservation district; increasing a penalty. | ||
| BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: | ||
| SECTION 1. Section 36.102, Water Code, is amended by | ||
| amending Subsection (b) and adding Subsections (b-1) and (f) to | ||
| read as follows: | ||
| (b) Except as provided by Subsection (f), the [ |
||
| rule may set reasonable civil penalties, including a range of | ||
| reasonable civil penalties, that the district may recover from | ||
| [ |
||
| amount not to exceed $25,000 [ |
||
| each day of a continuing violation constitutes a separate | ||
| violation. | ||
| (b-1) In determining the amount of a civil penalty under | ||
| this section, the court shall consider: | ||
| (1) the nature, circumstances, extent, duration, and | ||
| gravity of the violation, with special emphasis on the effect of the | ||
| violation on: | ||
| (A) groundwater resources; | ||
| (B) another person's right to produce | ||
| groundwater; | ||
| (C) public health and safety; or | ||
| (D) other water resources or the environment; | ||
| (2) with respect to the alleged violator: | ||
| (A) the history and extent of previous | ||
| violations; | ||
| (B) the degree of culpability, including whether | ||
| the violation was attributable to mechanical or electrical failures | ||
| and whether the violation could have been reasonably anticipated | ||
| and avoided; | ||
| (C) the demonstrated good faith, including | ||
| actions taken by the alleged violator to rectify the cause of the | ||
| violation and to compensate the affected person; | ||
| (D) whether there was an economic benefit gained | ||
| as a result of the violation and, if so, the amount of the economic | ||
| benefit; | ||
| (E) the amount necessary to deter future | ||
| violations; and | ||
| (F) if the alleged violator is a person required | ||
| to adopt a drought contingency plan under Section 11.1272 and | ||
| overproduction of groundwater is the basis of the alleged | ||
| violation, whether the person acted in good faith and exercised | ||
| reasonable diligence in implementing and enforcing the terms of the | ||
| plan; and | ||
| (3) any other matters that justice may require. | ||
| (f) In an enforcement action brought by a district against a | ||
| person, the court may assess a penalty greater than the maximum | ||
| penalty authorized under Subsection (b) if the court determines | ||
| that the person gained an economic benefit as a result of the | ||
| violation that was greater than the maximum penalty under | ||
| Subsection (b). A penalty assessed under this subsection must be in | ||
| an amount determined by the court to be necessary and appropriate to | ||
| outweigh the economic benefit gained by the person as a result of | ||
| the violation and discourage future violations. | ||
| SECTION 2. Subchapter D, Chapter 36, Water Code, is amended | ||
| by adding Sections 36.1021 and 36.1022 to read as follows: | ||
| Sec. 36.1021. DEFERRAL OF PENALTY. (a) A court by order may | ||
| allow a person to defer the payment of not more than 50 percent of | ||
| the total amount of the civil penalties awarded by the court to a | ||
| district for a violation under Section 36.102 on the condition that | ||
| the person complies with all provisions for corrective action to | ||
| address the violation. | ||
| (b) A court order under Subsection (a) must require the | ||
| person to spend an amount of money equal to the amount of the civil | ||
| penalty deferred by the court to mitigate the consequences of a | ||
| violation of a rule of the district or prevent future violations of | ||
| a rule of the district. | ||
| (c) In determining whether deferral of a civil penalty under | ||
| this section is appropriate and the amount, if any, to be deferred, | ||
| the court must consider: | ||
| (1) the factors used in determining the amount of the | ||
| civil penalty under Section 36.102(b-1); | ||
| (2) whether the amount of the civil penalty that is not | ||
| deferred, when combined with the amount of any attorney's fees | ||
| awarded by the court to the district, will at a minimum cover the | ||
| costs and expenditures of the district in enforcing its rules | ||
| against the person so that the district will be made financially | ||
| whole; | ||
| (3) the financial position of the person and the | ||
| person's ability to reasonably pay the costs associated with the | ||
| corrective action under the terms of the court order; | ||
| (4) any risks to groundwater resources, another | ||
| person's right to produce groundwater, public health and safety, or | ||
| other water resources or the environment that would result from a | ||
| delay in implementing the corrective action because of the person's | ||
| limited financial resources; | ||
| (5) any alternatives reasonably available to the | ||
| person for the purpose of paying the penalty and any costs | ||
| associated with taking the corrective action; and | ||
| (6) whether requiring the person to pay the civil | ||
| penalty will affect other essential public health and safety | ||
| services for which the person is responsible. | ||
| (d) If the person seeking deferral of a civil penalty under | ||
| this section is a wholesale or retail public water system, the | ||
| corrective action for purposes of Subsection (a) may include | ||
| capital improvements that benefit the water system in which the | ||
| violation occurred, including securing additional sources of water | ||
| supply, addressing system water loss, or otherwise addressing water | ||
| conservation issues. | ||
| (e) The court may require the person to pay the full amount | ||
| of the civil penalty under Section 36.102 if the court finds that | ||
| the person is not in compliance with a provision of the court order | ||
| issued under Subsection (a) of this section. | ||
| Sec. 36.1022. RECOVERY OF CIVIL PENALTY BY WATER AND SEWER | ||
| UTILITY. (a) A court that has assessed a civil penalty against a | ||
| water and sewer utility, as defined by Section 13.002, under | ||
| Section 36.102 for violation of a district rule limiting | ||
| groundwater production may authorize the utility to recover, in any | ||
| manner that is equitable and just, all or part of the civil penalty | ||
| from any customers or class of customers responsible for causing | ||
| the utility to violate the rule. | ||
| (b) The court may allow the recovery of the civil penalty | ||
| only if the court finds that: | ||
| (1) the utility acted in good faith and exercised | ||
| reasonable diligence in implementing and enforcing the terms of the | ||
| utility's drought contingency plan required by Section 11.1272; and | ||
| (2) the customers from whom the civil penalty will be | ||
| recovered continued to violate the provisions of the drought | ||
| contingency plan despite the utility's enforcement measures. | ||
| (c) The utility may retain a civil penalty recovered under | ||
| this section unless the court directs the utility to use the money | ||
| for a specific purpose in the interests of justice. | ||
| (d) A civil penalty recovered under this section is not a | ||
| rate as defined by Section 13.002 and may not be considered revenue | ||
| of the utility in a rate proceeding under Chapter 13. | ||
| SECTION 3. Section 36.102, Water Code, as amended by this | ||
| Act, and Sections 36.1021 and 36.1022, Water Code, as added by this | ||
| Act, apply only to a suit involving a groundwater conservation | ||
| district that is filed on or after the effective date of this Act. A | ||
| suit filed before the effective date of this Act is subject to the | ||
| law in effect on the date the suit is filed, and that law is | ||
| continued in effect for that purpose. | ||
| SECTION 4. This Act takes effect September 1, 2025. | ||
| ______________________________ | ______________________________ | |
| President of the Senate | Speaker of the House | |
| I certify that H.B. No. 5560 was passed by the House on May 8, | ||
| 2025, by the following vote: Yeas 144, Nays 3, 2 present, not | ||
| voting; and that the House concurred in Senate amendments to H.B. | ||
| No. 5560 on May 29, 2025, by the following vote: Yeas 125, Nays 4, | ||
| 3 present, not voting. | ||
| ______________________________ | ||
| Chief Clerk of the House | ||
| I certify that H.B. No. 5560 was passed by the Senate, with | ||
| amendments, on May 19, 2025, by the following vote: Yeas 28, Nays | ||
| 3. | ||
| ______________________________ | ||
| Secretary of the Senate | ||
| APPROVED: __________________ | ||
| Date | ||
| __________________ | ||
| Governor |
Texto oficial de la Legislatura de Texas. El formato se adaptó para leerlo en Ratifi.