Introduced
El texto subrayado se agregaría a la ley vigente. El texto tachado se eliminaría.
| 89R16793 SCL-D | ||
| By: Bonnen | H.B. No. 4806 |
| A BILL TO BE ENTITLED | |
| AN ACT | |
| relating to recovery of damages in civil actions. | |
| BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: | |
| SECTION 1. Section 18.001, Civil Practice and Remedies | |
| Code, is amended by amending Subsections (b), (e), (e-1), (h), and | |
| (i) and adding Subsections (b-1) and (b-2) to read as follows: | |
| (b) Unless notice of intent to controvert the | |
| reasonableness of the amounts charged or the necessity for health | |
| care services [ |
|
| this section, an affidavit complying with this section and stating | |
| that the amount a person charged for a service was reasonable at the | |
| time and place that the service was provided and that the service | |
| was necessary is sufficient evidence to support a finding of fact by | |
| judge or jury that the amount charged was reasonable or that the | |
| service was necessary. | |
| (b-1) Except as provided by Section 18.0011, if notice of | |
| intent to controvert the reasonableness of the amounts charged or | |
| necessity for health care services is served as provided by this | |
| section, an affidavit served under Subsection (b) has no effect | |
| except the affidavit may prove the authenticity of the health care | |
| records described by the affidavit. | |
| (b-2) An [ |
|
| evidence of and does not support a finding of the causation element | |
| of the cause of action that is the basis for the civil action. | |
| (e) A party intending to controvert the reasonableness of | |
| the amounts charged or necessity for health care services [ |
|
| attorney of record by the earlier of: | |
| (1) 120 days after the date the defendant files its | |
| answer; | |
| (2) the date the party serving notice [ |
|
| order; or | |
| (3) the date the party serving notice [ |
|
| the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure. | |
| (e-1) Notwithstanding Subsection (e), if the party offering | |
| the affidavit [ |
|
| Subsection (d-1), notice of intent to controvert the reasonableness | |
| of the amounts charged or necessity for health care services must be | |
| served [ |
|
| other party to the case by the later of: | |
| (1) 30 days after service of the affidavit on the party | |
| serving notice [ |
|
| (2) the date the party serving notice [ |
|
| order; or | |
| (3) the date the party serving notice [ |
|
| required by the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure. | |
| (h) If health care [ |
|
| a relevant deadline under this section: | |
| (1) a party may supplement an affidavit served by the | |
| party under Subsection (d) or (d-1) on or before the 60th day before | |
| the date the trial commences; and | |
| (2) a party that served notice [ |
|
| under Subsection (e) or (e-1) may serve notice related to the | |
| supplemental affidavit [ |
|
| before the 30th day before the date the trial commences. | |
| (i) Notwithstanding Subsections (d), (d-1), (d-2), (e), | |
| (e-1), [ |
|
| by all parties to an action by agreement or with leave of the court. | |
| SECTION 2. Subchapter A, Chapter 18, Civil Practice and | |
| Remedies Code, is amended by adding Section 18.0011 to read as | |
| follows: | |
| Sec. 18.0011. AFFIDAVIT OF HEALTH CARE FACILITY OR | |
| PROVIDER. (a) A party may not controvert the reasonableness of the | |
| charges for health care services stated in an affidavit served | |
| under Section 18.001 if, as to each health care service provided by | |
| the health care facility or provider: | |
| (1) the affidavit states one of the following amounts | |
| as the reasonable charge for the service: | |
| (A) the amounts received from all sources by the | |
| facility or provider to pay for the service provided to the person | |
| whose injury or death is the subject of the action; or | |
| (B) an amount that does not exceed 150 percent of | |
| the median amount paid by nongovernmental third-party payors to | |
| health care facilities or providers for the same type of service | |
| provided to the person whose injury or death is the subject of the | |
| action during the month in which the service was provided, as drawn | |
| from the Texas All Payor Claims Database established under | |
| Subchapter I, Chapter 38, Insurance Code, for the geozip: | |
| (i) in which the service was provided, if | |
| the service was provided in this state; or | |
| (ii) in which The University of Texas | |
| Health Science Center at Houston is located, if the service was | |
| provided outside of this state; and | |
| (2) the affidavit is accompanied by an invoice for the | |
| service that would comply with the clean claim requirements of | |
| Chapter 1301, Insurance Code. | |
| (b) If an affidavit of a health care facility or provider | |
| served under Section 18.001 complies with Subsection (a) and | |
| includes a statement that the facility or provider does not intend | |
| to appear at trial to testify regarding the reasonableness of the | |
| facility's or provider's charges or the necessity for the facility's | |
| or provider's services, then: | |
| (1) a party may not seek to obtain through any pretrial | |
| discovery procedure information from the facility or provider about | |
| the reasonableness of the facility's or provider's charges or the | |
| necessity for the facility's or provider's services; and | |
| (2) the trial court shall exclude trial testimony by | |
| the facility or provider regarding the reasonableness of the | |
| facility's or provider's charges or the necessity for the facility's | |
| or provider's services unless: | |
| (A) the court finds there is good cause to allow | |
| the testimony; | |
| (B) the testimony will not unfairly surprise or | |
| unfairly prejudice any party to the action; and | |
| (C) a party opposing admission of the testimony | |
| into evidence is given a reasonable opportunity to conduct | |
| discovery and present evidence relevant to the testimony to be | |
| offered by the facility or provider. | |
| (c) An affidavit of a health care facility or provider | |
| described by Subsection (a) and the statements made in the | |
| affidavit may be used only in the civil action in which the | |
| affidavit is served and not in other actions or for other purposes. | |
| SECTION 3. Chapter 41, Civil Practice and Remedies Code, is | |
| amended by designating Sections 41.001, 41.002, 41.008, 41.009, | |
| 41.0105, and 41.014 as Subchapter A and adding a subchapter heading | |
| to read as follows: | |
| SUBCHAPTER A. GENERAL PROVISIONS | |
| SECTION 4. Section 41.001, Civil Practice and Remedies | |
| Code, is amended by amending Subdivisions (9), (10), and (12) and | |
| adding Subdivisions (11-a) and (14) to read as follows: | |
| (9) "Future damages" means damages that in reasonable | |
| probability can be expected to be [ |
|
| the judgment. The term does [ |
|
| exemplary damages. | |
| (10) "Future loss of earnings" means a pecuniary loss | |
| from reductions in income, wages, or earning capacity that in | |
| reasonable probability can be expected to be incurred after the | |
| date of the judgment. The term does not include [ |
|
| [ |
|
| [ |
|
| (11-a) "Mental or emotional pain or anguish" means | |
| grievous and debilitating angst, distress, torment, or emotional | |
| suffering or turmoil that: | |
| (A) causes a substantial disruption in a person's | |
| daily routine; and | |
| (B) arises from loss of consortium, loss of | |
| companionship and society, loss of enjoyment of life, or a similar | |
| mental or emotional injury. | |
| (12) "Noneconomic damages" means damages awarded for | |
| the purpose of compensating a claimant for nonpecuniary losses for | |
| physical pain and suffering, mental or emotional pain or anguish, | |
| and [ |
|
| economic or exemplary damages. | |
| (14) "Physical pain and suffering" means a painful or | |
| distressing sensation associated with an injury or damage to a part | |
| of a person's body that: | |
| (A) is consciously felt; | |
| (B) is significant in magnitude; and | |
| (C) arises from an observable injury or | |
| impairment or is shown to exist through objectively verifiable | |
| medical evaluation or testing. | |
| SECTION 5. Section 41.002(d), Civil Practice and Remedies | |
| Code, is amended to read as follows: | |
| (d) Notwithstanding any provision to the contrary, the | |
| provisions of this chapter regarding exemplary damages do [ |
|
| not apply to: | |
| (1) Section 15.21, Business & Commerce Code (Texas | |
| Free Enterprise and Antitrust Act of 1983); | |
| (2) an action brought under the Deceptive Trade | |
| Practices-Consumer Protection Act (Subchapter E, Chapter 17, | |
| Business & Commerce Code) except as specifically provided in | |
| Section 17.50 of that Act; | |
| (3) an action brought under Chapter 36, Human | |
| Resources Code; or | |
| (4) an action brought under Chapter 21, Insurance | |
| Code. | |
| SECTION 6. Chapter 41, Civil Practice and Remedies Code, is | |
| amended by adding Subchapter B, and a heading is added to that | |
| subchapter to read as follows: | |
| SUBCHAPTER B. EXEMPLARY DAMAGES | |
| SECTION 7. Sections 41.003, 41.004, 41.005, 41.006, 41.007, | |
| 41.010, 41.011, 41.0115, 41.012, and 41.013, Civil Practice and | |
| Remedies Code, are transferred to Subchapter B, Chapter 41, Civil | |
| Practice and Remedies Code, as added by this Act, redesignated as | |
| Sections 41.051, 41.052, 41.053, 41.054, 41.055, 41.056, 41.057, | |
| 41.058, 41.059, and 41.060, Civil Practice and Remedies Code, | |
| respectively, and amended to read as follows: | |
| Sec. 41.051 [ |
|
| exemplary damages may be awarded only if the claimant proves by | |
| clear and convincing evidence that the harm with respect to which | |
| the claimant seeks recovery of exemplary damages results from: | |
| (1) fraud; | |
| (2) malice; or | |
| (3) gross negligence. | |
| (b) The claimant must prove by clear and convincing evidence | |
| the elements of exemplary damages as provided by this section. This | |
| burden of proof may not be shifted to the defendant or satisfied by | |
| evidence of ordinary negligence, bad faith, or a deceptive trade | |
| practice. | |
| (c) If the claimant relies on a statute establishing a cause | |
| of action and authorizing exemplary damages in specified | |
| circumstances or in conjunction with a specified culpable mental | |
| state, exemplary damages may be awarded only if the claimant proves | |
| by clear and convincing evidence that the damages result from the | |
| specified circumstances or culpable mental state. | |
| (d) Exemplary damages may be awarded only if the jury was | |
| unanimous in regard to finding liability for and the amount of | |
| exemplary damages. | |
| (e) In all cases where the issue of exemplary damages is | |
| submitted to the jury, the following instruction shall be included | |
| in the charge of the court: | |
| "You are instructed that, in order for you to find exemplary | |
| damages, your answer to the question regarding the amount of such | |
| damages must be unanimous." | |
| Sec. 41.052 [ |
|
| Except as provided by Subsection (b), exemplary damages may be | |
| awarded only if damages other than nominal damages are awarded. | |
| (b) Exemplary damages may not be awarded to a claimant who | |
| elects to have his recovery multiplied under another statute. | |
| Sec. 41.053 [ |
|
| (a) In an action arising from harm resulting from an assault, | |
| theft, or other criminal act, a court may not award exemplary | |
| damages against a defendant because of the criminal act of another. | |
| (b) The exemption provided by Subsection (a) does not apply | |
| if: | |
| (1) the criminal act was committed by an employee of | |
| the defendant; | |
| (2) the defendant is criminally responsible as a party | |
| to the criminal act under the provisions of Chapter 7, Penal Code; | |
| (3) the criminal act occurred at a location where, at | |
| the time of the criminal act, the defendant was maintaining a common | |
| nuisance under the provisions of Chapter 125, Civil Practice and | |
| Remedies Code, and had not made reasonable attempts to abate the | |
| nuisance; or | |
| (4) the criminal act resulted from the defendant's | |
| intentional or knowing violation of a statutory duty under | |
| Subchapter D, Chapter 92, Property Code, and the criminal act | |
| occurred after the statutory deadline for compliance with that | |
| duty. | |
| (c) In an action arising out of a criminal act committed by | |
| an employee, the employer may be liable for punitive damages but | |
| only if: | |
| (1) the principal authorized the doing and the manner | |
| of the act; | |
| (2) the agent was unfit and the principal acted with | |
| malice in employing or retaining the agent [ |
|
| (3) the agent was employed in a managerial capacity | |
| and was acting in the scope of employment; or | |
| (4) the employer or a manager of the employer ratified | |
| or approved the act. | |
| Sec. 41.054 [ |
|
| action in which there are two or more defendants, an award of | |
| exemplary damages must be specific as to a defendant, and each | |
| defendant is liable only for the amount of the award made against | |
| that defendant. | |
| Sec. 41.055 [ |
|
| interest may not be assessed or recovered on an award of exemplary | |
| damages. | |
| Sec. 41.056 [ |
|
| Before making an award of exemplary damages, the trier of fact shall | |
| consider the definition and purposes of exemplary damages as | |
| provided by Section 41.001. | |
| (b) Subject to Section 41.008, the determination of whether | |
| to award exemplary damages and the amount of exemplary damages to be | |
| awarded is within the discretion of the trier of fact. | |
| Sec. 41.057 [ |
|
| EXEMPLARY DAMAGES. (a) In determining the amount of exemplary | |
| damages, the trier of fact shall consider evidence, if any, | |
| relating to: | |
| (1) the nature of the wrong; | |
| (2) the character of the conduct involved; | |
| (3) the degree of culpability of the wrongdoer; | |
| (4) the situation and sensibilities of the parties | |
| concerned; | |
| (5) the extent to which such conduct offends a public | |
| sense of justice and propriety; and | |
| (6) the net worth of the defendant. | |
| (b) Evidence that is relevant only to the amount of | |
| exemplary damages that may be awarded is not admissible during the | |
| first phase of a bifurcated trial. | |
| Sec. 41.058 [ |
|
| FOR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES CLAIM. (a) On the motion of a party and after | |
| notice and a hearing, a trial court may authorize discovery of | |
| evidence of a defendant's net worth if the court finds in a written | |
| order that the claimant has demonstrated a substantial likelihood | |
| of success on the merits of a claim for exemplary damages. Evidence | |
| submitted by a party to the court in support of or in opposition to a | |
| motion made under this subsection may be in the form of an affidavit | |
| or a response to discovery. | |
| (b) If a trial court authorizes discovery under Subsection | |
| (a), the court's order may only authorize use of the least | |
| burdensome method available to obtain the net worth evidence. | |
| (c) When reviewing an order authorizing or denying | |
| discovery of net worth evidence under this section, the reviewing | |
| court may consider only the evidence submitted by the parties to the | |
| trial court in support of or in opposition to the motion described | |
| by Subsection (a). | |
| (d) If a party requests net worth discovery under this | |
| section, the court shall presume that the requesting party has had | |
| adequate time for the discovery of facts relating to exemplary | |
| damages for purposes of allowing the party from whom net worth | |
| discovery is sought to move for summary judgment on the requesting | |
| party's claim for exemplary damages under Rule 166a(i), Texas Rules | |
| of Civil Procedure. | |
| Sec. 41.059 [ |
|
| jury, the court shall instruct the jury with regard to Sections | |
| 41.001, 41.051 [ |
|
| Sec. 41.060 [ |
|
| Except as provided for in Subsection (b), an appellate court that | |
| reviews the evidence with respect to a finding by a trier of fact | |
| concerning liability for exemplary damages or with respect to the | |
| amount of exemplary damages awarded shall state, in a written | |
| opinion, the court's reasons for upholding or disturbing the | |
| finding or award. The written opinion shall address the evidence or | |
| lack of evidence with specificity, as it relates to the liability | |
| for or amount of exemplary damages, in light of the requirements of | |
| this chapter. | |
| (b) This section does not apply to the supreme court with | |
| respect to its consideration of a petition for review [ |
|
| SECTION 8. Chapter 41, Civil Practice and Remedies Code, is | |
| amended by adding Subchapters C and D to read as follows: | |
| SUBCHAPTER C. RECOVERY OF HEALTH CARE EXPENSES AS ECONOMIC DAMAGES | |
| Sec. 41.101. DEFINITIONS. In this subchapter: | |
| (1) "Database" means the Texas All Payor Claims | |
| Database established under Subchapter I, Chapter 38, Insurance | |
| Code. | |
| (2) "Health care expenses" means amounts paid or owed | |
| or that may be paid or owed to a provider for health care services, | |
| supplies, or devices provided to a patient. | |
| (3) "Health care services" means services provided by | |
| a provider to an individual to diagnose, prevent, alleviate, cure, | |
| treat, or heal the individual's condition, illness, or injury, | |
| including: | |
| (A) rehabilitative services provided to the | |
| individual; or | |
| (B) personal care provided to the individual on a | |
| short-term or long-term basis. | |
| (4) "Injured individual" means the individual whose | |
| injury or death is the subject of a civil action to which this | |
| subchapter applies. | |
| (5) "Letter of protection" means an agreement, | |
| regardless of the name, that includes an express or implied promise | |
| of payment to a health care provider from a judgment or settlement | |
| of an injured individual's civil action or that makes a payment to | |
| the provider contingent on the resolution of the action. | |
| (6) "Physician" means: | |
| (A) an individual licensed to practice medicine; | |
| and | |
| (B) a professional association, partnership, | |
| limited liability partnership, or other type of entity formed or | |
| organized by an individual physician or group of physicians to | |
| provide medical care to patients. | |
| (7) "Provider" means a person, including an | |
| individual, partnership, professional association, corporation, | |
| facility, or institution, who is licensed, certified, registered, | |
| chartered, or otherwise authorized, in this state or elsewhere, to | |
| provide health care services, including: | |
| (A) an acupuncturist; | |
| (B) a chiropractor; | |
| (C) a dentist; | |
| (D) a health care institution of a type described | |
| by Section 74.001(11); | |
| (E) a health care collaborative; | |
| (F) a nonprofit health organization; | |
| (G) a nurse, including a licensed vocational | |
| nurse, nurse practitioner, and registered nurse; | |
| (H) an occupational therapist; | |
| (I) an ophthalmologist; | |
| (J) an optometrist; | |
| (K) a pharmacist; | |
| (L) a physical therapist; | |
| (M) a physician; | |
| (N) a physician's assistant; and | |
| (O) a podiatrist. | |
| (8) "Third-party payor" means an entity, plan, or | |
| program that has a legal or contractual obligation to pay, | |
| reimburse, or otherwise contract with a provider to pay the | |
| provider for the provision of a health care service, supply, or | |
| device to a patient, including: | |
| (A) an insurance company providing health or | |
| dental insurance; | |
| (B) an employer-provided plan or any other | |
| sponsor or administrator of a health or dental plan; | |
| (C) a health maintenance organization operating | |
| under Chapter 843, Insurance Code, an insurer providing a preferred | |
| provider benefit plan under Chapter 1301, Insurance Code, or other | |
| similar entity; | |
| (D) Medicare; | |
| (E) the state Medicaid program, including the | |
| Medicaid managed care program operating under Chapter 540, | |
| Government Code; and | |
| (F) workers' compensation insurance or insurance | |
| provided instead of subscribing to workers' compensation | |
| insurance. | |
| Sec. 41.102. APPLICABILITY OF SUBCHAPTER. This subchapter | |
| applies to any civil action in which the claimant seeks recovery of | |
| health care expenses as economic damages in a personal injury or | |
| wrongful death action. | |
| Sec. 41.103. CONFLICT WITH OTHER LAW. If there is a | |
| conflict between this subchapter and Section 41.0105, this | |
| subchapter controls. | |
| Sec. 41.104. LIMITATIONS ON AMOUNT OF RECOVERY. (a) In | |
| addition to any other limitation provided by law, the economic | |
| damages that may be awarded to a claimant for health care services | |
| provided in the past to an injured individual are limited to the sum | |
| of: | |
| (1) amounts third-party payors paid to providers for | |
| health care services provided to the injured individual; | |
| (2) amounts paid by the injured individual or paid on | |
| behalf of the injured individual by non-third-party payors to | |
| providers for health care services provided to the injured | |
| individual, but not to purchase an account receivable, if paid | |
| without a formal or informal agreement for the provider to refund, | |
| rebate, or remit money to the payor, injured individual, claimant, | |
| or claimant's attorney or anyone associated with the payor, injured | |
| individual, claimant, or claimant's attorney; and | |
| (3) if Subdivisions (1) and (2) do not apply, an amount | |
| that does not exceed 150 percent of the median amount paid by | |
| nongovernmental third-party payors to health care providers for the | |
| same types of services provided to the injured individual during | |
| the month in which the services were provided, as drawn from the | |
| database for the geozip: | |
| (A) in which the services were provided, if the | |
| services were provided in this state; or | |
| (B) in which The University of Texas Health | |
| Science Center at Houston is located, if the services were provided | |
| outside of this state. | |
| (b) In addition to any other limitation provided by law, | |
| economic damages awarded for health care expenses that in | |
| reasonable probability can be expected to be incurred by the | |
| injured individual in the future because of the injury-causing | |
| event shall be limited to the reasonable value of necessary | |
| services, determined in the manner provided by Subsection (a)(3) | |
| for determination of past health care expenses, except that the | |
| determination must use data from the database for the month | |
| preceding the date the trial commenced. | |
| (c) Health care provider statements or invoices presented | |
| for purposes of Subsection (a) or (b) must be in a form that would | |
| comply with the clean claim requirements of Chapter 1301, Insurance | |
| Code. If a service does not have an industry-recognized billing | |
| code, no amount of money may be awarded to the claimant for that | |
| service. | |
| (d) The failure of the injured individual to use available | |
| health benefit coverage shall be considered a failure to mitigate | |
| damages. | |
| Sec. 41.105. CLAIMANT DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS. (a) In | |
| addition to other items required to be provided by law, in an action | |
| to which this subchapter applies, the claimant shall provide to | |
| each other party a copy of: | |
| (1) all statements or invoices generated by health | |
| care providers showing health care services provided to the injured | |
| individual because of the injury-causing event that is the basis | |
| for the action; | |
| (2) any letter of protection related to the action; | |
| and | |
| (3) any written agreement under which a provider may | |
| refund, rebate, or remit money to a payor, injured individual, | |
| claimant, claimant's attorney, or person associated with the payor, | |
| injured individual, claimant, or claimant's attorney. | |
| (b) In a civil action to which this subchapter applies, the | |
| claimant shall, in addition to other requirements of law: | |
| (1) identify any provider who provided health care | |
| services to the injured individual in relation to the injury caused | |
| to the injured individual in the event giving rise to the action and | |
| provide an authorization to all other parties to the case that will | |
| allow those parties to obtain from the provider all of the injured | |
| individual's medical records; | |
| (2) identify any third-party payor that may have had a | |
| legal or contractual obligation to pay for health care services | |
| provided to the injured individual, regardless of whether the third | |
| party was legally or contractually obligated to pay for the | |
| specific services provided to the injured individual; | |
| (3) disclose any unwritten agreement under which a | |
| provider may refund, rebate, or remit money to a payor, injured | |
| individual, claimant, claimant's attorney, or person associated | |
| with the payor, injured individual, claimant, or claimant's | |
| attorney; and | |
| (4) if the injured individual was referred to a | |
| provider for services, disclose: | |
| (A) the name, address, and telephone number of | |
| the person who made the referral, regardless of whether that person | |
| is the injured individual's attorney; | |
| (B) if the person making the referral was not the | |
| injured individual's attorney, the relationship between the person | |
| making the referral and the injured individual or the injured | |
| individual's attorney; and | |
| (C) if the person making the referral was the | |
| injured individual's attorney: | |
| (i) an anonymized list of persons referred | |
| by the attorney to the provider in the preceding two years; | |
| (ii) the date and amount of each payment | |
| made to the provider in the preceding two years by or at the | |
| direction of the attorney; | |
| (iii) if applicable, each person | |
| anonymously described under Subparagraph (i) on whose behalf a | |
| payment described by Subparagraph (ii) was made; and | |
| (iv) other aspects of any financial | |
| relationship between the attorney and the provider. | |
| (c) For purposes of Subsection (b)(4)(C), a referral is | |
| considered to have been made by the injured individual's attorney | |
| even if made by another person when the injured individual's | |
| attorney knew or had reason to know that the referral would be made. | |
| Sec. 41.106. CLAIMANT'S OBLIGATION OF PROOF NOT AFFECTED. | |
| Nothing in this subchapter affects the claimant's obligation to | |
| prove that the health care services provided to the injured | |
| individual were necessary and causally connected to a defendant's | |
| acts or omissions. | |
| Sec. 41.107. MATTERS ADMISSIBLE INTO EVIDENCE. In an | |
| action to which this subchapter applies, the following matters are | |
| admissible into evidence by any party: | |
| (1) a document or information provided, disclosed, or | |
| obtained under Section 41.105(a) or (b); | |
| (2) an injured individual's health care expenses | |
| incurred as a result of the injury-causing event, regardless of | |
| whether the claimant seeks to recover health care expenses in the | |
| action; | |
| (3) evidence of health benefit plan coverage that is | |
| available to the injured individual to pay for past or future health | |
| care services; and | |
| (4) treatment guidelines and drug formularies | |
| approved by the Workers' Compensation Division of the Texas | |
| Department of Insurance as evidence relating to the necessity of | |
| health care services provided to the injured individual. | |
| SUBCHAPTER D. NONECONOMIC DAMAGES | |
| Sec. 41.151. STANDARDS FOR RECOVERY OF CERTAIN NONECONOMIC | |
| DAMAGES. (a) Damages for physical pain and suffering or for mental | |
| or emotional pain or anguish may be awarded only if the trier of | |
| fact is unanimous in finding the amount of money that will fairly | |
| and reasonably compensate the claimant for those injuries. | |
| (b) An award of damages for physical pain and suffering or | |
| mental or emotional pain or anguish: | |
| (1) must provide fair and reasonable compensation to a | |
| claimant for the claimant's injury for the period of time the pain, | |
| suffering, or anguish has persisted or reasonably can be expected | |
| to persist in the future; | |
| (2) must be based on evidence of the nature, duration, | |
| and severity of the injury and reflect a rational connection, | |
| grounded in the evidence, between the injury suffered and the | |
| dollar amount necessary to provide fair and reasonable compensation | |
| to a claimant; | |
| (3) may not be used to penalize or punish a defendant, | |
| make an example to others, or serve a social good; and | |
| (4) may not include amounts that are properly | |
| considered economic losses, such as lost earnings caused by | |
| physical impairment or medical expenses incurred for emotional or | |
| psychological care. | |
| (c) In an action to which this chapter applies, it is | |
| reversible error for a court to allow an attorney, witness, or other | |
| person through argument, the introduction of evidence, or otherwise | |
| to: | |
| (1) state or suggest that the trier of fact should | |
| determine the amount of damages to award to a claimant for physical | |
| pain and suffering or mental or emotional pain or anguish by | |
| referring to objects, values, or repeating metrics having no | |
| rational connection to the facts of the case; or | |
| (2) characterize an award of damages for physical pain | |
| and suffering or mental or emotional pain or anguish as | |
| establishing a valuation of human life. | |
| (d) Except to the extent of a conflict, this section | |
| supplements court decisions and rules of procedure and evidence. | |
| Sec. 41.152. JURY INSTRUCTIONS. In a trial to a jury in | |
| which noneconomic damages are sought, the court shall provide the | |
| jury definitions and instructions required by this chapter and | |
| other law and ask the jury, if appropriate, to determine the amount | |
| of money that will fairly and reasonably compensate the claimant | |
| for: | |
| (1) past physical pain and suffering; | |
| (2) future physical pain and suffering; | |
| (3) past mental or emotional pain or anguish; | |
| (4) future mental or emotional pain or anguish; | |
| (5) past injury to reputation; and | |
| (6) future injury to reputation. | |
| Sec. 41.153. MOTION TO REMIT NONECONOMIC DAMAGES IN CERTAIN | |
| ACTIONS. (a) Except in an action in which another law limits | |
| recovery of noneconomic damages, in a trial to a jury in a personal | |
| injury or wrongful death action, a trial court shall state the legal | |
| and factual support for the amount of noneconomic damages awarded | |
| to a claimant in a judgment if a defendant requests remittitur of | |
| noneconomic damages awarded to the claimant and the award exceeds: | |
| (1) $1 million for past and future mental or emotional | |
| pain or anguish in a wrongful death action; | |
| (2) for past and future damages for physical pain and | |
| suffering in a personal injury action, the lesser of: | |
| (A) three times the amount awarded for past and | |
| future health care expenses; or | |
| (B) $100,000 per year for each year of the | |
| claimant's life expectancy; | |
| (3) $1 million for past and future mental or emotional | |
| pain or anguish in a personal injury action arising from an event | |
| primarily causing emotional injury to a claimant; or | |
| (4) $250,000 for past and future mental or emotional | |
| pain or anguish in a personal injury action arising from an event | |
| primarily causing bodily injury to the claimant. | |
| (b) In a statement of legal support for the amount of | |
| noneconomic damages awarded in the judgment, the court shall | |
| include references to judgments rendered in this state and affirmed | |
| on appeal of comparable amounts awarded under comparable facts. | |
| SECTION 9. Section 304.102, Finance Code, is amended to | |
| read as follows: | |
| Sec. 304.102. PREJUDGMENT INTEREST REQUIRED IN CERTAIN | |
| CASES. A judgment in a wrongful death, personal injury, or property | |
| damage case earns prejudgment interest on amounts awarded in the | |
| judgment for economic losses, calculated from the date: | |
| (1) the health care expenses are actually paid by the | |
| claimant, if applicable; or | |
| (2) other economic losses are actually suffered by the | |
| claimant. | |
| SECTION 10. Sections 18.001(f) and (g), Civil Practice and | |
| Remedies Code, are repealed. | |
| SECTION 11. The changes in law made by this Act apply only | |
| to an action commenced on or after the effective date of this Act. | |
| An action commenced before the effective date of this Act is | |
| governed by the law applicable to the action immediately before the | |
| effective date of this Act, and that law is continued in effect for | |
| that purpose. | |
| SECTION 12. This Act takes effect immediately if it | |
| receives a vote of two-thirds of all the members elected to each | |
| house, as provided by Section 39, Article III, Texas Constitution. | |
| If this Act does not receive the vote necessary for immediate | |
| effect, this Act takes effect September 1, 2025. |
Texto oficial de la Legislatura de Texas. El formato se adaptó para leerlo en Ratifi.