Printer's No. PN2451
See other bills
under the
same topic PRINTER'S NO. 2451 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIAHOUSE BILL No.1942 Session of 2025 INTRODUCED BY BURGOS, KINKEAD, GUZMAN, HILL-EVANS, RIVERA, HOHENSTEIN, STEELE, BOROWSKI, HADDOCK, SANCHEZ, CEPEDA-FREYTIZ, MERSKI, GALLAGHER, GREEN AND CIRESI, OCTOBER 14, 2025 REFERRED TO COMMITTEE ON CONSUMER PROTECTION, TECHNOLOGY AND UTILITIES, OCTOBER 16, 2025 AN ACTProviding for prohibition on surveillance pricing; and imposing penalties.The General Assembly finds and declares as follows:(1) A recent study documented how businesses are aggressively and secretly engaging in surveillance of their customers and secretly varying prices between customers or groups accordingly. The study documented the following surveillance-based pricing practices:(i) Orbitz learned that Mac users typically spend more money to stay at hotels and steered those users toward different, sometimes costlier, travel options than non-Mac users.(ii) Hotel booking sites charged people in certain zip codes more money to stay at hotels than people in other zip codes across the country. In one example, a person in the Bay area was charged by Hotels.com $80 more 12345678910111213141516 to stay in a New York City hotel than someone browsing for the same room from Kansas City.(iii) Staples.com charged people more for the same stapler if they knew a person had fewer options such as not being physically near a competitor.(iv) Target charged people more for its products when they were in a Target parking lot versus when they were in another location because the company determined people who were near a store entrance were willing to pay more. As a result, prices spiked for a television, a smart watch, a vacuum and a child car seat once consumers had arrived in a store parking lot.(v) Test preparation company The Princeton Review charged customers more money when it found that they lived in zip codes with large Asian populations.(2) Corporate consultants have told clients that surveillance-based pricing strategies "have become a cornerstone of modern business strategy." Profit margins are improved by two to seven percentage points when surveillance pricing is implemented, according to McKinsey and Company. A Yale study found surveillance-based pricing increased profits for airlines by 4% to 5%.(3) Other studies document that surveillance pricing impacts lower-income people the most. A study of broadband Internet offers to 1,100,000 residential addresses showed the worst deals given to the poorest people. Areas with discounted prices tended to have a higher average income than areas that tended to see higher prices.(4) Personalized or surveillance-based pricing technologies could permit large grocery store chains to 20250HB1942PN2451 - 2 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 impose unfair and discriminatory prices on their customers for basic food necessities in ways that might increase the economic burdens of those already subject to discrimination or economic hardships.(5) Recent reports have raised the possibility that publicly traded grocery store chains, including the dozens of grocery brands under Kroger's corporate umbrella, are concurrently installing facial recognition and other biometric technologies and adopting electronic shelving labels. Together, these technologies could allow grocery retailers to distinguish between customers based on race, gender, disability, distance traveled to the store, age and electronically stored personal information in real time and price food differently based on individualized profiling.(6) Legislation is required to fairly and compassionately restrain the deployment and use of unfair, discriminatory, privacy-invading technologies that, if deployed in ways contrary to the public interest and welfare, will dramatically exacerbate gaps between wealthy and working families to the unneeded benefit of the former and the enduring, unjust harm of the latter.The General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania hereby enacts as follows:Section 1. Short title.This act shall be known and may be cited as the Surveillance Pricing Act.Section 2. Definitions.The following words and phrases when used in this act shall have the meanings given to them in this section unless the context clearly indicates otherwise:20250HB1942PN2451 - 3 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 "Electronic surveillance technology." A technological method or system of surveillance used to observe, monitor or collect information related to a person, including the following:(1) Actions, habits, race, religion, residence, sexuality or preferences.(2) Interests, including the individual's political, personal or professional affiliation.(3) Web-browsing history, purchase history, financial circumstances or consumer behaviors.(4) Personally identifiable information."Person." A natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative or other organization."Personally identifiable information." The term shall have the same meaning as "personal information" as defined in section 2 of the act of December 22, 2005 (P.L.474, No.94), known as the Breach of Personal Information Notification Act."Surveillance pricing." Offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers based, in whole or in part, on personally identifiable information collected through electronic surveillance technology. The term includes the use of technological methods, systems or tools, including, but not limited to:(1) Sensors.(2) Cameras.(3) Device tracking.(4) Biometric monitoring.(5) Other forms of observation or data collection that are capable of gathering personally identifiable information about:20250HB1942PN2451 - 4 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (i) A consumer's behavior and characteristics.(ii) The location or other personal attributes of a consumer, whether in physical or digital environments.Section 3. Prohibition on surveillance pricing.(a) Prohibition.--Except as provided in subsection (b), a person shall not engage in surveillance pricing.(b) Exception.--A person does not engage in surveillance pricing if any of the following apply:(1) The difference in price is based solely on costs associated with providing the good or service to different consumers.(2) A discounted price is offered based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, including, but not limited to:(i) signing up for a mailing list;(ii) registering for promotional communications; or(iii) participating in a promotional event.(3) A discounted price is offered to members of a broadly defined group based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, including, but not limited to:(i) teachers;(ii) active or retired military;(iii) senior citizens;(iv) students; or(v) residents of a certain area.(4) A discounted price is offered through a loyalty, membership or rewards program that consumers affirmatively purchase or enroll in, based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria.(5) The person operates as an insurer as defined in 40 20250HB1942PN2451 - 5 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 Pa.C.S. § 4502 (relating to definitions) and the pricing is in connection with the activity.(c) Consumer report.--A person is not in violation of this act if the information used in surveillance pricing is based on information contained in a consumer report as defined in 15 U.S.C. § 1681a(d) (relating to definitions; rules of construction) or a commercial credit report, and the use relates to:(1) the pricing or specific terms for extending credit;(2) entering into a transaction with a specific consumer; or(3) a specific commercial enterprise.(d) Requirements.--A discounted price or reward offered under subsection (b)(2), (3), (4) or (5) that collects personally identifiable information shall:(1) Clearly and conspicuously disclose any eligibility criteria, available discounts and conditions for receiving or earning the discount or reward before any personally identifiable information is collected.(2) Be uniformly offered or made available to all consumers who meet the disclosed eligibility criteria.(3) Not be augmented or supplemented by personally identifiable information obtained from a third party or other means.(e) Personal information.--Any personally identifiable information collected under subsection (b) shall be used solely for the purpose of offering or administering the applicable discount, cost-based pricing or loyalty program and shall not be used for any other purpose, including profiling or individualized price setting.20250HB1942PN2451 - 6 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (f) Construction.--Nothing in this act shall be construed to allow any insurance company to engage in conduct that violates any provision of 40 Pa.C.S. (relating to insurance).Section 4. Penalties.(a) Actions.--Except as provided under subsection (b), actions under this act may only be brought by the Attorney General or a district attorney as follows:(1) In addition to any other remedy at law, a person that violates this act shall be liable for the following civil penalties, which shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought under this subsection:(i) A civil penalty not to exceed $12,500 for each violation, with each violation of this act constituting a separate violation with respect to each consumer or transaction involved.(ii) For an intentional violation of this act, a civil penalty no greater than three times the amount of the penalty assessed under subparagraph (i) in addition to all revenues earned from the violation.(2) A prevailing plaintiff in an action brought under this section shall be awarded reasonable attorney fees and applicable court costs.(3) In addition to seeking civil penalties and other monetary relief, a court may award injunctive or declaratory relief as necessary to enforce this act and to remedy any violation of law.(b) Civil action by consumer.--A consumer may bring an action for injunctive relief as necessary to enforce this act and to remedy any violation of law. A prevailing plaintiff in an action brought under this subsection shall be awarded reasonable 20250HB1942PN2451 - 7 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 attorney fees and applicable court costs.Section 5. Waiver.Any waiver of this act is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.Section 6. Interaction with other laws.The rights, remedies and penalties established by this act are cumulative and shall not be construed to supersede the rights, remedies or penalties established under other laws, including, but not limited to, the act of December 17, 1968 (P.L.1224, No.387), known as the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law.Section 7. Effective date.This act shall take effect in 60 days.20250HB1942PN2451 - 8 - 12345678910111213
under the
same topic PRINTER'S NO. 2451 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIAHOUSE BILL No.1942 Session of 2025 INTRODUCED BY BURGOS, KINKEAD, GUZMAN, HILL-EVANS, RIVERA, HOHENSTEIN, STEELE, BOROWSKI, HADDOCK, SANCHEZ, CEPEDA-FREYTIZ, MERSKI, GALLAGHER, GREEN AND CIRESI, OCTOBER 14, 2025 REFERRED TO COMMITTEE ON CONSUMER PROTECTION, TECHNOLOGY AND UTILITIES, OCTOBER 16, 2025 AN ACTProviding for prohibition on surveillance pricing; and imposing penalties.The General Assembly finds and declares as follows:(1) A recent study documented how businesses are aggressively and secretly engaging in surveillance of their customers and secretly varying prices between customers or groups accordingly. The study documented the following surveillance-based pricing practices:(i) Orbitz learned that Mac users typically spend more money to stay at hotels and steered those users toward different, sometimes costlier, travel options than non-Mac users.(ii) Hotel booking sites charged people in certain zip codes more money to stay at hotels than people in other zip codes across the country. In one example, a person in the Bay area was charged by Hotels.com $80 more 12345678910111213141516 to stay in a New York City hotel than someone browsing for the same room from Kansas City.(iii) Staples.com charged people more for the same stapler if they knew a person had fewer options such as not being physically near a competitor.(iv) Target charged people more for its products when they were in a Target parking lot versus when they were in another location because the company determined people who were near a store entrance were willing to pay more. As a result, prices spiked for a television, a smart watch, a vacuum and a child car seat once consumers had arrived in a store parking lot.(v) Test preparation company The Princeton Review charged customers more money when it found that they lived in zip codes with large Asian populations.(2) Corporate consultants have told clients that surveillance-based pricing strategies "have become a cornerstone of modern business strategy." Profit margins are improved by two to seven percentage points when surveillance pricing is implemented, according to McKinsey and Company. A Yale study found surveillance-based pricing increased profits for airlines by 4% to 5%.(3) Other studies document that surveillance pricing impacts lower-income people the most. A study of broadband Internet offers to 1,100,000 residential addresses showed the worst deals given to the poorest people. Areas with discounted prices tended to have a higher average income than areas that tended to see higher prices.(4) Personalized or surveillance-based pricing technologies could permit large grocery store chains to 20250HB1942PN2451 - 2 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 impose unfair and discriminatory prices on their customers for basic food necessities in ways that might increase the economic burdens of those already subject to discrimination or economic hardships.(5) Recent reports have raised the possibility that publicly traded grocery store chains, including the dozens of grocery brands under Kroger's corporate umbrella, are concurrently installing facial recognition and other biometric technologies and adopting electronic shelving labels. Together, these technologies could allow grocery retailers to distinguish between customers based on race, gender, disability, distance traveled to the store, age and electronically stored personal information in real time and price food differently based on individualized profiling.(6) Legislation is required to fairly and compassionately restrain the deployment and use of unfair, discriminatory, privacy-invading technologies that, if deployed in ways contrary to the public interest and welfare, will dramatically exacerbate gaps between wealthy and working families to the unneeded benefit of the former and the enduring, unjust harm of the latter.The General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania hereby enacts as follows:Section 1. Short title.This act shall be known and may be cited as the Surveillance Pricing Act.Section 2. Definitions.The following words and phrases when used in this act shall have the meanings given to them in this section unless the context clearly indicates otherwise:20250HB1942PN2451 - 3 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 "Electronic surveillance technology." A technological method or system of surveillance used to observe, monitor or collect information related to a person, including the following:(1) Actions, habits, race, religion, residence, sexuality or preferences.(2) Interests, including the individual's political, personal or professional affiliation.(3) Web-browsing history, purchase history, financial circumstances or consumer behaviors.(4) Personally identifiable information."Person." A natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative or other organization."Personally identifiable information." The term shall have the same meaning as "personal information" as defined in section 2 of the act of December 22, 2005 (P.L.474, No.94), known as the Breach of Personal Information Notification Act."Surveillance pricing." Offering or setting a customized price for a good or service for a specific consumer or group of consumers based, in whole or in part, on personally identifiable information collected through electronic surveillance technology. The term includes the use of technological methods, systems or tools, including, but not limited to:(1) Sensors.(2) Cameras.(3) Device tracking.(4) Biometric monitoring.(5) Other forms of observation or data collection that are capable of gathering personally identifiable information about:20250HB1942PN2451 - 4 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (i) A consumer's behavior and characteristics.(ii) The location or other personal attributes of a consumer, whether in physical or digital environments.Section 3. Prohibition on surveillance pricing.(a) Prohibition.--Except as provided in subsection (b), a person shall not engage in surveillance pricing.(b) Exception.--A person does not engage in surveillance pricing if any of the following apply:(1) The difference in price is based solely on costs associated with providing the good or service to different consumers.(2) A discounted price is offered based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, including, but not limited to:(i) signing up for a mailing list;(ii) registering for promotional communications; or(iii) participating in a promotional event.(3) A discounted price is offered to members of a broadly defined group based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, including, but not limited to:(i) teachers;(ii) active or retired military;(iii) senior citizens;(iv) students; or(v) residents of a certain area.(4) A discounted price is offered through a loyalty, membership or rewards program that consumers affirmatively purchase or enroll in, based on publicly disclosed eligibility criteria.(5) The person operates as an insurer as defined in 40 20250HB1942PN2451 - 5 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 Pa.C.S. § 4502 (relating to definitions) and the pricing is in connection with the activity.(c) Consumer report.--A person is not in violation of this act if the information used in surveillance pricing is based on information contained in a consumer report as defined in 15 U.S.C. § 1681a(d) (relating to definitions; rules of construction) or a commercial credit report, and the use relates to:(1) the pricing or specific terms for extending credit;(2) entering into a transaction with a specific consumer; or(3) a specific commercial enterprise.(d) Requirements.--A discounted price or reward offered under subsection (b)(2), (3), (4) or (5) that collects personally identifiable information shall:(1) Clearly and conspicuously disclose any eligibility criteria, available discounts and conditions for receiving or earning the discount or reward before any personally identifiable information is collected.(2) Be uniformly offered or made available to all consumers who meet the disclosed eligibility criteria.(3) Not be augmented or supplemented by personally identifiable information obtained from a third party or other means.(e) Personal information.--Any personally identifiable information collected under subsection (b) shall be used solely for the purpose of offering or administering the applicable discount, cost-based pricing or loyalty program and shall not be used for any other purpose, including profiling or individualized price setting.20250HB1942PN2451 - 6 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (f) Construction.--Nothing in this act shall be construed to allow any insurance company to engage in conduct that violates any provision of 40 Pa.C.S. (relating to insurance).Section 4. Penalties.(a) Actions.--Except as provided under subsection (b), actions under this act may only be brought by the Attorney General or a district attorney as follows:(1) In addition to any other remedy at law, a person that violates this act shall be liable for the following civil penalties, which shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought under this subsection:(i) A civil penalty not to exceed $12,500 for each violation, with each violation of this act constituting a separate violation with respect to each consumer or transaction involved.(ii) For an intentional violation of this act, a civil penalty no greater than three times the amount of the penalty assessed under subparagraph (i) in addition to all revenues earned from the violation.(2) A prevailing plaintiff in an action brought under this section shall be awarded reasonable attorney fees and applicable court costs.(3) In addition to seeking civil penalties and other monetary relief, a court may award injunctive or declaratory relief as necessary to enforce this act and to remedy any violation of law.(b) Civil action by consumer.--A consumer may bring an action for injunctive relief as necessary to enforce this act and to remedy any violation of law. A prevailing plaintiff in an action brought under this subsection shall be awarded reasonable 20250HB1942PN2451 - 7 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 attorney fees and applicable court costs.Section 5. Waiver.Any waiver of this act is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.Section 6. Interaction with other laws.The rights, remedies and penalties established by this act are cumulative and shall not be construed to supersede the rights, remedies or penalties established under other laws, including, but not limited to, the act of December 17, 1968 (P.L.1224, No.387), known as the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law.Section 7. Effective date.This act shall take effect in 60 days.20250HB1942PN2451 - 8 - 12345678910111213
Texto oficial de la Legislatura de Pennsylvania. El formato se adaptó para leerlo en Ratifi.