Florida Senate
-
2026
CS for SB 1422
By
the Committee on Environment and Natural Resources; and
SenatorSenators Garcia and Jones
36-01104A-26592-02472-26 20261422__20261422c1
1 A bill to be entitled
2 An act relating to surfacecoral watersreefs; amending s. 403.93345,
3 373.414, F.S.; requiringrevising thelegislative Departmentfindings; ofproviding a
4 Environmental Protection to incorporate habitat
5 equivalency analysis in the uniform mitigation
6 assessment method; defining the term “habitat
7 equivalency analysis”; amending s. 403.811, F.S.;
8 requiring that permits for dredging and filling
94 includelegislative certain requirementsdesignation; requiringproviding thean departmenteffective date.
10 to adopt rules; requiring permitted entities to bear
11 the full cost and responsibility for any damage or
5
6 Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:
7
8 Section 1. Present subsections (5) through (12) of section
9 403.93345, Florida Statutes, are redesignated as subsections (6)
10 through (13), respectively, a new subsection (5) is added to
11 that section, and subsection (4) and present subsections (7) and
12 destruction (8) causedof bythat dredgingsection are amended, filling,to or relatedread:
13 activities; amending s. 403.93345, Coral Freef protection.S.; revising—
14 legislative findings; providing a legislative
15 designation; reenacting s. 373.4137(2)(b) and (4),
16 F.S., relating to mitigation requirements for
17 specified transportation projects, to incorporate the
18 amendment made to s. 373.414, F.S., in a reference
19 thereto; providing an effective date.
20
21 Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:
22
23 Section 1. Paragraph (a) of subsection (18) of section
24 373.414, Florida Statutes, is amended to read:
25 373.414 Additional criteria for activities in surface
26 waters and wetlands.—
27 (18) The department and each water management district
28 responsible for implementation of the environmental resource
29 permitting program shall develop a uniform mitigation assessment
30 method for wetlands and other surface waters. The department
31 shall adopt the uniform mitigation assessment method by rule no
32 later than July 31, 2002. The rule shall provide an exclusive
33 and consistent process for determining the amount of mitigation
34 required to offset impacts to wetlands and other surface waters,
35 and, once effective, shall supersede all rules, ordinances, and
36 variance procedures from ordinances that determine the amount of
37 mitigation needed to offset such impacts. Once the department
38 adopts the uniform mitigation assessment method by rule, the
39 uniform mitigation assessment method shall be binding on the
40 department, the water management districts, local governments,
41 and any other governmental agencies and shall be the sole means
42 to determine the amount of mitigation needed to offset adverse
43 impacts to wetlands and other surface waters and to award and
44 deduct mitigation bank credits. A water management district and
45 any other governmental agency subject to chapter 120 may apply
46 the uniform mitigation assessment method without the need to
47 adopt it pursuant to s. 120.54. It shall be a goal of the
48 department and water management districts that the uniform
49 mitigation assessment method developed be practicable for use
50 within the timeframes provided in the permitting process and
51 result in a consistent process for determining mitigation
52 requirements. It shall be recognized that any such method shall
53 require the application of reasonable scientific judgment. The
54 uniform mitigation assessment method must determine the value of
55 functions provided by wetlands and other surface waters
56 considering the current conditions of these areas, utilization
57 by fish and wildlife, location, uniqueness, and hydrologic
58 connection, and, when applied to mitigation banks, the factors
59 listed in s. 373.4136(4). The uniform mitigation assessment
60 method shall also account for the expected time-lag associated
61 with offsetting impacts and the degree of risk associated with
62 the proposed mitigation. The uniform mitigation assessment
63 method shall account for different ecological communities in
64 different areas of the state. In developing the uniform
65 mitigation assessment method, the department and water
66 management districts shall consult with approved local programs
67 under s. 403.182 which have an established mitigation program
68 for wetlands or other surface waters. The department and water
69 management districts shall consider the recommendations
70 submitted by such approved local programs, including any
71 recommendations relating to the adoption by the department and
72 water management districts of any uniform mitigation methodology
73 that has been adopted and used by an approved local program in
74 its established mitigation program for wetlands or other surface
75 waters. Environmental resource permitting rules may establish
76 categories of permits or thresholds for minor impacts under
77 which the use of the uniform mitigation assessment method will
78 not be required. The application of the uniform mitigation
79 assessment method is not subject to s. 70.001. In the event the
80 rule establishing the uniform mitigation assessment method is
81 deemed to be invalid, the applicable rules related to
82 establishing needed mitigation in existence prior to the
83 adoption of the uniform mitigation assessment method, including
84 those adopted by a county which is an approved local program
85 under s. 403.182, and the method described in paragraph (b) for
86 existing mitigation banks, shall be authorized for use by the
87 department, water management districts, local governments, and
88 other state agencies.
89 (a) In developing the uniform mitigation assessment method,
90 the department shall
:
91
1.
Seek input from the United States Army Corps of
92 Engineers in order to promote consistency in the mitigation
93 assessment methods used by the state and federal permitting
94 programs.
95
2.
Incorporate habitat equivalency analysis. As used in
96
this paragraph, the term “habitat equivalency analysis” means a
97
type of methodology used to determine how much restoration is
98
necessary to compensate for adverse impacts.
99 Section 2. Section 403.811, Florida Statutes, is amended to
100 read:
101 403.811 Dredge and fill permits issued pursuant to this
102 chapter and s. 373.414.—
103
(1)
Permits or other orders addressing dredging and filling
104 in, on, or over waters of the state issued pursuant to this
105 chapter or s. 373.414(9) before the effective date of rules
106 adopted under s. 373.414(9) and permits or other orders issued
107 in accordance with s. 373.414(13), (14), (15), or (16) shall
108 remain valid through the duration specified in the permit or
109 order, unless revoked by the agency issuing the permit. The
110 agency issuing the permit or other order may seek to enjoin the
111 violation of, or to enforce compliance with, the permit or other
112 order as provided in ss. 403.121, 403.131, 403.141, and 403.161.
113 A violation of a permit or other order addressing dredging or
114 filling issued pursuant to this chapter is punishable by a civil
115 penalty as provided in s. 403.141 or a criminal penalty as
116 provided in s. 403.161.
117
(2)
Permits for dredging and filling must include a
118
requirement that dredging and turbidity monitoring be performed
119
by separate and distinct entities. The department shall adopt
120
rules to implement this subsection.
121
(3)
Permitted entities shall bear the full cost of and
122
responsibility for any damage or destruction caused by dredging,
123
filling, or related activities.
124 Section 3. Present subsections (5) through (12) of section
125 403.93345, Florida Statutes, are redesignated as subsections (6)
126 through (13), respectively, and a new subsection (5) is added,
127 and present subsection (4) is amended to read:
128 403.93345 Coral reef protection.—
12914 (4)
(a)
The Legislature finds that coral reefs are valuable
13015 natural resources that contribute ecologically, aesthetically,
13116 and economically to the state. Therefore, the Legislature
13217 declares it is in the best interest of the state to clarify the
13318 department’s powers and authority to protect coral reefs through
13419 timely and efficient recovery of monetary damages resulting from
13520 vessel groundings and anchoring-related injuries.
136
21
(b)
The Legislature further finds that coral reefs, ifcan help
137
healthy
and
effectively managed, can help mitigate the risks and
138
22
mitigate the risks and related loss and damage from floods,
,
climate change
,
and natural
139
disasters.
The Legislature recognizes that
s
tudies have shown
140
that healthy coral
reefs
can
23
climate change, and natural disasters. The Legislature
24
recognizes that studies have shown that healthy coral reefs can
25
protect coastal properties from climate change-related risks and
141
such
climate change
-
related risks and disaster events
,
including
142
26
disaster events, including storms, high wave events, sea level rise, and flooding.
The
143
27
rise, and flooding. The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) is responsible for
144
28
(FEMA) is responsible for responding to natural disasters and providing technical and
145
29
providing technical and financial hazard mitigation support,
,
30
primarily distributed as grant funding through FEMA’s hazard
146
grant funding through FEMA’s hazard mitigation assistance
147
programs.
31
mitigation assistance programs. Coral reef restoration for risk reduction, known as
148
32
reduction, known as CR4, is an active restoration strategy with the aim of
149
33
the aim of increasing the structural integrity and complexity of coral reef
150
34
coral reef ecosystems to attenuate wave energy and reduce coastal flooding.
151
35
coastal flooding. Legislative recognition of coral reefs as critical natural
152
infrastructure
and a nature
-
based solution
demonstrates
153
36
critical natural infrastructure and a nature-based solution
37
demonstrates political support for nature-based solutions.
154
38
(c)
It is the intent of the Legislature that the department
15539 be recognized as the state’s lead trustee for coral reef
15640 resources located within waters of the state or on sovereignty
15741 submerged lands unless preempted by federal law. This section
15842 does not divest other state agencies and political subdivisions
15943 of the state of their interests in protecting coral reefs.
160
44
(5)
The Legislature designates coral reefs as critical
161
45
natural infrastructure and as a nature-based solution that helps
as a
nature
-
based solution that help
s
162
46
mitigate climate change-related risks and disaster events,
,
163
including
,
47
exposure toincluding storms, high wave events, sea level rise, and
164
and flooding.
165 Section 4. For the purpose of incorporating the amendment
166 made by this act to section 373.414, Florida Statutes, in a
167 reference thereto, paragraph (b) of subsection (2) and
168 subsection (4) of section 373.4137, Florida Statutes, are
169 reenacted to read:
170 373.4137 Mitigation requirements for specified
171 transportation projects.—
172 (2) Environmental impact inventories for transportation
173 projects proposed by the Department of Transportation or a
174 transportation authority established pursuant to chapter 348 or
175 chapter 349 shall be developed as follows:
176 (b) The environmental impact inventory must include a
177 description of habitat impacts, including location, acreage, and
178 type; the anticipated mitigation needed based on the functional
179 loss as determined through the uniform mitigation assessment
180 method adopted by the Department of Environmental Protection by
181 rule pursuant to s. 373.414(18); identification of the proposed
182 mitigation option; state water quality classification of
183 impacted wetlands and other surface waters; any other state or
184 regional designations for these habitats; and a list of
185 threatened species, endangered species, and species of special
186 concern affected by the proposed project.
187 (4) Before March 1 of each year, each water management
188 district shall develop a mitigation plan to offset only the
189 impacts of transportation projects in the environmental impact
190 inventory for which a water management district is implementing
191 mitigation that meets the requirements of this section, 33
192 U.S.C. s. 1344, and 33 C.F.R. part 332. The water management
193 district mitigation plan must be developed in consultation with
194 the Department of Environmental Protection, the United States
195 Army Corps of Engineers, the Department of Transportation,
196 participating transportation authorities established pursuant to
197 chapter 348 or chapter 349, other appropriate federal, state,
198 and local governments, and other interested parties, including
199 entities operating mitigation banks. In developing such plans,
200 the water management districts shall use sound ecosystem
201 management practices to address significant water resource needs
202 and consider activities of the Department of Environmental
203 Protection and the water management districts, such as surface
204 water improvement and management (SWIM) projects and lands
205 identified for potential acquisition for preservation,
48
flooding. As such, the Legislature further designates the
49
206 restorationprotection of corals, orcoral enhancementreefs, and thecoral control of invasive andreef-associated
207 exotic plants in wetlands and other surface waters, to the
208 extent that the activities comply with the mitigation
209 requirements adopted under this part, 33 U.S.C. s. 1344, and 33
210 C.F.R. part 332. The water management district mitigation plan
211 must identify each site where the water management district will
212 mitigate for a transportation project. For each mitigation site,
213 the water management district shall provide the scope of the
214 mitigation services; provide the functional gain as determined
215 through the uniform mitigation assessment method adopted by the
216 Department of Environmental Protection by rule pursuant to s.
217 373.414(18); describe how the mitigation offsets the impacts of
218 each transportation project as permitted; and provide a schedule
219 for the mitigation services. The water management districts
220 shall maintain records of costs incurred and payments received
221 for providing these services. Records must include, but are not
222 limited to, planning, land acquisition, design, construction,
223 staff support, long-term maintenance and monitoring of the
224 mitigation site, and other costs necessary to meet the
225 requirements of 33 U.S.C. s. 1344 and 33 C.F.R. part 332. To the
226 extent moneys paid to a water management district by the
227 Department of Transportation or a participating transportation
228 authority are greater than the amount spent by the water
229 management districts in providing the mitigation services to
230 offset the permitted transportation project impacts, these
231 moneys must be refunded to the Department of Transportation or
232 participating transportation authority. The mitigation plan
233 shall be submitted to the water management district governing
234 board or its designee for review and approval. At least 14 days
235 before approval by the governing board, the water management
236 district shall provide a copy of the draft mitigation plan to
237 the Department of Environmental Protection and any person who
238 has requested a copy. Subsequent to the governing board
239 approval, the mitigation plan shall be submitted to the
240 Department of Environmental Protection for approval. The plan
241 may not be implemented until it is submitted to, and approved in
242 part or in its entirety by, the Department of Environmental
243 Protection.
244 (a) Specific projects may be excluded from the mitigation
245 plan, in whole or in part, and are not subject to this section
246 upon the election of the Department of Transportation, a
247 transportation authority if applicable, or the appropriate water
248 management district. The Department of Transportation or a
249 participating transportation authority may not exclude a
250 transportation project from the mitigation plan if mitigation is
251 scheduled for implementation by the water management district in
252 the current fiscal year unless the transportation project is
253 removed from the Department of Transportation’s work program or
254 transportation authority funding plan, the mitigation cannot be
255 timely permitted to offset the impacts of a Department of
256 Transportation project identified in the environmental impact
257 inventory, or the proposed mitigation does not meet state and
258 federal requirements. If a project is removed from the work
259 program or the mitigation plan, costs spent by the water
260 management district before removal are eligible for
261 reimbursement by the Department of Transportation or
262 participating transportation authority.
263 (b) When determining which projects to include in or
264 exclude from the mitigation plan, the Department of
265 Transportation shall investigate using credits from a permitted
266 mitigation bank before those projects are submitted for
267 inclusion in a water management district mitigation plan. The
268 Department of Transportation shall exclude a project from the
269 mitigation plan if the investigation undertaken pursuant to this
270 paragraph results in the conclusion that the use of credits from
271 a permitted mitigation bank promotes efficiency, timeliness in
272 project delivery, cost-effectiveness, and transfer of liability
273 for success and long-term maintenance.
274 Section 5. This act shall take effect July 1, 2026.
50
hardbottom in Broward, Martin, Miami-Dade, Monroe, and Palm
51
Beach Counties as being in the public interest.
52
(8)
(7)
The department may use habitat equivalency analysis
53 as the method by which the compensation described in subsection
54
(7)
(5)
is calculated. The parameters for calculation by this
55 method may be prescribed by rule adopted by the department.
56
(9)
(8)
In addition to the compensation described in
57 subsection
(
7
)
(5)
, the department may assess, per occurrence,
58 civil penalties according to the following schedule:
59 (a) For any anchoring of a vessel on a coral reef or for
60 any other damage to a coral reef totaling less than or equal to
61 an area of 1 square meter, $225, provided that a responsible
62 party who has anchored a recreational vessel as defined in s.
63 327.02 which is lawfully registered or exempt from registration
64 pursuant to chapter 328 is issued, at least once, a warning
65 letter in lieu of penalty; with aggravating circumstances, an
66 additional $225; occurring within a state park or aquatic
67 preserve, an additional $225.
68 (b) For damage totaling more than an area of 1 square meter
69 but less than or equal to an area of 10 square meters, $450 per
70 square meter; with aggravating circumstances, an additional $450
71 per square meter; occurring within a state park or aquatic
72 preserve, an additional $450 per square meter.
73 (c) For damage exceeding an area of 10 square meters,
74 $1,500 per square meter; with aggravating circumstances, an
75 additional $1,500 per square meter; occurring within a state
76 park or aquatic preserve, an additional $1,500 per square meter.
77 (d) For a second violation, the total penalty may be
78 doubled.
79 (e) For a third violation, the total penalty may be
80 tripled.
81 (f) For any violation after a third violation, the total
82 penalty may be quadrupled.
83 (g) The total of penalties levied may not exceed $375,000
84 per occurrence.
85 Section 2. This act shall take effect July 1, 2026.