2025 SESSION
SENATE SUBSTITUTE
INTRODUCED
25105237D25101605D
SENATE BILL NO. 821
AMENDMENT IN THE NATURE OF A SUBSTITUTE
(Proposed by the Senate Committee on Education and Health
onOffered January 238, 2025)
(Patron Prior to Substitute—Senator Craig)
Prefiled December 31, 2024
A BILL to amend the Code of Virginia by adding in Article 2 of Chapter 5 of Title 32.1 a section numbered 32.1-138.5:1, relating to nursing facilities; electronic monitoring in resident rooms.
—————
Patron—Craig
—————
Referred to Committee on Education and Health
—————
Be it enacted by the General Assembly of Virginia:
1. That the Code of Virginia is amended by adding in Article 2 of Chapter 5 of Title 32.1 a section numbered 32.1-138.5:1 as follows:
§ 32.1-138.5 : 1. Electronic monitoring in resident rooms .
A. As used in this section, unless the context requires a different meaning:
"Electronic monitoring" means the use of a surveillance devi ce with a fixed position video camera or audio recording device, or a combination thereof , that is installed in a resident's room and broadcasts or records activities or sounds occurring within the confines of the room. Electronic monitoring shall not include use of a device that enables audio communication into the resident's room from another source.
"Electronic monitoring" means video or audio monitoring or recording of a resident of a nursing facility as a means of monitor ing the resident 's well - being .
"Family member" means the resident 's spouse , parent, stepparent, child, stepchild, brother, sister, half-brother, half-sister, grandparent , or grandchild.
"Legal representative" means a person legally responsible for representing or standing in the place of the resident for the conduct of his affairs. This may include a guardian, conservator, attorney-in-fact under durable power of attorney, trustee, or other person expressly named by a court of competent jurisdiction or the resident as his agency in a legal document that specifies the scope of the representative's authority to act. A legal representative may only represent or stand in the place of a resident for the function for which he has legal authority to act.
B. All requests for electronic monitoring shall be made in writing and signed by the resident or , if the resident has been legallyproperly deemedassessed incompetentincapable of requesting and authorizing the monitoring , the resident's legal representative. Only electronic monitoring in accordance with this section is permitted.
Electronic monitoring shall be permitted only:
1. Upon the informed consent of the resident or resident's legal representative, which shall be obtained prior to the installation or use of any electronic monitoring device being installed or used . Consent for electronic monitoring shall be kept in the resident's medical record as well as on file with the nursing facility's designated electronic monitoring coordinator;
2. When t he resident resides in a room with no roommates;
3. Upon executiona of an agreement for the sharing and releasewaiver of medical data and information protected by the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (42 U.S.C. § 1320d et seq.)privacy signed by the resident or resident's legal representative t h at shall be kept in the resident's medical record ; and
4. When the nursing facility has secured and password - protected wireless I nternet access or other means available to operate the electronic monitoring device without permanent modification to the nursing facility or a change in level or capacity of Internet access .
C . A nursing facility shall allow electronic monitoring of a resident of a nursing facility if the electronic monitoring is conducted in accordance with this section. A nursing facility shall not refuse to admit an individual and shall not discharge or transfer a resident due to a request to conduct authorized electronic monitoring.
D . Family members shallcannot not implement or activateobtain electronic monitoring over the objections of or contrary to the instructions of the resident or the resident's legal representative. No el ectronic monitoring equipment may be installed over the objections of or contrary to the instructions of the resident or resident's legal representative. Nursing facilities shall not use monitoring equipment in violation of the law based solely on a family member's request or approval.
E . Nursing facilities shall designate one or more staff person s to be the point of contactresponsible for managing the electronic monitoring requests and for providing information and policies upon request during normal business hours program.
F. Except as provided in subsection O, n ursingNursing facilities may assumedesignate custodial ownership of any recordings from electronic monitoring devices fromto the resident or resident's legal representative. Recordings fromretained electronicby monitoringa devicesnursing facility shall not be considered part of the resident's medical record and shall be retained for no less than two years or as required by state and federal law.
G . If a nursing facility chooses to assumeretain ownership of recordings from electronic monitoring devices pursuant to subsection F , the nursing facility shall not permit viewings of recordings without consent of the resident or resident's legal representative except to the extent that disclosure is required by law through a court order or forpursuant qualityto assurancea purposeslawful subpoena duces tecum. Should the resident or resident's legal representative approve viewing, the nursing facility shall accommodate viewing of any recordings in a timely manner, including providing:
1. Appropriate playing or viewing equipment;
2. Privacy during viewing; and
3. Viewing times convenient to the resident or resident's legal representative.
If unauthorized viewing is discovered, the nursing facility shall report any such violation to t he Office of Licensure and Certification (the OLC) of the Department of Health .
H . A nursing facility shall not be held liable for any breach of data or privacydirectly related to the presence of the electronic monitoring device .
I . A nursing facility shall require its staff to immediately report any incidents regarding safety or quality of care discovered or reported to staff as a result of viewing a recording from an electronic monitoring device immediately to the administrator of the nursing facility and to the OLC. Nursing facilities shall instruct the resident or resident's legal representative of this reporting requirement and shall provide the resident or resident's legal representative with the OLC's complaint hotline telephone number.
J . A nursing facility shall have no obligation to seek access to a recording forin whichits it has not assumed custodial ownershippossession or to have knowledge of a recording's content unless (i) the nursing facility is aware of a recorded incident of suspected abuse or neglect, or of a n accident or injury based upon a report received by the facility of such incident, accident, or injury or (ii) the resident, the resident's legal representative, or a government agency seeks to use a recording. Nursing facilities shall immediately report suspected abuse or neglect discovered as a result of using electronic monitoring devices, as required by law.
K . Unless aA nursing facility choosesmay to assume ownership of any recordings from an electronic monitoring device,require the resident or resident's legal representative shallto be responsible for all aspects of the operation of the electronic monitoring device, including the removal and replacement of recordings; adherence to local, state, and federal privacy laws; and use o f firewall protections to prevent images that would violate obscenity laws from being inadvertently shown on the Internet.
L . A nursing facility shall prohibit assigned staff from refusing to enter a resident's room solely because of electronic monitoring.
M . Any electronic monitoring device shall be installed in a manner that is safe for residents, employees, and visitors who may be moving about the resident's room.
MN . A nursing facility shall make reasonable physical accommodation s for electronic monitoring device s , including:
1. Providing a reasonably secure place to mount the device; and
2. Providing reasonab le access to power sources if already in proximity tofor the device.
NO . A nursing facility shall require a resident or resident's legal representative to pay for all costs, other than the cost of electricity, associated with the purchase and installation of the electronic monitoring device . In addition, aA nursing facility may charge a one-time fee not to exceed $ 15025 when the electronic monitoring device is installed a long with a security deposit not to exceed $250 . A nursing facility may charge a monthly fee not to exceed $10 to cover costs associated with the electronic monitoring device . Such costs may include equipment, securedrecording media and password - protected wireless Internet and server capabilities installation, compliance with life safety and building and electrical codes, maintenance or removal of the equipment, posting and removal of any public notices, or structural repairs to the building resulting from the removal of the equipment. Nursing facilities shall give 45 days' notice of an increase in monthly monitoring fees.
O . The resident or resident's legal representative of a room with an electronic monitoring device may verbally or in writing condition consent to the installation or use of the electronic monitoring device. Such conditions on consent may include : (i) the ability of the resid ent, or staff at the request of the resident, to turn off or disable the audio or video electronic monitoring device during certain periods of time and (ii) a prohibition on the ability of the nursing facility to , pursuant to subsection F, choose to assume custodial ownership of any recordings from the electronic monitoring device after the electronic monitoring device has been installed and is operational . If the resident or resident's legal representative places any such conditions on consent, the nursing facility and staff shall ensure that the installation, use, and operation of the electronic monitoring device and any electronic monitoring or other activities conducted in connection therewith are conducted in compliance with such conditions.
P . Any equipment installed for the purpose of monitoring a resident's room shall be fixed and unable to be manipulated .
Q. The resident or resident's legal representative of a room with an electronic monitoring device may condition consent for use of monitoring devices. Such conditions may include pointing the camera away or limiting or prohibiting the use of certain devices. If conditions are placed on consent, then electronic monitoring shall be conducted according to those conditions.
P R. The nursing facility shall conspicuously post and maintain a notice at the entrance to the resident's room stating that an electronic monitoring device is in operation.
Q S. Nursing facilities shall notify assignedall staff f orand the residentlong-term care division of the OLC when electronic monitoring is in use in a resident's room pursuant to this section .
T . A nursing facility shall prohibit staff from covert monitoring in violation of this section. Nursing facilities shall instruct the resident or resident's legal representative of this prohibition and shall provide the resident or resident's legal representative with the OLC's complaint hotline telephone number.
U. If covert monitoring is discovered, the nursing facility shall report any such violation to the OLC, and the nursing facility may require a resident or resident's legal representative to meet all the requirements for authorized monitoring.
R V. Each nursing facility shall adopt policies and procedures for electronic monitoring. consistentThese withpolicies and procedures shall address all the elements of this section.
SW . EachA nursing facility shall adopt a policy prohibit ing staff from willfully tampering with electronic monitoring devices in violation of this section, .except Adjusting or disabli ng an electronic monitoring device duringwhen the provisiontampering ofis patienttemporarily necessary to provide care shall not constitute willful tampering if such adjusting or disabling is done in order to protect the dignity of a resident or. atNursing thefacilities directionshall ofinstruct the resident or resident's legal representative of this prohibition and shall provide the resident or resident's legal representative with the OLC's complaint hotline telephone number.
TX . If the placement or position of the electronic monitoring device creates risk to a nursin g facility employee or resident, or if the resident or resident's legal representative or family member violates the nursing facilities policies and procedures for electronic monitoring, the equipment may be disabled and removed and the resident, resident's legal representative , or family member responsible for the camera shall be notified of the removal.
2. That the Virginia Department of Health shall promulgate regulations consistent with this act and the provisions of this act shall become effective when such regulations become effective.