Introduced
Underlined text would be added to current law. Struck-through text would be removed.
| 90R460 CJD-D | ||
| By: Moody | H.B. No. 545 |
| A BILL TO BE ENTITLED | |
| AN ACT | |
| relating to the applicability of the death penalty to a capital | |
| offense committed by a person with an intellectual disability. | |
| BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: | |
| SECTION 1. Article 44.01, Code of Criminal Procedure, is | |
| amended by amending Subsection (a) and adding Subsection (a-1) to | |
| read as follows: | |
| (a) The state is entitled to appeal an order of a court in a | |
| criminal case if the order: | |
| (1) dismisses an indictment, information, or | |
| complaint or any portion of an indictment, information, or | |
| complaint; | |
| (2) arrests or modifies a judgment; | |
| (3) grants a new trial; | |
| (4) sustains a claim of former jeopardy; | |
| (5) grants a motion to suppress evidence, a | |
| confession, or an admission, if jeopardy has not attached in the | |
| case and if the prosecuting attorney certifies to the trial court | |
| that the appeal is not taken for the purpose of delay and that the | |
| evidence, confession, or admission is of substantial importance in | |
| the case; | |
| (6) is issued under Chapter 46D or 64; or | |
| (7) grants bail, in an amount considered insufficient | |
| by the prosecuting attorney, to a defendant who: | |
| (A) is charged with an offense under any of the | |
| following sections of the Penal Code: | |
| (i) Section 19.02 (murder); | |
| (ii) Section 19.03 (capital murder); | |
| (iii) Section 22.02 (aggravated assault) | |
| if: | |
| (a) the offense was committed under | |
| Subsection (a)(1); or | |
| (b) the defendant used a firearm, | |
| club, knife, or explosive weapon, as those terms are defined by | |
| Section 46.01, Penal Code, during the commission of the assault; | |
| (iv) Section 20.04 (aggravated | |
| kidnapping); | |
| (v) Section 29.03 (aggravated robbery); | |
| (vi) Section 22.021 (aggravated sexual | |
| assault); | |
| (vii) Section 21.11 (indecency with a | |
| child); | |
| (viii) Section 20A.02 (trafficking of | |
| persons); or | |
| (ix) Section 20A.03 (continuous | |
| trafficking of persons); or | |
| (B) is charged with an offense punishable as a | |
| felony and was released on bail for an offense punishable as a | |
| felony at the time the instant offense was committed. | |
| (a-1) The state's appeal of an order issued under Chapter | |
| 46D is a direct appeal to the court of criminal appeals. The court | |
| of criminal appeals shall expeditiously review the appeal. | |
| SECTION 2. Title 1, Code of Criminal Procedure, is amended | |
| by adding Chapter 46D to read as follows: | |
| CHAPTER 46D. CAPITAL CASE: EFFECT OF INTELLECTUAL DISABILITY | |
| Art. 46D.001. DEFINITIONS. In this chapter: | |
| (1) "Deficits in adaptive behavior" means sufficient | |
| deficits in adaptive functioning under prevailing medical | |
| standards for determining intellectual disability. | |
| (2) "Developmental period" means the developmental | |
| period of a person's life, as determined by prevailing medical | |
| standards. | |
| (3) "Intellectual disability" means significantly | |
| subaverage general intellectual functioning that is concurrent | |
| with deficits in adaptive behavior and originates during the | |
| developmental period. | |
| (4) "Significantly subaverage general intellectual | |
| functioning" refers to a measured intelligence quotient on a | |
| standardized psychometric instrument of approximately two or more | |
| standard deviations below the age-group mean for the test used, | |
| considering the standard error of measurement applicable to the | |
| instrument. | |
| Art. 46D.002. RESTRICTION ON DEATH PENALTY. A defendant | |
| who is a person with an intellectual disability may not be sentenced | |
| to death. | |
| Art. 46D.003. HEARING; DETERMINATION. (a) The attorney | |
| for a defendant in a capital case, not later than the first | |
| anniversary of the date of the defendant's indictment, may request | |
| in writing that the judge hearing the case hold a hearing to | |
| determine whether the defendant is a person with an intellectual | |
| disability. | |
| (b) On receipt of a request under this article, if the judge | |
| determines that the request was timely filed, the judge shall hold a | |
| hearing in accordance with this chapter to determine the issue. The | |
| hearing must be held: | |
| (1) not earlier than 180 days after the date that the | |
| written request was submitted under Subsection (a); and | |
| (2) not later than the 120th day before the date the | |
| trial is scheduled to begin. | |
| (c) If the attorney for a defendant files an untimely | |
| request under Subsection (a), or after the time for filing a request | |
| under Subsection (a) otherwise presents evidence that the defendant | |
| is a person with an intellectual disability, the judge may hold a | |
| hearing in accordance with this chapter if the attorney can show | |
| good cause for not filing a request within the time limit prescribed | |
| by Subsection (a). The hearing may not be held before a jury | |
| empaneled in the case. | |
| Art. 46D.004. APPOINTMENT OF DISINTERESTED EXPERT. (a) | |
| After the judge receives a request under Article 46D.003, and on the | |
| request of either party or on the judge's own motion, the judge | |
| shall appoint a disinterested expert experienced and qualified in | |
| the field of diagnosing intellectual disabilities to examine the | |
| defendant and determine whether the defendant is a person with an | |
| intellectual disability. | |
| (b) The judge may order the defendant to submit to an | |
| examination by an expert appointed under this article. | |
| (c) An examination described by this article must be | |
| narrowly tailored to determine whether the defendant has an | |
| intellectual disability. | |
| Art. 46D.005. BURDEN OF PROOF. (a) At a hearing under this | |
| chapter, the burden is on the defendant to prove by a preponderance | |
| of the evidence that the defendant is a person with an intellectual | |
| disability. | |
| (b) The state may offer evidence to rebut evidence offered | |
| by the defendant. | |
| Art. 46D.006. PREVAILING MEDICAL STANDARDS. Evidence | |
| offered by either party for purposes of a hearing under this chapter | |
| must be consistent with prevailing medical standards for the | |
| diagnosis of intellectual disabilities. | |
| Art. 46D.007. DETERMINATION BY JURY AND ORDER RELATED TO | |
| INTELLECTUAL DISABILITY. (a) Except as provided by Subsection | |
| (f), the judge shall empanel a jury solely for the purpose of | |
| determining whether the defendant is a person with an intellectual | |
| disability. The judge shall empanel the jury in the same manner as | |
| a jury is empaneled by the court for a felony other than a capital | |
| felony. | |
| (b) After the conclusion of the hearing, the judge shall | |
| instruct the jury to state in its verdict whether the defendant is a | |
| person with an intellectual disability. | |
| (c) The jury's verdict that the defendant is a person with | |
| an intellectual disability must be unanimous. | |
| (d) If the jury determines that the defendant is a person | |
| with an intellectual disability, the judge shall issue an | |
| appropriate order in accordance with this chapter that the | |
| defendant is a person with an intellectual disability. | |
| (e) If the jury does not determine that the defendant is a | |
| person with an intellectual disability, the judge shall conduct the | |
| trial of the offense in the same manner as if a hearing under this | |
| chapter had not been held. At the trial: | |
| (1) the trial jury may not be informed of the fact that | |
| a hearing was held under this chapter; and | |
| (2) the defendant may present evidence of intellectual | |
| disability as otherwise permitted by law. | |
| (f) The defendant may, with the consent of the attorney | |
| representing the state, waive a hearing before a jury and request a | |
| hearing before the judge under Article 46D.008. | |
| Art. 46D.008. DETERMINATION BY JUDGE AND ORDER RELATED TO | |
| INTELLECTUAL DISABILITY. (a) If a hearing before a jury is waived | |
| in accordance with Article 46D.007(f), the hearing must be held | |
| before the judge, outside the presence of a jury. | |
| (b) As soon as practicable but not later than the 30th day | |
| after the conclusion of a hearing under this article, the judge | |
| shall determine whether the defendant is a person with an | |
| intellectual disability and issue an appropriate order. The order | |
| must contain findings of fact explaining the judge's reasoning for | |
| the determination and citing evidence in the record. | |
| (c) If the judge does not determine that the defendant is a | |
| person with an intellectual disability, the judge shall conduct the | |
| trial of the offense in the same manner as if a hearing under this | |
| chapter had not been held. At the trial: | |
| (1) the jury may not be informed of the fact that the | |
| judge held a hearing under this chapter; and | |
| (2) the defendant may present evidence of intellectual | |
| disability as otherwise permitted by law. | |
| SECTION 3. The changes in law made by this Act apply only to | |
| a trial that commences on or after the effective date of this Act, | |
| regardless of whether the alleged offense was committed before, on, | |
| or after that date. | |
| SECTION 4. This Act takes effect September 1, 2027. |
Official text from the Texas Legislature. Formatting has been adapted for reading on Ratifi.