Introduced
Underlined text would be added to current law. Struck-through text would be removed.
| 90R3162 MLH-D | ||
| By: Lalani | H.B. No. 280 |
| A BILL TO BE ENTITLED | |
| AN ACT | |
| relating to a prohibition on the use of certain personalized | |
| dynamic pricing models by a business in this state. | |
| BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: | |
| SECTION 1. Subtitle C, Title 5, Business & Commerce Code, is | |
| amended by adding Chapter 125 to read as follows: | |
| CHAPTER 125. PERSONALIZED DYNAMIC PRICING | |
| SUBCHAPTER A. GENERAL PROVISIONS | |
| Sec. 125.001. DEFINITIONS. In this chapter: | |
| (1) "Dynamic pricing model" means a pricing model that | |
| uses an algorithm or other metric to determine the price of a good | |
| or service based on variables related to the market or a consumer. | |
| (2) "Personal identifying information" means any | |
| information, including sensitive information, that is linked or | |
| reasonably linkable to an identified or identifiable individual. | |
| The term includes publicly available information. | |
| Sec. 125.002. APPLICABILITY. This chapter applies to: | |
| (1) a retailer that conducts business in this state on | |
| a physical premises; and | |
| (2) an online retailer that conducts business in this | |
| state resulting in not less than $10 million in annual revenue. | |
| SUBCHAPTER B. PROHIBITION ON PERSONALIZED PRICING | |
| Sec. 125.021. PROHIBITION ON CERTAIN DYNAMIC PRICING | |
| MODELS. (a) A person may not use a dynamic pricing model to | |
| determine the price of a good if the model: | |
| (1) uses personal identifying information or other | |
| unique qualities of the customer as an input; and | |
| (2) results in a price that is: | |
| (A) unique to the customer; and | |
| (B) greater than the price that would be expected | |
| in the absence of the model. | |
| (b) For purposes of this section, a dynamic pricing model | |
| uses personal identifying information or other unique qualities of | |
| a customer if it uses any public or private information, whether | |
| collected directly from the customer or obtained from another | |
| source, that could provide insight into the customer's purchasing | |
| practices or proclivities, including: | |
| (1) the customer's purchase or transaction history; | |
| (2) the customer's Internet browsing or search | |
| history; | |
| (3) the personal behavior of the customer when using | |
| an electronic device or the Internet; | |
| (4) the customer's precise geolocation data, as that | |
| term is defined by Section 541.001; | |
| (5) information about the customer or the unique | |
| qualities of the customer that is obtained from a data broker, as | |
| that term is defined by Section 510.001, or another third party; | |
| (6) publicly available information that can be used to | |
| infer the unique qualities of the customer; and | |
| (7) any other information that could be used to infer: | |
| (A) the customer's ability or willingness to | |
| purchase a good or service at a certain price; | |
| (B) the customer's sensitivity to price | |
| fluctuations for a good or service; | |
| (C) the urgency of the customer to purchase a | |
| certain good or service in a timely manner; or | |
| (D) the likelihood of the customer to engage in | |
| certain shopping practices or techniques, including by comparing | |
| the price of a good or service at multiple retailers. | |
| (c) For purposes of this section, a dynamic pricing model | |
| results in a price that is greater than the price that would be | |
| expected in the absence of the model if the model makes any change | |
| that leads to an increased final retail price for a customer when | |
| compared to the price the customer would pay without the model, | |
| including by: | |
| (1) increasing the base price of a good or service; | |
| (2) adding or increasing a fee or surcharge; | |
| (3) withholding or reducing the amount of a discount | |
| that is or should be available under reasonably comparable | |
| circumstances; or | |
| (4) otherwise influencing the final retail price for | |
| the customer. | |
| (d) This section may not be construed to prevent the use of a | |
| dynamic pricing model otherwise permitted by this chapter solely on | |
| the basis of the method or technological manner in which the model | |
| is operated, including on the basis that the model: | |
| (1) uses machine learning, a software algorithm, or an | |
| artificial intelligence system, as that term is defined by Section | |
| 551.001, to determine the price of a good or service; | |
| (2) uses or includes a specific type of predictive or | |
| statistical modeling; | |
| (3) changes the price of a good or service often or | |
| quickly, whether automatically or because of a manual change; or | |
| (4) displays prices in an electronic or other | |
| easy-to-change format. | |
| Sec. 125.022. DYNAMIC PRICING MODEL PROVIDED BY THIRD | |
| PARTY. (a) Except as provided by Subsection (b), a person is | |
| considered responsible for the use of a dynamic pricing model even | |
| if the model is provided or administered by a third party. | |
| (b) A person who uses a dynamic pricing model prohibited | |
| under Section 125.021 that is provided or administered by a third | |
| party is not responsible for a violation of this chapter if the | |
| person: | |
| (1) reasonably evaluated the model and the model's | |
| provider before beginning use; | |
| (2) received written assurance from the third party | |
| that the model did not violate this chapter; and | |
| (3) reasonably believed in good faith that the model | |
| did not violate this chapter. | |
| Sec. 125.023. RETENTION OF RECORDS RELATING TO MODEL. A | |
| person who makes use of a dynamic pricing model not prohibited by | |
| Section 125.021 shall: | |
| (1) keep records relating to the model, including: | |
| (A) a list of any algorithms or related software, | |
| including artificial intelligence systems, as that term is defined | |
| by Section 551.001, that play a role in the operation of the model; | |
| (B) the operational structure or code related to | |
| any algorithm or related software listed under Paragraph (A); | |
| (C) any metrics or categories of personal | |
| identifying information used by the model; and | |
| (D) any material factors that affect the | |
| determination of the price of a good or service; and | |
| (2) retain the records described by Subdivision (1) | |
| for a period of not less than two years. | |
| SUBCHAPTER C. PERMITTED DYNAMIC PRICING MODELS | |
| Sec. 125.041. MARKET-BASED DYNAMIC PRICING MODELS. (a) | |
| This chapter may not be construed to prohibit: | |
| (1) price variation related to identifiable costs | |
| attributable to providing retail services; or | |
| (2) price fluctuations applicable to all customers at | |
| a retail location. | |
| (b) This chapter does not prohibit a person from using a | |
| dynamic pricing model intended to adjust the price of a good or | |
| service to reflect legitimate and identifiable market-based or | |
| transaction-influenced factors, including: | |
| (1) changes in the supply of or demand for the good or | |
| service; | |
| (2) differences in the nature, characteristics, or | |
| quality of similar goods or services; | |
| (3) changes in the cost to acquire inventory or other | |
| inputs for the good or service; | |
| (4) changes in the cost of labor, energy, | |
| transportation, or other expenses involved in providing retail | |
| services; | |
| (5) differences in the time or place of a transaction, | |
| including the: | |
| (A) time of day; | |
| (B) date or day of the week; | |
| (C) season, including weather or climatic | |
| considerations; | |
| (D) distance from the source of or shipping | |
| constraints for the good or service or a component of the good or | |
| service; or | |
| (E) manner in which the purchase is transacted or | |
| will be fulfilled; | |
| (6) changes to the local geographic market conditions; | |
| (7) the capacity of the person to accept additional | |
| customer traffic, including due to occupancy limits on a physical | |
| premises; | |
| (8) differences in the imposition of taxes or fees | |
| based on the location or nature of the market; | |
| (9) differences in the cost of shipping a good to a | |
| different location; or | |
| (10) other objective, determinable factors that could | |
| reasonably affect the price of the good or service. | |
| Sec. 125.042. REWARD OR CUSTOMER LOYALTY DYNAMIC PRICING | |
| MODELS. (a) This chapter may not be construed to prohibit | |
| promotional pricing, loyalty benefits, clearance sales, or other | |
| temporary discounts that are: | |
| (1) available to multiple customers on the same terms; | |
| (2) optional and selected into by each participating | |
| customer; and | |
| (3) intended to attract or retain customers. | |
| (b) This chapter does not prohibit a person from using a | |
| dynamic pricing model intended to adjust the price of a good or | |
| service to reward or incentivize new or loyal customers, including: | |
| (1) sales, rebates, or promotional discounts; | |
| (2) coupons, including personalized coupons; | |
| (3) loyalty or rewards programs, including | |
| memberships or club pricing; | |
| (4) discounts provided as part of a customer service | |
| or customer retention effort; | |
| (5) discounts for customers who are students, members | |
| of the armed forces, veterans, seniors, educators, first | |
| responders, government employees, or similar classes of customers | |
| known to receive similar discounts; | |
| (6) discounts or price cuts associated with or | |
| provided through public or private financial assistance programs; | |
| or | |
| (7) other customer benefits that meet the description | |
| in Subsection (a). | |
| Sec. 125.043. DYNAMIC PRICING MODELS FOR NEGOTIATED | |
| TRANSACTION. (a) This chapter may not be construed to prohibit | |
| changes in price inherent to a negotiated transaction. | |
| (b) This chapter does not prohibit a person from using a | |
| dynamic pricing model to help the person respond to various factors | |
| of a bona fide individualized negotiation with a customer, | |
| including: | |
| (1) the amount of the customer's offer or | |
| counteroffer; | |
| (2) the nature of any contractual terms sought or | |
| offered by the customer; | |
| (3) personal identifying information provided or | |
| introduced by the customer as part of the negotiation; | |
| (4) the value of any nonmonetary consideration offered | |
| by the customer, including a trade-in or return; | |
| (5) the proposed or anticipated financing structure, | |
| if applicable; or | |
| (6) other information, including market-based | |
| information described by Section 125.041, that could reasonably | |
| affect the price of a good or service under negotiation. | |
| (c) A person may not use a dynamic pricing model to help the | |
| person respond to various factors of a bona fide individualized | |
| negotiation with a customer if the model uses personal identifying | |
| information or other unique qualities of the customer that were not | |
| provided by, introduced by, or consented to by the customer. | |
| Sec. 125.044. DYNAMIC PRICING MODEL FOR RANDOMIZED PRICING | |
| TEST. This chapter does not prohibit a person from using a dynamic | |
| pricing model as part of a randomized pricing test if the model: | |
| (1) assigns or determines the price of a good or | |
| service for a customer in a manner that is genuinely random; | |
| (2) does not use personal identifying information or | |
| other unique qualities of the customer as an input; | |
| (3) uses personal identifying information or other | |
| unique qualities only for the purpose of evaluating the randomized | |
| pricing test and determining appropriate pricing for future | |
| transactions; and | |
| (4) does not use, generate, or retain any personal | |
| identifying information or other unique qualities for use in any | |
| dynamic pricing model that violates Section 125.021. | |
| Sec. 125.045. DYNAMIC PRICING MODELS FOR CERTAIN REGULATED | |
| ACTIVITY. This chapter does not prohibit a person from using a | |
| dynamic pricing model as part of an industry or practice that is | |
| regulated in a manner that requires the type of individualized | |
| pricing prohibited by this chapter, including: | |
| (1) insurance underwriting or rating; | |
| (2) credit and lending decisions; | |
| (3) rates of taxes, utilities, or tariffs; | |
| (4) health care reimbursement or cost-sharing | |
| arrangements; | |
| (5) government pricing or benefit programs; or | |
| (6) pricing conduct preempted by federal law. | |
| SUBCHAPTER D. ENFORCEMENT | |
| Sec. 125.061. (a) A violation of this chapter is a | |
| deceptive trade practice under Subchapter E, Chapter 17, and is | |
| actionable under that subchapter. | |
| (b) For purposes of this chapter, each day in which a person | |
| uses a dynamic pricing model in violation of this chapter | |
| constitutes a separate violation. | |
| SECTION 2. Chapter 125, Business & Commerce Code, as added | |
| by this Act, applies only to a dynamic pricing model in use on or | |
| after September 1, 2028. A dynamic pricing model in use before that | |
| date is not governed by Chapter 125, Business & Commerce Code, as | |
| added by this Act, for purposes of determining whether a violation | |
| has occurred. | |
| SECTION 3. This Act takes effect September 1, 2027. |
Official text from the Texas Legislature. Formatting has been adapted for reading on Ratifi.