House Committee Report
Underlined text would be added to current law. Struck-through text would be removed.
| 89R15304 JCG-F | ||
| By: Patterson, Capriglione, Curry | H.B. No. 5083 |
| A BILL TO BE ENTITLED | |
| AN ACT | |
| relating to the adoption and review of rules by state agencies. | |
| BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: | |
| SECTION 1. Section 28.002(m), Education Code, is amended to | |
| read as follows: | |
| (m) Section 2001.0395 [ |
|
| of Education under Subsection (c) or (d). | |
| SECTION 2. Subchapter A, Chapter 2001, Government Code, is | |
| amended by adding Section 2001.008 to read as follows: | |
| Sec. 2001.008. EXPRESS STATUTORY AUTHORITY FOR RULE OR | |
| GUIDANCE DOCUMENT REQUIRED. (a) In this section, "guidance | |
| document" means any letter, opinion, compliance manual, or other | |
| statement issued by a state agency that explains or interprets one | |
| or more of the state agency's rules. | |
| (b) A state agency may not adopt a rule or issue a guidance | |
| document unless the agency has been granted an express statutory | |
| delegation of authority to adopt the rule or issue the guidance | |
| document. | |
| (c) For purposes of Subsection (b), a state agency does not | |
| have an express statutory delegation of authority to adopt a rule or | |
| issue a guidance document solely because the rule or guidance | |
| document is reasonably related to the purpose of the state agency's | |
| enabling legislation or to a general statutory power or duty of the | |
| state agency. | |
| SECTION 3. Subchapter B, Chapter 2001, Government Code, is | |
| amended by adding Section 2001.0227 to read as follows: | |
| Sec. 2001.0227. CERTAIN RULES PROHIBITED BASED ON COSTS OF | |
| COMPLIANCE; COST-BENEFIT ANALYSES REQUIRED. (a) A state agency | |
| shall prepare a cost-benefit analysis for each proposed rule as | |
| provided by this section. | |
| (b) The cost-benefit analysis must include: | |
| (1) a cost-benefit analysis estimating for each year | |
| of the first six years that the rule will be in effect: | |
| (A) the public benefits expected as a result of | |
| adoption of the rule; and | |
| (B) the expected economic costs to persons | |
| required to comply with the rule; | |
| (2) an explanation of all assumptions, methods, | |
| supporting data, and, if any, discount rates used in preparing the | |
| cost-benefit analysis; and | |
| (3) a clear statement of the total expected economic | |
| costs to persons required to comply with the rule and the total | |
| public benefits expected as a result of the adoption of the rule. | |
| (c) A state agency may not adopt a proposed rule: | |
| (1) for which the cost-benefit analysis under | |
| Subsection (b) states that the total expected economic costs to | |
| comply with the rule exceed the total public benefits expected as a | |
| result of the adoption of the proposed rule; or | |
| (2) if there are alternative methods of regulation | |
| that could accomplish the legislature's intent in authorizing the | |
| rule and any statutory purposes provided by the legislature at a | |
| lower economic cost to persons required to comply with the rule. | |
| (d) If the proposed rule takes effect and remains in effect | |
| at least six years, the state agency shall: | |
| (1) solicit from interested stakeholders data | |
| regarding the stakeholders' experience and actual economic costs of | |
| compliance with the rule; and | |
| (2) conduct a retrospective cost-benefit analysis | |
| that compares: | |
| (A) estimates made under Subsection (b)(1) | |
| regarding the economic costs of compliance; and | |
| (B) the actual economic costs of compliance based | |
| on the data provided under Subdivision (1) and any other readily | |
| available data relevant to this purpose. | |
| (e) If a state agency uses a discount rate in preparing an | |
| analysis under Subsection (b) or (d), the state agency shall | |
| provide: | |
| (1) a reasoned justification for the use of the | |
| discount rate; and | |
| (2) another cost-benefit analysis for the same rule | |
| that does not include the use of the discount rate. | |
| (f) A state agency that prepares an analysis under | |
| Subsection (b) or (d) shall publish on the agency's publicly | |
| accessible Internet website all documentation and other materials | |
| used to prepare the analysis in a machine-readable format. | |
| (g) A reference to an existing rule under this section | |
| includes any amendments to the rule, and, to the extent feasible, | |
| the state agency shall prepare the analysis required under | |
| Subsection (b) based on the terms of the rule as amended. | |
| SECTION 4. Section 2001.024(a), Government Code, is amended | |
| to read as follows: | |
| (a) The notice of a proposed rule must include: | |
| (1) a brief explanation of the proposed rule; | |
| (2) the text of the proposed rule, except any portion | |
| omitted under Section 2002.014, prepared in a manner to indicate | |
| any words to be added or deleted from the current text; | |
| (3) a statement of the statutory or other authority | |
| under which the rule is proposed to be adopted, including: | |
| (A) a concise explanation of the particular | |
| statutory or other provisions under which the rule is proposed; | |
| (B) the section or article of the code affected; | |
| (C) if applicable, the bill number for the | |
| legislation that enacted the statutory authority under which the | |
| rule is proposed to be adopted if the legislation was enacted during | |
| the four-year period preceding the date notice of the proposed rule | |
| is given; and | |
| (D) a certification that the proposed rule has | |
| been reviewed by legal counsel and found to be within the state | |
| agency's authority to adopt; | |
| (4) a fiscal note showing the name and title of the | |
| officer or employee responsible for preparing or approving the note | |
| and stating for each year of the first five years that the rule will | |
| be in effect: | |
| (A) the additional estimated cost to the state | |
| and to local governments expected as a result of enforcing or | |
| administering the rule; | |
| (B) the estimated reductions in costs to the | |
| state and to local governments as a result of enforcing or | |
| administering the rule; | |
| (C) the estimated loss or increase in revenue to | |
| the state or to local governments as a result of enforcing or | |
| administering the rule; and | |
| (D) if applicable, that enforcing or | |
| administering the rule does not have foreseeable implications | |
| relating to cost or revenues of the state or local governments; | |
| (5) the cost-benefit analysis required under Section | |
| 2001.0227 [ |
|
| [ |
|
| [ |
|
| (6) the local employment impact statement prepared | |
| under Section 2001.022, if required; | |
| (7) a request for comments on the proposed rule from | |
| any interested person; and | |
| (8) any other statement required by law. | |
| SECTION 5. Section 2001.033, Government Code, is amended by | |
| amending Subsection (a) and adding Subsection (c) to read as | |
| follows: | |
| (a) A state agency order finally adopting a rule must | |
| include: | |
| (1) a reasoned justification for the rule as adopted | |
| consisting solely of: | |
| (A) a summary of comments received from parties | |
| interested in the rule that shows the names of interested groups or | |
| associations offering comment on the rule and whether they were for | |
| or against its adoption; | |
| (B) a summary of the factual basis for the rule as | |
| adopted which demonstrates a rational connection between the | |
| factual basis for the rule and the rule as adopted; and | |
| (C) the reasons why the agency disagrees with | |
| party submissions and proposals; | |
| (2) a concise restatement of the particular statutory | |
| provisions under which the rule is adopted and of how the agency | |
| interprets the provisions as authorizing or requiring the rule; | |
| [ |
|
| (3) a certification that the rule, as adopted, has | |
| been reviewed by legal counsel and found to be a valid exercise of | |
| the agency's legal authority; and | |
| (4) the cost-benefit analysis required under Section | |
| 2001.0227 updated to reflect reasonable public commentary on the | |
| state agency's calculations of the costs and benefits of the rule or | |
| a reasoned justification for why the agency did not update the | |
| cost-benefit analysis based on the public commentary. | |
| (c) A state agency rule may not be arbitrary or capricious. | |
| SECTION 6. Section 2001.038, Government Code, is amended by | |
| adding Subsection (g) to read as follows: | |
| (g) A respondent subject to an enforcement action by a state | |
| agency for the violation of a rule may request a declaratory | |
| judgment from the court finding a rule invalid if the state agency | |
| lacks express statutory delegation of authority to adopt the rule | |
| on which the enforcement action is based, including if the state | |
| agency relies on a guidance document to interpret the rule for | |
| purposes of the enforcement action. A court shall award a | |
| respondent that prevails on the ground provided by this subsection | |
| reasonable attorney's fees and court costs. For purposes of this | |
| section, "guidance document" has the meaning assigned by Section | |
| 2001.008. | |
| SECTION 7. Subchapter B, Chapter 2001, Government Code, is | |
| amended by adding Sections 2001.0395 and 2001.042 to read as | |
| follows: | |
| Sec. 2001.0395. EXPIRATION OF RULES. (a) Each state agency | |
| rule expires on the 12th anniversary of the rule's effective date | |
| unless the state agency that adopted the rule readopts the rule | |
| before the rule's expiration date in accordance with this section. | |
| (b) The expiration date for a readopted rule is the 12th | |
| anniversary of the readopted rule's effective date. | |
| (c) The adoption of an amendment to an existing rule does | |
| not affect the expiration date of the rule under this section unless | |
| the amendment is made as part of a readoption of the entire rule or | |
| chapter of the Texas Administrative Code containing the amended | |
| rule. | |
| (d) The procedures of this subchapter required for the | |
| adoption of a rule apply to the readoption of a rule under this | |
| section, including: | |
| (1) preparing a cost-benefit analysis under Section | |
| 2001.0227(b); | |
| (2) providing opportunity for public comment under | |
| Section 2001.029; | |
| (3) responding to substantive public comments, as | |
| required under Section 2001.033(a)(1)(C); and | |
| (4) providing an updated cost-benefit analysis under | |
| Section 2001.033(a)(4). | |
| (e) In readopting a rule under this section, a state agency | |
| must also: | |
| (1) provide an assessment of whether the reasons for | |
| initially adopting the rule continue to exist; | |
| (2) provide an assessment of whether the rule is | |
| obsolete, unnecessary, or duplicative or conflicts with other | |
| rules; | |
| (3) consider public comments that provide data and | |
| information on the actual economic costs to persons required to | |
| comply with the rule; | |
| (4) to the fullest extent practicable, base estimates | |
| on expected economic costs to persons required to comply with the | |
| rule on data and information described by Section 2001.0227(d)(1); | |
| and | |
| (5) publish all notices, analyses, and responses to | |
| public comments on the state agency's publicly accessible Internet | |
| website. | |
| (f) Each state agency shall with respect to the state | |
| agency's rules: | |
| (1) publish on the state agency's publicly accessible | |
| Internet website the expiration date for each rule; and | |
| (2) make the expiration date of each rule available | |
| through an application programming interface that allows automated | |
| access and monitoring of the rules' expiration dates. | |
| (g) The secretary of state shall include a rule's expiration | |
| date in the online publication of the Texas Administrative Code in a | |
| standardized metadata field that accompanies each section of the | |
| code. | |
| (h) Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, a | |
| rule does not expire under this section if the governor in writing | |
| exempts a rule from the application of this section. On the written | |
| request from a state agency, the governor shall exempt a rule that: | |
| (1) is necessary: | |
| (A) to comply with federal law; or | |
| (B) because federal funding is conditioned on the | |
| rule remaining in effect; or | |
| (2) is authorized or required by the constitution. | |
| (i) A state agency that administers a rule exempted under | |
| Subsection (h) shall every 12 years after the date of the exemption | |
| consider less burdensome alternatives to the rule, solicit public | |
| commentary on those potential alternatives, and in determining | |
| whether to adopt less burdensome alternatives, calculate the | |
| expected economic costs to persons required to comply with the rule | |
| based on data and information provided by persons subject to the | |
| rule and bearing those costs. | |
| (j) On written request by a state agency, the governor may | |
| extend a rule's expiration date under this section for a period not | |
| to exceed one year following the date on which the extension is | |
| granted. A written request under this subsection to extend a rule's | |
| expiration date must: | |
| (1) explain the reason the state agency cannot | |
| complete the readoption of the rule under this section before the | |
| rule's expiration date; and | |
| (2) describe the harm to the public's health, safety, | |
| or welfare that would result if the rule expired. | |
| (k) Any extension granted under Subsection (j) must be | |
| accompanied by findings affirming the conditions described by | |
| Subsections (j)(1) and (2). | |
| Sec. 2001.042. CERTAIN ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS INVALID | |
| REGARDLESS OF COMMENCEMENT DATE. An enforcement action brought by | |
| a state agency shall be dismissed if the enforcement action is based | |
| on the violation of a rule that expired, regardless of whether the | |
| enforcement action commenced before the date the rule expired. | |
| SECTION 8. Section 801.022(e), Occupations Code, is amended | |
| to read as follows: | |
| (e) Not later than December 31, 2026, the department shall | |
| conduct a review under former Section 2001.039, Government Code, of | |
| each rule under 22 T.A.C. Part 24. In conducting the review under | |
| this subsection, the department shall ensure that license holders | |
| and the public have a meaningful opportunity to provide input and | |
| recommend changes to the rules. | |
| SECTION 9. Section 2001.039, Government Code, is repealed. | |
| SECTION 10. (a) Notwithstanding Section 2001.0395, | |
| Government Code, as added by this Act, a state agency shall assign | |
| the state agency's rules that exist on the effective date of this | |
| section eight different expiration dates for the purpose of | |
| staggering the expiration dates of the rules and implementing that | |
| section. | |
| (b) An expiration date assigned to a rule under this section | |
| may not be later than January 1, 2040. | |
| (c) Not later than December 1, 2025, each state agency shall | |
| report to the governor the expiration dates assigned under this | |
| section. | |
| (d) The governor shall publish on the office's publicly | |
| accessible Internet website a schedule of all the expiration dates | |
| assigned under this section. | |
| (e) This section takes effect September 1, 2025. | |
| SECTION 11. The changes in law made by this Act to | |
| Subchapter B, Chapter 2001, Government Code, apply only to a | |
| proposed state agency rule for which notice is filed with the | |
| secretary of state under Section 2001.023, Government Code, on or | |
| after the effective date of this Act. | |
| SECTION 12. Except as otherwise provided by this Act, this | |
| Act takes effect January 1, 2026. |
Official text from the Texas Legislature. Formatting has been adapted for reading on Ratifi.