Introduced
Underlined text would be added to current law. Struck-through text would be removed.
| 89R13330 MAW-F | ||
| By: Schofield | H.B. No. 4501 |
| A BILL TO BE ENTITLED | |
| AN ACT | |
| relating to statutory construction. | |
| BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: | |
| SECTION 1. Sections 311.016(2) and (3), Government Code, | |
| are amended to read as follows: | |
| (2) "Shall" imposes a duty. The use of "shall" does not | |
| indicate that an action is discretionary. | |
| (3) "Must" imposes a requirement and either creates a | |
| duty or creates or recognizes a condition precedent. | |
| SECTION 2. Subchapter C, Chapter 311, Government Code, is | |
| amended by adding Sections 311.0211, 311.0212, and 311.0213 to read | |
| as follows: | |
| Sec. 311.0211. INTENTIONALISM PROHIBITED. When | |
| interpreting a statute, a court: | |
| (1) may not inquire into what members of the | |
| legislature intended to accomplish by enacting the statute; and | |
| (2) shall enforce the statutory text as written and in | |
| accordance with the meaning that the words of the statute would have | |
| to an ordinary speaker of the English language. | |
| Sec. 311.0212. USE OF LEGISLATURE HISTORY PROHIBITED. When | |
| interpreting a statute, a court may not consider, consult, cite, | |
| rely on, or give any weight to: | |
| (1) any statement from an individual legislator, | |
| including a statement by the author or sponsor of the bill that | |
| enacted the statute or a statement made during a committee hearing | |
| or debate of the bill on the floor of a house of the legislature; | |
| (2) a committee report; or | |
| (3) a statement of a presiding officer or the governor | |
| made on the signing of the bill. | |
| Sec. 311.0213. DEFERENCE TO AGENCY CONSTRUCTION | |
| PROHIBITED. Notwithstanding any other law, a court is not required | |
| to give deference to any construction of a statute by a state agency | |
| responsible for administering, implementing, or enforcing the | |
| statute. This section does not prohibit a court from considering a | |
| state agency's construction of a statute if that construction is | |
| reasonable and does not conflict with the plain language of the | |
| statute. | |
| SECTION 3. Section 311.025(c), Government Code, is amended | |
| to read as follows: | |
| (c) In determining whether amendments are irreconcilable, | |
| text that is reenacted because of the requirement of Article III, | |
| Section 36, of the Texas Constitution is not considered to be | |
| irreconcilable with additions or omissions in the same text made by | |
| another amendment. Unless clearly indicated to the contrary, an | |
| amendment that reenacts text in compliance with that constitutional | |
| requirement does not mean [ |
|
| reenacted text prevails [ |
|
| made by another amendment, regardless of the relative dates of | |
| enactment. | |
| SECTION 4. Section 311.026(b), Government Code, is amended | |
| to read as follows: | |
| (b) If the conflict between the general provision and the | |
| special or local provision is irreconcilable, the special or local | |
| provision prevails as an exception to the general provision, unless | |
| the general provision is the later enactment and clearly and | |
| unambiguously supersedes the special or local provision [ |
|
| SECTION 5. Section 311.028, Government Code, is amended to | |
| read as follows: | |
| Sec. 311.028. UNIFORM CONSTRUCTION OF UNIFORM ACTS. A | |
| uniform act included in a code shall be construed, when possible, | |
| [ |
|
| states that enact it. | |
| SECTION 6. Subchapter C, Chapter 311, Government Code, is | |
| amended by adding Section 311.0311 to read as follows: | |
| Sec. 311.0311. SEVERABILITY AND SAVING CONSTRUCTIONS. (a) | |
| Unless a statute contains a provision expressly providing for | |
| nonseverability, every provision, section, subsection, sentence, | |
| clause, phrase, and word of the statute, including every discrete | |
| application of the provision, section, subsection, sentence, | |
| clause, phrase, or word to any person, group of persons, or | |
| circumstance, is severable. | |
| (b) If any application of any statutory provision, section, | |
| subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or word to any person, group | |
| of persons, or circumstance is determined by a court to be invalid, | |
| preempted, or unconstitutional, regardless of the reason, all | |
| remaining applications of that statutory provision, section, | |
| subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or word to any other person, | |
| group of persons, or circumstance shall be severed and preserved | |
| and remain in effect. | |
| (c) It is the intent of the legislature that every valid, | |
| non-preempted, and constitutional application of its statutory | |
| enactments be allowed to stand alone and remain enforceable. | |
| (d) A court may not decline to enforce the severability | |
| requirements of this section on the grounds that the severance | |
| would rewrite the statute or involve the court in legislative or | |
| lawmaking activity. A court that declines to enforce, or that | |
| enjoins a state official from enforcing, wholly or partly, a | |
| statute is not considered to be rewriting a statute or engaging in | |
| legislative or lawmaking activity because the statute continues to | |
| contain the same words as before the court's decision. A judicial | |
| injunction or declaration of unconstitutionality: | |
| (1) is only an edict prohibiting enforcement of the | |
| disputed statute against the parties to that lawsuit and may | |
| subsequently be vacated by a higher court based on a different | |
| understanding of the law; | |
| (2) is not a formal amendment of the language in a | |
| statute; and | |
| (3) does not rewrite the statute any more than a | |
| decision by the executive not to enforce a duly enacted statute in a | |
| limited and defined set of circumstances. | |
| (e) If a court, in violation of this section, declares or | |
| finds any statutory provision, section, subsection, sentence, | |
| clause, phrase, or word to be facially or totally invalid, | |
| preempted, or unconstitutional, when there are discrete | |
| applications of that statutory provision, section, subsection, | |
| sentence, clause, phrase, or word that could be enforced against a | |
| person, group of persons, or circumstance without violating federal | |
| law or the federal or state constitutions, then that statutory | |
| provision, section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or word | |
| shall be interpreted, as a matter of state law, as if the | |
| legislature had explicitly limited its application to the person, | |
| group of persons, or circumstance for which its application will | |
| not violate federal law or the federal or state constitutions, and | |
| every court shall adopt and apply this saving construction until | |
| the court ruling declaring the statutory provision, section, | |
| subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or word facially or totally | |
| invalid, preempted, or unconstitutional is vacated or overturned. | |
| SECTION 7. Section 311.034, Government Code, is amended to | |
| read as follows: | |
| Sec. 311.034. WAIVER OF SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY; JURISDICTIONAL | |
| REQUIREMENTS. In order to preserve the legislature's interest in | |
| managing state fiscal matters through the appropriations process, a | |
| statute shall not be construed as a waiver of sovereign immunity | |
| unless the waiver is effected by clear and unambiguous language. In | |
| a statute, the use of "person," as defined by Section 311.005 to | |
| include governmental entities, does not [ |
|
| statute indicates no other reasonable construction. Statutory | |
| prerequisites to a suit, including the provision of notice, are | |
| jurisdictional requirements in all suits against a governmental | |
| entity. | |
| SECTION 8. Subchapter C, Chapter 311, Government Code, is | |
| amended by adding Section 311.037 to read as follows: | |
| Sec. 311.037. GRAMMATICAL OR SCRIVENER'S ERROR. A | |
| grammatical or scrivener's error does not vitiate a law. A court | |
| construing a statute that contains a grammatical or scrivener's | |
| error that would be apparent to an ordinary reader of the English | |
| language may interpret the statute consistent with the | |
| understanding of the statute by an ordinary reader of the English | |
| language. | |
| SECTION 9. Subchapter A, Chapter 312, Government Code, is | |
| amended by adding Sections 312.0051, 312.0052, 312.0053, 312.0081, | |
| and 312.0082 to read as follows: | |
| Sec. 312.0051. INTENTIONALISM PROHIBITED. When | |
| interpreting a statute, a court: | |
| (1) may not inquire into what members of the | |
| legislature intended to accomplish by enacting the statute; and | |
| (2) shall enforce the statutory text as written and in | |
| accordance with the meaning that the words of the statute would have | |
| to an ordinary speaker of the English language. | |
| Sec. 312.0052. USE OF LEGISLATURE HISTORY PROHIBITED. When | |
| interpreting a statute, a court may not consider, consult, cite, | |
| rely on, or give any weight to: | |
| (1) any statement from an individual legislator, | |
| including a statement by the author or sponsor of the bill that | |
| enacted the statute or a statement made during a committee hearing | |
| or debate of the bill on the floor of a house of the legislature; | |
| (2) a committee report; or | |
| (3) a statement of a presiding officer or the governor | |
| made on the signing of the bill. | |
| Sec. 312.0053. DEFERENCE TO AGENCY CONSTRUCTION | |
| PROHIBITED. Notwithstanding any other law, a court is not required | |
| to give deference to any construction of a statute by a state agency | |
| responsible for administering, implementing, or enforcing the | |
| statute. This section does not prohibit a court from considering a | |
| state agency's construction of a statute if that construction is | |
| reasonable and does not conflict with the plain language of the | |
| statute. | |
| Sec. 312.0081. GRAMMATICAL OR SCRIVENER'S ERROR. A | |
| grammatical or scrivener's error does not vitiate a law. A court | |
| construing a statute that contains a grammatical or scrivener's | |
| error that would be apparent to an ordinary reader of the English | |
| language may interpret the statute consistent with the | |
| understanding of the statute by an ordinary reader of the English | |
| language. | |
| Sec. 312.0082. SEVERABILITY AND SAVING CONSTRUCTIONS. (a) | |
| Unless a statute contains a provision expressly providing for | |
| nonseverability, every provision, section, subsection, sentence, | |
| clause, phrase, and word of the statute, including every discrete | |
| application of the provision, section, subsection, sentence, | |
| clause, phrase, or word to any person, group of persons, or | |
| circumstance, is severable. | |
| (b) If any application of any statutory provision, section, | |
| subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or word to any person, group | |
| of persons, or circumstance is determined by a court to be invalid, | |
| preempted, or unconstitutional, regardless of the reason, all | |
| remaining applications of that statutory provision, section, | |
| subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or word to any other person, | |
| group of persons, or circumstance shall be severed and preserved | |
| and remain in effect. | |
| (c) It is the intent of the legislature that every valid, | |
| non-preempted, and constitutional application of its statutory | |
| enactments be allowed to stand alone and remain enforceable. | |
| (d) A court may not decline to enforce the severability | |
| requirements of this section on the grounds that the severance | |
| would rewrite the statute or involve the court in legislative or | |
| lawmaking activity. A court that declines to enforce, or that | |
| enjoins a state official from enforcing, wholly or partly, a | |
| statute is not considered to be rewriting a statute or engaging in | |
| legislative or lawmaking activity because the statute continues to | |
| contain the same words as before the court's decision. A judicial | |
| injunction or declaration of unconstitutionality: | |
| (1) is only an edict prohibiting enforcement of the | |
| disputed statute against the parties to that lawsuit and may | |
| subsequently be vacated by a higher court based on a different | |
| understanding of the law; | |
| (2) is not a formal amendment of the language in a | |
| statute; and | |
| (3) does not rewrite the statute any more than a | |
| decision by the executive not to enforce a duly enacted statute in a | |
| limited and defined set of circumstances. | |
| (e) If a court, in violation of this section, declares or | |
| finds any statutory provision, section, subsection, sentence, | |
| clause, phrase, or word to be facially or totally invalid, | |
| preempted, or unconstitutional, when there are discrete | |
| applications of that statutory provision, section, subsection, | |
| sentence, clause, phrase, or word that could be enforced against a | |
| person, group of persons, or circumstance without violating federal | |
| law or the federal or state constitutions, then that statutory | |
| provision, section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or word | |
| shall be interpreted, as a matter of state law, as if the | |
| legislature had explicitly limited its application to the person, | |
| group of persons, or circumstance for which its application will | |
| not violate federal law or the federal or state constitutions, and | |
| every court shall adopt and apply this saving construction until | |
| the court ruling declaring the statutory provision, section, | |
| subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or word facially or totally | |
| invalid, preempted, or unconstitutional is vacated or overturned. | |
| SECTION 10. Sections 311.021, 311.023, 311.032, 312.005, | |
| 312.006, 312.012, and 312.013, Government Code, are repealed. | |
| SECTION 11. This Act takes effect September 1, 2025. |
Official text from the Texas Legislature. Formatting has been adapted for reading on Ratifi.