Ratifi Español Sign in
Ratifi

Federal bills from Congress.gov. State bills from Open States.

SB 1504Session 2025-2026

An Act amending Title 35 (Health and Safety) of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, providing for dispute resolution; and making a repeal.

Printer's No. PN2049

See other bills
under the
same topic PRINTER'S NO. 2049 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIASENATE BILL No.1504 Session of 2026 INTRODUCED BY BROOKS AND STEFANO, OCTOBER 15, 2026 REFERRED TO HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, OCTOBER 15, 2026 AN ACTAmending Title 35 (Health and Safety) of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, providing for dispute resolution; and making a repeal.The General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania hereby enacts as follows:Section 1. Part II of Title 35 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes is amended by adding a chapter to read:CHAPTER 35DISPUTE RESOLUTIONSubchapterA. Preliminary ProvisionsB. Informal Dispute Resolution for Long-Term Care Nursing FacilitiesC. Informal Dispute Resolution for HospitalsD. Formal Dispute Resolution for HospitalsSUBCHAPTER APRELIMINARY PROVISIONSSec.3501. Scope of chapter.12345678910111213141516171819 3502. Definitions.3503. Notice of how to dispute deficiencies.§ 3501. Scope of chapter.This chapter relates to:(1) An informal dispute resolution process for long-term care nursing facilities.(2) An informal dispute resolution process for hospitals.(3) A formal dispute resolution process for hospitals.§ 3502. Definitions.The following words and phrases when used in this chapter shall have the meanings given to them in this section unless the context clearly indicates otherwise:"Arbitration organization." An association, agency, board, commission or other entity that is neutral and initiates, sponsors or administers an arbitration proceeding or is involved in the appointment of an arbitrator, including an organization with expertise in health care disputes, such as the American Health Lawyers Association, the American Arbitration Association or similar entity with relevant health care regulatory knowledge."Arbitrator." An individual who:(1) is appointed or employed to render a decision, alone or with others, in a controversy subject to dispute under Subchapter D (relating to formal dispute resolution for hospitals); and(2) has relevant expertise in health care regulations, laws or practices."Deficiency." With respect to a long-term care nursing facility or hospital, the alleged noncompliance of the long-term 20260SB1504PN2049 - 2 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 care nursing facility or hospital with a requirement under any of the following:(1) The Social Security Act (49 Stat. 620, 42 U.S.C. § 301 et seq.).(2) 42 CFR Pt. 483 Subpt. B (relating to requirements for long term care facilities).(3) The act of July 19, 1979 (P.L.130, No.48), known as the Health Care Facilities Act.(4) 28 Pa. Code Pt. IV Subpt. B Ch. 101 (relating to general information) or Subpt. C (relating to long-term care facilities), as applicable."Department." The Department of Health of the Commonwealth."Hospital." As defined in section 802.1 of the Health Care Facilities Act."Independent IDR." An appeal process conducted by an independent IDR agent, in compliance with 42 CFR 488.331 (relating to informal dispute resolution), by which a long-term care nursing facility or hospital may challenge deficiencies cited during a survey and certification inspection by the department."Independent IDR agent." The entity designated by the department to conduct an independent IDR on its behalf."Informal dispute resolution" or "IDR." An appeal process within the department, in compliance with 42 CFR 488.331, by which a long-term care nursing facility or hospital may challenge deficiencies cited during a survey and certification inspection by the department."Long-term care nursing facility." As follows:(1) A facility that provides skilled or intermediate nursing care, or both levels of care, to two or more 20260SB1504PN2049 - 3 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 patients, who are unrelated to the licensee, for a period exceeding 24 hours.(2) The term does not include an intermediate care facility exclusively for individuals who are intellectually disabled."Plan of correction." A long-term care nursing facility's or hospital's response to deficiencies that explain:(1) The manner by which corrective action will be accomplished.(2) The manner by which the long-term care nursing facility or hospital will identify other residents who might be affected by the deficient practice.(3) The measures that will be used or systemic changes that will be made by the long-term care nursing facility or hospital to ensure that the deficient practice will not recur.(4) The manner by which the long-term care nursing facility or hospital will monitor its operations to ensure that corrective actions are sustained."QIO." A federally designated Medicare quality improvement organization."State Operations Manual." The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services State Operations Manual."Statement of deficiencies." Written notice by the department to a long-term care nursing facility or hospital specifying the items of noncompliance found upon completion of a survey."Survey." An inspection of a long-term care nursing facility or hospital conducted by representatives of the department in accordance with Federal or State laws, regulations, standards 20260SB1504PN2049 - 4 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 and survey procedures, including applicable procedures outlined in the State Operations Manual.§ 3503. Notice of how to dispute deficiencies.(a) Requirement.--Upon issuance of a finding of deficiency under this chapter, the department shall provide written notice of all available rights to dispute deficiencies, including the rights under this chapter, to the long-term care nursing facility under Subchapter B (relating to informal dispute resolution for long-term care nursing facilities) or the hospital under Subchapter C (relating to informal dispute resolution for hospitals) or D (relating to formal dispute resolution for hospitals) that is the subject of the deficiency.(b) Contents.--The written notice under subsection (a) must include a clear explanation of the procedures and the applicable timelines to dispute deficiencies.(c) Duty of department.--The department shall maintain a standardized form for the notice described under this section.SUBCHAPTER BINFORMAL DISPUTE RESOLUTIONFOR LONG-TERM CARE NURSING FACILITIESSec.3511. Purpose and intent.3512. Informal dispute resolution process.3513. Data collection.3514. Liability and responsibility.§ 3511. Purpose and intent.The purpose of this subchapter is to establish an informal review process for long-term care nursing facilities to dispute Department of Health survey findings using an independent agent. This informal review process is intended to ensure that a 20260SB1504PN2049 - 5 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 statement of deficiencies, as maintained in Federal and State data systems, accurately identifies a long-term care nursing facility's actual state of compliance with applicable regulations by providing nursing facilities with the opportunity to redress grievances arising during the survey process prior to the entry of the survey results in the Federal data system and without need to engage in formal litigation.§ 3512. Informal dispute resolution process. (a) Establishment of an independent IDR process.--(1) The department shall establish an IDR process to determine whether a cited deficiency contained in a statement of deficiencies against a long-term care nursing facility should be upheld.(2) (i) The department shall designate Pennsylvania's QIO as the independent IDR agent.(ii) If Pennsylvania's QIO is unable to serve as the independent IDR agent, the department, in consultation with the Health Policy Board, shall designate the QIO of another state that has experience in conducting informal dispute resolutions for a state survey agency as the independent IDR agent.(iii) If no other QIO is available to serve as the independent IDR agent, the department, in consultation with the Health Policy Board, shall designate as the independent IDR agent an independent review organization that is accredited by the Utilization Review Accreditation Commission.(iv) The department shall enter into a sole source contract with the independent IDR agent as necessary to implement the provisions of this subchapter.20260SB1504PN2049 - 6 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (3) The department shall obtain all necessary approvals from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to contract with the independent IDR process.(4) The independent IDR agent shall offer long-term care nursing facilities that request the independent IDR process a choice of the following levels of review:(i) desk review;(ii) telephone review; or(iii) in-person review, including the utilization of video conferencing.(5) The independent IDR process may not replace or be a substitute for the existing informal dispute resolution process conducted by the department, but shall be an optional process that can be selected by long-term care nursing facilities on a fee-for-service basis.(6) The fee for the independent IDR process shall be established by the independent IDR agent, provided that the fees are approved by the department and consistent with law.(7) Independent IDR recommendations made by the independent IDR agent shall be subject to final review and approval by the department.(b) Minimum requirements of the independent IDR process.--(1) The department shall establish written policies and procedures governing the independent IDR process that comply with the provisions of 42 CFR 488.331 (relating to informal dispute resolution) and the State Operations Manual regarding the informal dispute resolution process.(2) The independent IDR procedures must include the following:(i) Within 10 business days of the end of the 20260SB1504PN2049 - 7 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 survey, the department shall, by certified mail or by the intranet of the department, if the long-term care nursing facility is connected to the intranet, transmit to the long-term care nursing facility a statement of alleged deficiencies.(ii) A long-term care nursing facility may request that an informal dispute resolution review be conducted by:(A) department staff not associated with the survey, at no charge; or(B) an independent IDR by the independent IDR agent designated by the department on a fee-for- service basis.(iii) A long-term care nursing facility may select only one method of review under subparagraph (ii).(iv) A long-term care nursing facility must submit its request for an independent IDR review and indicate its selection of the type of review and level of review in writing within the same 10-day period applicable to the long-term care nursing facility for submission of the plan of correction.(3) (i) Within 45 days of receipt of the request for an independent IDR by a long-term care nursing facility, the independent IDR agent shall issue a written decision to the long-term care nursing facility based upon its review of the facts, survey findings, State Operations Manual and applicable law.(ii) If the independent IDR agent sustains the deficiency, the independent IDR agent's written determination shall include the rationale for its 20260SB1504PN2049 - 8 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 decision and provide recommended action that the long-term care nursing facility can implement to achieve compliance.(iii) If the department disagrees with an independent IDR agent's determination that reverses a deficiency, the department shall provide a written explanation for its decision to nullify the independent IDR agent's report to the independent IDR agent and to the long-term care nursing facility.§ 3513. Data collection. T he department shall collect and maintain the following data: (1) The total number of review requests received on an annual basis, including the number of independent IDR requests and the number of State informal dispute resolution review requests.(2) The total number of independent IDRs completed, including the number of reviews that resulted in the removal of a deficiency, the number of reviews that resulted in the downgrade of a deficiency and the number of reviews that upheld a deficiency.(3) The total number of State informal dispute resolution reviews completed, including the number of reviews that resulted in the removal of a deficiency, the number of reviews that resulted in the downgrade of a deficiency and the number of reviews that upheld a deficiency.§ 3514. Liability and responsibility. Except as otherwise provided in this subchapter, nothing in this subchapter is intended to affect common law or statutory liability and responsibility of licensees.SUBCHAPTER C20260SB1504PN2049 - 9 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 INFORMAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION FOR HOSPITALSSec.3521. Purpose and intent.3522. Informal dispute resolution process.3523. Data collection.3524. Liability and responsibility.§ 3521. Purpose and intent.The purpose of this subchapter is to establish an informal review process to provide hospitals with the opportunity to dispute deficiencies arising from the survey process prior to the entry of the survey results in the Federal data system and without need to engage in formal litigation.§ 3522. Informal dispute resolution process. (a) Establishment of an independent IDR process.--(1) The department shall establish an IDR process to determine whether a cited deficiency contained in a statement of deficiencies against a hospital should be upheld.(2) (i) The department shall designate Pennsylvania's QIO as the independent IDR agent if the QIO is authorized and available to conduct independent IDR under this subchapter.(ii) If Pennsylvania's QIO is unable to serve as the independent IDR agent, the department, in consultation with the Health Policy Board, shall designate another QIO with appropriate experience or an independent review organization accredited by the Utilization Review Accreditation Commission.(iii) The department shall enter into a sole source contract with the independent IDR agent as necessary to implement the provisions of this subchapter.20260SB1504PN2049 - 10 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (3) The department shall seek to obtain any necessary approval from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to implement the independent IDR process.(4) The independent IDR agent shall offer hospitals that request the independent IDR process a choice of the following levels of review:(i) desk review;(ii) telephone review; or(iii) in-person review, including the utilization of video conferencing.(5) The independent IDR process shall be an optional process that can be selected by hospitals on a fee-for-service basis.(6) The fee for the independent IDR process shall be established by the independent IDR agent, provided that the fees are approved by the department and consistent with law.(7) Independent IDR recommendations made by the independent IDR agent shall be subject to final review and approval by the department.(b) Minimum requirements of the independent IDR process.--(1) The department shall establish written policies and procedures governing the independent IDR process that comply with applicable Federal and State law.(2) The independent IDR procedures must include the following:(i) Within 10 business days of the end of the survey, the department shall, by certified mail or by the intranet of the department, if the hospital is connected to the intranet, transmit to the hospital a statement of alleged deficiencies.20260SB1504PN2049 - 11 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (ii) A hospital may request that an informal dispute resolution review be conducted by:(A) department staff not associated with the survey, at no charge; or(B) an independent IDR by the independent IDR agent designated by the department on a fee-for- service basis.(iii) A hospital may select only one method of review under subparagraph (ii).(iv) A hospital must submit its request for an independent IDR review and indicate its selection of the type of review and level of review in writing within the same 10-day period applicable to the hospital for submission of the plan of correction.(3) (i) Within 45 days of receipt of the request for an independent IDR by a hospital, the independent IDR agent shall issue a written decision to the hospital based upon its review of the facts, survey findings, State Operations Manual and applicable law.(ii) If the independent IDR agent sustains the deficiency, the independent IDR agent's written determination shall include the rationale for its decision and provide recommended action that the hospital can implement to achieve compliance.(iii) If the department disagrees with an independent IDR agent's determination that reverses a deficiency, the department shall provide a written explanation for its decision to nullify the independent IDR agent's report to the independent IDR agent and to the hospital.20260SB1504PN2049 - 12 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 § 3523. Data collection. T he department shall collect and maintain the following data under this subchapter:(1) The total number of review requests received on an annual basis, including the number of independent IDR requests and the number of State informal dispute resolution review requests.(2) The total number of independent IDRs completed, including the number of reviews that resulted in the removal of a deficiency, the number of reviews that resulted in the downgrade of a deficiency and the number of reviews that upheld a deficiency.(3) The total number of State informal dispute resolution reviews completed, including the number of reviews that resulted in the removal of a deficiency, the number of reviews that resulted in the downgrade of a deficiency and the number of reviews that upheld a deficiency.§ 3524. Liability and responsibility. Except as otherwise provided in this subchapter, nothing in this subchapter is intended to affect common law or statutory liability and responsibility of licensees.SUBCHAPTER DFORMAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION FOR HOSPITALSSec.3531. Right to pursue.3532. Notice of intent.3533. Consolidation.3534. Arbitrators.3535. Hearing.3536. Final decision.20260SB1504PN2049 - 13 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 3537. Costs.3538. Construction.3539. Data collection and reporting.§ 3531. Right to pursue.A hospital may pursue formal dispute resolution regarding substantial and bona fide disputes of deficiencies that are cited during a survey and that:(1) involve immediate jeopardy findings for open hospitals;(2) prevent a closed hospital from reopening;(3) prevent a hospital that has not yet opened from beginning operations; or(4) involve State-assessed penalties amounting to $10,000 or more in the aggregate.§ 3532. Notice of intent.A hospital that wishes to pursue formal dispute resolution under this subchapter shall, not later than 10 days after receiving formal communication of deficiencies, provide to the department written notice of intent to pursue formal dispute resolution.§ 3533. Consolidation.All disputes of deficiencies contested under this subchapter by a hospital must be consolidated into a single dispute resolution proceeding such that the hospital may not appeal each finding as to deficiencies separately but must address all contested matters in a single dispute resolution process.§ 3534. Arbitrators.(a) Selection.--(1) Under the formal dispute resolution process:(i) a hospital shall select a single arbitrator with 20260SB1504PN2049 - 14 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 the mutual consent and agreement of the department; or(ii) each party shall select one arbitrator, who shall then jointly appoint a neutral third-party arbitrator.(2) Arbitrators shall be selected from an arbitration organization.(b) Disclosure.--Before accepting an appointment, an arbitrator must disclose to all parties any known facts that could affect the arbitrator's impartiality, including financial or personal interests in the outcome, and any prior relationships with the parties, counsel or witnesses.§ 3535. Hearing.(a) Scheduling and notice.--As soon as practicable, but not later than 10 days after receiving a request for a hearing, the arbitrators shall:(1) Fix a date for the hearing.(2) Notify both parties of the time and place of the hearing.(b) Purpose.--The purpose of the hearing is to:(1) facilitate a negotiated resolution or compromise; or(2) provide final resolution through the issuance of a binding ruling.(c) Conduct.--(1) The hearing shall be conducted by all the arbitrators but a majority may determine any issue and render a final decision.(2) If, during the course of the hearing, an arbitrator for any reason ceases to act, the remaining arbitrator or arbitrators appointed to act as neutrals may continue with the hearing and determine the controversy.20260SB1504PN2049 - 15 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 § 3536. Final decision.(a) Authorization.--If a compromise cannot be reached, the arbitrators shall be empowered to issue a decision that shall be binding on both parties.(b) Written and signed.--The decision of the arbitrators shall be in writing and shall be signed by the arbitrators.(c) Delivery.--The arbitrators shall deliver a copy of the decision to each party personally or by registered or certified mail, or as otherwise agreed to by the parties.(d) Deficiencies.-- If a hospital is successful during the formal dispute resolution process at demonstrating that deficiencies should not have been cited, the deficiencies shall be removed from the statement of deficiencies and any enforcement actions imposed solely as a result of those cited deficiencies shall be rescinded.§ 3537. Costs.(a) General rule.-- Except as provided in subsection (b), the hospital involved in the formal dispute resolution process shall pay the costs incurred in the conduct of the formal dispute resolution process. Costs shall include the expenses and fees of the arbitrators and other administrative expenses, except counsel fees.(b) Exception.--Notwithstanding subsection (a), the arbitrators may award the costs under subsection (a) to the hospital as the prevailing party or may allocate the costs if the department has engaged in willful or malicious misconduct against the hospital.§ 3538. Construction.Nothing in this subchapter shall be construed to affect or impair the right of a hospital to seek other relief permitted by 20260SB1504PN2049 - 16 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 law, including the rights of judicial review under 2 Pa.C.S. Ch. 7 (relating to judicial review).§ 3539. Data collection and reporting.(a) Data.--T he department shall collect and maintain the following data:(1) The total number of formal dispute resolution review requests.(2) The total number of formal dispute resolution reviews completed, including the number of reviews that resulted in the removal of a deficiency, the number of reviews that resulted in the downgrade of a deficiency and the number of reviews that upheld a deficiency.(b) Reporting.--The department shall:(1) Report the findings under subsection (a) to the General Assembly on an annual basis.(2) Post the findings under subsection (a) on the publicly accessible Internet website of the department, with a redaction of identifying information regarding the hospitals under the formal dispute resolution process.Section 2. Repeals are as follows:(1) The General Assembly declares that the repeal under paragraph (2) is necessary to effectuate the addition of 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 35 Subchs. A and B.(2) The act of December 22, 2011 (P.L.592, No.128), known as the Long-Term Care Nursing Facility Independent Informal Dispute Resolution Act, is repealed.Section 3. The addition of 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 35 Subchs. A and B is a continuation of the act of December 22, 2011 (P.L.592, No.128), known as the Long-Term Care Nursing Facility Independent Informal Dispute Resolution Act. The following 20260SB1504PN2049 - 17 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 apply:(1) Except as otherwise provided in 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 35 Subchs. A and B, all activities initiated under the Long-Term Care Nursing Facility Independent Informal Dispute Resolution Act shall continue and remain in full force and effect and may be completed under 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 35 Subchs. A and B. Orders, regulations, rules and decisions which were made under the Long-Term Care Nursing Facility Independent Informal Dispute Resolution Act and which are in effect on the effective date of section 2 of this act shall remain in full force and effect until revoked, vacated or modified under 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 35 Subchs. A and B. Contracts, obligations and collective bargaining agreements entered into under the Long-Term Care Nursing Facility Independent Informal Dispute Resolution Act are not affected nor impaired by the repeal of the Long-Term Care Nursing Facility Independent Informal Dispute Resolution Act.(2) Except as set forth in paragraph (3), any difference in language between 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 35 Subchs. A and B and the Long-Term Care Nursing Facility Independent Informal Dispute Resolution Act is intended only to conform to the style of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes and is not intended to change or affect the legislative intent, judicial construction or administration and implementation of the Long-Term Care Nursing Facility Independent Informal Dispute Resolution Act.(3) Paragraph (2) does not apply to the addition of the following provisions:(i) The definitions of "arbitration organization," "arbitrator," "deficiency," "hospital," "long-term care 20260SB1504PN2049 - 18 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 nursing facility," "plan of correction," "statement of deficiencies" and "survey" in 35 Pa.C.S. § 3502.(ii) 35 Pa.C.S. § 3503.Section 4. This act shall take effect in 60 days.20260SB1504PN2049 - 19 - 1234

Official text from the Pennsylvania Legislature. Formatting has been adapted for reading on Ratifi.