Printer's No. PN3884
See other bills
under the
same topic PRINTER'S NO. 3884 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIAHOUSE BILL No.2776 Session of 2026 INTRODUCED BY RABB, PROBST, WAXMAN, PASHINSKI, OTTEN, FLEMING AND INGLIS, SEPTEMBER 16, 2026 REFERRED TO COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION, SEPTEMBER 18, 2026 AN ACTAmending Title 24 (Education) of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, in preliminary provisions, providing for religious neutrality and freedom of conscience in public schools.The General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania hereby enacts as follows:Section 1. Title 24 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes is amended by adding a chapter to read:CHAPTER 5RELIGIOUS NEUTRALITY AND FREEDOM OFCONSCIENCE IN PUBLIC SCHOOLSSec.501. Construction.502. Definitions.503. Age-appropriate protections for student religious expression.504. Prohibited acts.505. Protected student and employee expression and accommodation.123456789101112131415161718 506. Enforcement by commission.507. Judicial review and remedies.508. Guidance and training.509. Regulations.510. Severability.§ 501. Construction.This chapter shall be construed in pari materia with the act of October 27, 1955 (P.L.744, No.222), known as the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act, and shall not be interpreted to diminish a right or remedy available under Federal or State law, including 20 U.S.C. Ch. 52 Subch. VIII (relating to equal access) and the act of December 9, 2002 (P.L.1701, No.214), known as the Religious Freedom Protection Act. Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to restrict, limit or diminish any student or school employee's right to religious or nonreligious expression not addressed by this chapter.§ 502. Definitions.The following words and phrases when used in this chapter shall have the meanings given to them in this section unless the context clearly indicates otherwise:"Academic study of religion." The objective, secular instruction concerning religion as a subject of history, literature, culture or social studies, presented without endorsement or denigration and consistent with academic standards, including comparative religion, history of religion and the role of religion in literature, culture, art and music."Coerce." The exertion of direct or indirect pressure that would cause a reasonable student, of similar age and in similar circumstances, to participate in or refrain from religious activity against conscience.20260HB2776PN3884 - 2 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 "Commission." The Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission."Consent." A voluntary, affirmative and informed agreement that may be terminated at any time for any reason by a student to participate in a religious activity, given freely without coercion, pressure, inducement or fear of retaliation. The term does not include an inference from silence, attendance at a school event or prior participation or compliance with the authority of a school official."Covered person." Any of the following individuals or persons that allege a violation of this chapter:(1) A student, parent or guardian acting on behalf of a minor student.(2) A school employee, including an individual who contracts to perform a function for a school.(3) A student organization registered with or seeking recognition from a school."Devotional expression." Communication that is addressed to a deity or that invites, leads or directs an audience to engage in an act of worship, prayer or religious ritual."Graduation or promotion ceremony." A school event marking completion of a grade level, program or educational milestone, including a commencement exercise, promotion ceremony, award ceremony and a ceremony that is substantially similar in purpose or function."Instructional time." A portion of the school day when a student is engaged in required curricular instruction under the direct supervision of a school official teaching a curriculum. The term does not include time before or after the official school day, lunch, recess, a period between classes, study hall or other noncurricular break.20260HB2776PN3884 - 3 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 "Nonparticipatory capacity." Presence at a student religious organization's meeting or activity solely to maintain order and ensure safety without lecturing, proselytizing, praying, preaching, planning religious content or otherwise engaging in, encouraging, discouraging or influencing the activity."Official capacity." An action taken by a school official while performing a duty or exercising authority conferred by employment."Religious activity." Prayer, worship, religious instruction, proselytizing or devotional observance. The term includes an expression, devotional expression, observance or practice motivated by a sincerely held religious belief, whether or not formal or structured."Religious display." A permanent or semipermanent display placed or maintained by a school official in an official capacity and selected, controlled, funded, required or officially attributed by the school as promoting or disparaging religious belief. The term does not include:(1) an objective curricular display;(2) student work selected under neutral criteria;(3) a historical or cultural exhibit;(4) use of a shared facility by a private group on the same terms as other private groups; or(5) incidental religious imagery in art, literature, music or history instruction."Religious dress or adornment." Clothing, jewelry, accessory, hairstyle, marking or item worn on or presented on the body as a manifestation of a sincerely held religious belief or religious activity. The term includes a hairstyle historically associated with a religious creed.20260HB2776PN3884 - 4 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 "School." A public school entity established under State law, including a school district, charter school or cyber charter school, regional charter school, intermediate unit or area career and technical school, that receives public funding and is subject to the supervision of the department."School event." A gathering, ceremony, assembly or activity organized, conducted or hosted by a school in the institutional capacity of the school, including a graduation or promotion ceremony, school assembly and a school-organized extracurricular event. The term does not include:(1) a student religious organization's meeting or activity, if every school official present acts in a nonparticipatory capacity;(2) an activity at a school facility outside the presence of students, at which no school official acts in an official capacity; or(3) use of a school facility by a private party under a standard facility use agreement or written permission specifying the user, use period, facility, purpose and conditions of use, if the use:(i) occurs on the same terms available to other private users;(ii) involves no school official acting in an official capacity; and(iii) does not occur during the school day."School official." A teacher, administrator, coach, counselor, aide, contracted employee, substitute teacher employed by a school or supplied by a third-party contractor, volunteer, guest speaker, school resource officer, school board or governing board member or other individual employed by, under 20260HB2776PN3884 - 5 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 contract with or authorized to act on behalf of a school in a supervisory, instructional, ceremonial or policy-making capacity. The term does not include a student."School-sponsored activity." As follows:(1) An activity that:(i) is attributable to a school rather than to an individual student, employee or speaker; or(ii) a school official acting in an official capacity organizes, directs, leads or affirmatively adopts.(2) The term does not include an activity that is initiated by a student or is permitted, authorized or subject to:(i) routine supervision by a school official acting in a nonparticipatory capacity for purposes of safety, order or facility management;(ii) a school official's service as a required or optional adviser to a student organization where the official does not select or direct the organization's religious content or leadership; or(iii) age-appropriate permission or notification requirements applied consistent with section 503(c) (relating to age-appropriate protections for student religious expression)."Sincerely held religious belief." A genuine religious conviction held by an individual, without regard to whether the belief is required by the official doctrine of a religion or is held by other members of the same religion.§ 503. Age-appropriate protections for student religious expression.20260HB2776PN3884 - 6 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (a) No consent exception.--No student consent, parental or guardian permission, opt-out or characterization of attendance as voluntary shall authorize, excuse or cure conduct prohibited under section 504 (relating to prohibited acts) regardless of a student's grade level.(b) Protected expression at all grade levels.--Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to prohibit voluntary, student-initiated religious or nonreligious expression that constitutes private student speech, regardless of the student's grade level, in accordance with section 505 (relating to protected student and employee expression and accommodation).(c) Age-appropriate permission and supervision.--(1) A school may apply age-appropriate permission slip, parental notification or supervision requirements to student participation in a religious activity, or activity initiated by a student, provided the requirements are applied only on the same terms as comparable secular student organizations or activities of the same type. A requirement applied consistent with this subsection does not render the activity a school-sponsored activity.(2) In determining whether a religious activity is motivated by a sincerely held religious belief under this subsection or other provision of this chapter, a school official may not inquire into the validity, correctness or plausibility of the religious belief itself.(d) Equal Access Act compliance.--Nothing in this section shall be construed to prevent a public secondary school from complying with the Equal Access Act (Public Law 98-377, 20 U.S.C. Ch. 52 Subch. VIII), including permitting a student religious organization to meet on school premises during 20260HB2776PN3884 - 7 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 noninstructional time with a school employee present in a nonparticipatory capacity. The permission does not constitute school sponsorship for purposes of this chapter.§ 504. Prohibited acts.(a) Acting in official capacity.--(1) In determining whether a school official acted in an official capacity, the totality of the objective circumstances shall be considered, including:(i) whether the school created, commissioned or selected the specific communication of the school official;(ii) whether the school official was performing an assigned instructional, supervisory or ceremonial role;(iii) whether the school controlled or approved the content of the communication;(iv) whether the school official participated in an activity in which students were a captive audience subject to the school official's authority;(v) whether the school official communicated to students through an official school communication channel; and(vi) whether the school official was on personal or noninstructional time.(2) A school official does not act in an official capacity under paragraph (1) if the school official makes a genuinely personal expression, regardless of whether the school official is present on school property or otherwise on duty.(b) Proof of coercion.--(1) Coercion may be proven by conduct including:20260HB2776PN3884 - 8 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (i) conditioning a grade, privilege, honor or favorable treatment on participation or nonparticipation in religious activity;(ii) repeated solicitation of a student to participate after the student has declined;(iii) singling out a student for differential treatment based on participation, nonparticipation or religious belief; or(iv) subjecting a student to ridicule, exclusion or disciplinary consequence for declining to participate.(2) A finding of coercion does not require proof that a school official intended to coerce a student, provided the effect of the school official's conduct would cause a reasonable student of similar age and in similar circumstances to feel compelled to participate or refrain from participating against conscience.(c) School and school official actions.--A school or school official acting in an official capacity may not:(1) Discriminate against a student on the basis of religious belief or nonbelief. For purposes of this paragraph, discrimination includes conduct that would constitute discrimination on the basis of religious creed, as that term is defined under the act of October 27, 1955 (P.L.744, No.222), known as the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act.(2) Coerce a student to participate in or refrain from religious activity or direct, lead, require, solicit or knowingly use official authority to engage a student in religious activity. Student consent, parental or guardian permission or characterization of attendance as voluntary 20260HB2776PN3884 - 9 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 does not authorize conduct otherwise prohibited by this paragraph, in accordance with section 503(a) (relating to age-appropriate protections for student religious expression).(3) Sponsor, organize, direct, lead or affirmatively adopt religious activity at a school event or during instructional time or at any other time or place if the school official exercises governmental authority over students. This paragraph does not prohibit a school official from providing a reasonable accommodation under section 505(b) (relating to protected student and employee expression and accommodation) or engaging in personal expression protected under this chapter.(4) Incorporate religious doctrine or worship into required curriculum, including presenting creationism or intelligent design as scientific alternatives to evolution, or otherwise present a theological doctrine, a profession of religious faith or a disavowal of religious faith as the school's authoritative position. Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to require a student or school official to adopt, affirm or disavow a religious or nonreligious belief. This paragraph does not apply to academic study of religion and shall not prohibit a school official from:(i) providing evidence-based instruction consistent with applicable academic standards;(ii) responding to a student's question about a religious or philosophical viewpoint, including creationism or intelligent design, by accurately describing the viewpoint and its relationship to the current academic and scientific consensus without 20260HB2776PN3884 - 10 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 endorsing or disparaging the viewpoint; or(iii) declining to affirm or disavow the truth of a religious or nonreligious belief.(5) Maintain permanent or recurring school-sponsored religious displays on school property.(d) Graduation and promotion ceremonies.--(1) Religious activity that is a school-sponsored activity may not occur during a graduation or promotion ceremony, regardless of whether attendance at the ceremony is mandatory or voluntary.(2) Nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit or limit:(i) Private religious activity, including a student's wearing of religious dress or adornment in accordance with section 505(d).(ii) A school's authority to enforce its code of student conduct and other generally applicable, content-neutral standards applicable to student speakers, as permitted by Federal and State law.(e) No opt-out substitution.--The availability of an opt-out, alternative activity or absence from a ceremony shall not constitute consent or cure a violation of this chapter.§ 505. Protected student and employee expression and accommodation.(a) Existing student expression protections preserved.--Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to limit, and this chapter shall be construed consistently with, a student's rights to voluntary religious or nonreligious expression, including in coursework, student publications and peer interactions, in accordance with Federal and State law. This chapter does not 20260HB2776PN3884 - 11 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 create new restrictions on student expression beyond the prohibitions on school and school official conduct as provided in section 504 (relating to prohibited acts).(b) Accommodation.--(1) A school shall provide reasonable accommodation of a student's religious practice upon request, unless:(i) the school demonstrates that doing so would materially disrupt operations or compromise safety; or(ii) a request implicates a substantial burden on religious exercise and the school can demonstrate that denial is the least restrictive means of furthering a compelling governmental interest, consistent with the act of December 9, 2002 (P.L.1701, No.214), known as the Religious Freedom Protection Act.(2) An accommodation provided under this subsection, including the assignment of space in a school facility, time or routine supervision, does not by itself render the accommodation a school-sponsored activity.(3) A request under this subsection may be made by a student or by a parent or guardian on behalf of a student under 18 years of age.(4) A school shall decide a request within a reasonable time on events that are not imminent and on an expedited basis where the request concerns an imminent event.(5) If a school denies a request, the school shall state the reasons for any denial in writing and include whether a less restrictive alternative was considered.(6) A school may not retaliate against a student, parent or guardian for making a request under this subsection.(c) Employee personal expression.--20260HB2776PN3884 - 12 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (1) Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to prohibit a school employee from engaging in personal religious or nonreligious expression, including private prayer, if the school employee:(i) Is not acting in an official capacity.(ii) Does not direct, invite, require or pressure student participation.(iii) Complies with neutral rules governing time, place, manner and the performance of assigned duties.(2) This subsection does not authorize conduct otherwise prohibited under section 504.(d) Religious dress and adornment.--(1) A school may not prohibit, restrict or penalize a student or school employee for wearing religious dress or adornment unless the school demonstrates that the specific item:(i) poses a genuine and particularized safety risk that cannot be addressed through a valid, tailored and equally applied health or safety requirement;(ii) constitutes a true threat against, or unlawful harassment of, a specific individual or material and substantial disruption of school operations, as distinct from the wearing of religious dress or adornment; or(iii) is restricted under a nondiscriminatory health or safety requirement or bona fide occupational qualification applied equally to comparable nonreligious attire or adornment.(2) A school may not rely on the mere discomfort, disagreement or objection of a student, employee or member of the public to an individual's religious dress or adornment as 20260HB2776PN3884 - 13 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 the basis for a finding under paragraph (1).(3) A student or school employee who has been subject of bullying, harassment or misconduct by others because of the student's or employee's religious dress, adornment or private religious expression is not, by itself, grounds to find that the dress, adornment or expression is disruptive or creates a safety concern. A school shall address the misconduct of the individuals responsible for the bullying, harassment or misconduct and may not restrict or penalize the student or employee who is the target of the bullying, harassment or misconduct as a means of resolving the bullying, harassment or misconduct.§ 506. Enforcement by commission.(a) Violation.--A violation of this chapter constitutes an unlawful discriminatory practice under the act of October 27, 1955 (P.L.744, No.222), known as the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act.(b) Administrative enforcement.--A complaint alleging a violation of this chapter must be filed with, and shall be adjudicated by, the commission in accordance with the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act. The commission shall process a complaint under this chapter on an expedited basis consistent with regulation promulgated under section 509 (relating to regulations) and may award the following relief:(1) A cease-and-desist order.(2) An affirmative compliance order.(3) An order directing correction or expungement of school records.(4) An order restoring organizational recognition or standing.20260HB2776PN3884 - 14 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (c) Exhaustion requirement.--(1) A civil action may not be commenced until the administrative remedies under the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act are exhausted or are deemed exhausted by a court of competent jurisdiction. The administrative remedies are exhausted or deemed exhausted if the commission dismisses the complaint, issues a notice permitting a civil action or fails to resolve the complaint no later than one year after filing, whichever occurs first.(2) Filing a civil action under subsection (e) terminates the commission's jurisdiction over the merits of the same claim. If the commission first issues a final adjudication on the merits, the exclusive remedy is judicial review of the adjudication under section 507(c) (relating to judicial review and remedies).(3) This subsection does not apply to an action described in subsection (d).(d) Preliminary injunctive relief.--(1) Notwithstanding subsection (c), a covered person may seek preliminary injunctive relief in the court in which a civil action under subsection (e) is or would be filed or, if the named party is a Commonwealth agency in Commonwealth Court, without exhausting the administrative remedies if:(i) the alleged violation is ongoing or imminent; and(ii) administrative review would not provide an adequate remedy before the harm occurs, including a violation involving an imminent graduation or promotion ceremony, an imminent school event or an imminent denial of a requested accommodation.20260HB2776PN3884 - 15 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (2) A covered person proceeding under this subsection may also bring the civil action described in subsection (e) without exhausting the administrative remedies.(e) Private right of action.--A covered person who has satisfied subsection (c) or who qualifies under subsection (d), may bring a civil action in a court of common pleas alleging a violation of this chapter and seeking the relief described in section 507(a).(f) Limitations period.--(1) A complaint under subsection (b) must be filed no later than 180 days after the alleged violation or, for a continuing violation, no later than 180 days after its most recent occurrence.(2) A civil action under subsection (e) must be commenced no later than two years after the earliest event described in subsection (c) permitting the action or, for an action proceeding under subsection (d), no later than 180 days after the alleged violation.§ 507. Judicial review and remedies.(a) Relief.--Relief available for violations of this chapter shall be consistent with the remedies available under the act of October 27, 1955 (P.L.744, No.222), known as the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act, and:(1) In a civil action under section 506(e) (relating to enforcement by commission), a covered person who prevails may be awarded, as appropriate:(i) Declaratory relief.(ii) Temporary and permanent injunctive relief.(iii) Compensatory and nominal damages, reasonable attorney fees and costs.20260HB2776PN3884 - 16 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (2) Notwithstanding 42 Pa.C.S. § 8541 (relating to governmental immunity generally), immunity is waived to the extent necessary to permit an award of the relief described in this subsection against a school for a violation of this chapter, provided that an award of damages against a school is subject to the limitations in 42 Pa.C.S. § 8553 (relating to limitations on damages). A school official found to have engaged in willful misconduct in violation of this chapter is not entitled to immunity for that conduct under 42 Pa.C.S. § 8550 (relating to willful misconduct) and may be individually liable for compensatory, nominal and punitive damages for such conduct.(3) The judicial remedies described in this section are available only through a civil action initiated under section 506(e).(b) Retaliation prohibited.--(1) A school or school official may not retaliate against a covered person for asserting a right established or making a request for accommodation or participating in a proceeding under this chapter.(2) A covered person may proceed in accordance with section 506, including under section 506(d), where applicable.(c) Judicial review of commission adjudications.--A final adjudication of the commission on the merits of a complaint under this chapter is subject to judicial review by Commonwealth Court in the manner provided by law for review of Commonwealth agency adjudications.(d) Whistleblower protection.--A school official is not subject to discipline or retaliation by a school for a good- 20260HB2776PN3884 - 17 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 faith report of a suspected violation of this chapter, regardless of the outcome of the report.(e) Definition.--As used in this section, "retaliation" means an adverse action taken against a covered person because the covered person filed, supported or was identified in connection with a complaint, request or proceeding under this chapter, including disciplinary action, exclusion from activities, reduction in academic recognition or interference with organizational status.§ 508. Guidance and training.The department, in consultation with the commission, shall issue, no later than 120 days after the effective date of this section, guidance, model policies and training materials to ensure compliance with this chapter, including an accommodation request procedure consistent with section 505(b) (relating to protected student and employee expression and accommodation) and consistent, objective criteria for determinations required under this chapter, to be applied uniformly by each school.§ 509. Regulations.(a) Duty of commission.--The commission shall promulgate, no later than 120 days after the effective date of this section, regulations governing complaints under this chapter, including complaint forms, investigation procedures, expedited review standards and any notice permitting a civil action under section 506(c) (relating to enforcement by commission), consistent with its existing authority to establish rules of practice under the act of October 27, 1955 (P.L.744, No.222), known as the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act.(b) Training by schools.--Each school shall provide training consistent with the regulation promulgated under this section to 20260HB2776PN3884 - 18 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 school officials no later than 90 days after the effective date of the regulation and annually thereafter.§ 510. Severability.If any provision of this chapter or its application to any person or circumstance is held invalid, the invalidity does not affect other provisions or applications of this chapter which can be given effect without the invalid provision or application and to this end the provisions of this chapter are declared severable.Section 2. This act shall take effect as follows:(1) The following shall take effect immediately:The addition of 24 Pa.C.S. § 509.This section.(2) The remainder of this act shall take effect 90 days after the publication of regulations under 24 Pa.C.S. § 509, or in one year, whichever is earlier.20260HB2776PN3884 - 19 - 12345678910111213141516
under the
same topic PRINTER'S NO. 3884 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIAHOUSE BILL No.2776 Session of 2026 INTRODUCED BY RABB, PROBST, WAXMAN, PASHINSKI, OTTEN, FLEMING AND INGLIS, SEPTEMBER 16, 2026 REFERRED TO COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION, SEPTEMBER 18, 2026 AN ACTAmending Title 24 (Education) of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, in preliminary provisions, providing for religious neutrality and freedom of conscience in public schools.The General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania hereby enacts as follows:Section 1. Title 24 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes is amended by adding a chapter to read:CHAPTER 5RELIGIOUS NEUTRALITY AND FREEDOM OFCONSCIENCE IN PUBLIC SCHOOLSSec.501. Construction.502. Definitions.503. Age-appropriate protections for student religious expression.504. Prohibited acts.505. Protected student and employee expression and accommodation.123456789101112131415161718 506. Enforcement by commission.507. Judicial review and remedies.508. Guidance and training.509. Regulations.510. Severability.§ 501. Construction.This chapter shall be construed in pari materia with the act of October 27, 1955 (P.L.744, No.222), known as the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act, and shall not be interpreted to diminish a right or remedy available under Federal or State law, including 20 U.S.C. Ch. 52 Subch. VIII (relating to equal access) and the act of December 9, 2002 (P.L.1701, No.214), known as the Religious Freedom Protection Act. Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to restrict, limit or diminish any student or school employee's right to religious or nonreligious expression not addressed by this chapter.§ 502. Definitions.The following words and phrases when used in this chapter shall have the meanings given to them in this section unless the context clearly indicates otherwise:"Academic study of religion." The objective, secular instruction concerning religion as a subject of history, literature, culture or social studies, presented without endorsement or denigration and consistent with academic standards, including comparative religion, history of religion and the role of religion in literature, culture, art and music."Coerce." The exertion of direct or indirect pressure that would cause a reasonable student, of similar age and in similar circumstances, to participate in or refrain from religious activity against conscience.20260HB2776PN3884 - 2 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 "Commission." The Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission."Consent." A voluntary, affirmative and informed agreement that may be terminated at any time for any reason by a student to participate in a religious activity, given freely without coercion, pressure, inducement or fear of retaliation. The term does not include an inference from silence, attendance at a school event or prior participation or compliance with the authority of a school official."Covered person." Any of the following individuals or persons that allege a violation of this chapter:(1) A student, parent or guardian acting on behalf of a minor student.(2) A school employee, including an individual who contracts to perform a function for a school.(3) A student organization registered with or seeking recognition from a school."Devotional expression." Communication that is addressed to a deity or that invites, leads or directs an audience to engage in an act of worship, prayer or religious ritual."Graduation or promotion ceremony." A school event marking completion of a grade level, program or educational milestone, including a commencement exercise, promotion ceremony, award ceremony and a ceremony that is substantially similar in purpose or function."Instructional time." A portion of the school day when a student is engaged in required curricular instruction under the direct supervision of a school official teaching a curriculum. The term does not include time before or after the official school day, lunch, recess, a period between classes, study hall or other noncurricular break.20260HB2776PN3884 - 3 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 "Nonparticipatory capacity." Presence at a student religious organization's meeting or activity solely to maintain order and ensure safety without lecturing, proselytizing, praying, preaching, planning religious content or otherwise engaging in, encouraging, discouraging or influencing the activity."Official capacity." An action taken by a school official while performing a duty or exercising authority conferred by employment."Religious activity." Prayer, worship, religious instruction, proselytizing or devotional observance. The term includes an expression, devotional expression, observance or practice motivated by a sincerely held religious belief, whether or not formal or structured."Religious display." A permanent or semipermanent display placed or maintained by a school official in an official capacity and selected, controlled, funded, required or officially attributed by the school as promoting or disparaging religious belief. The term does not include:(1) an objective curricular display;(2) student work selected under neutral criteria;(3) a historical or cultural exhibit;(4) use of a shared facility by a private group on the same terms as other private groups; or(5) incidental religious imagery in art, literature, music or history instruction."Religious dress or adornment." Clothing, jewelry, accessory, hairstyle, marking or item worn on or presented on the body as a manifestation of a sincerely held religious belief or religious activity. The term includes a hairstyle historically associated with a religious creed.20260HB2776PN3884 - 4 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 "School." A public school entity established under State law, including a school district, charter school or cyber charter school, regional charter school, intermediate unit or area career and technical school, that receives public funding and is subject to the supervision of the department."School event." A gathering, ceremony, assembly or activity organized, conducted or hosted by a school in the institutional capacity of the school, including a graduation or promotion ceremony, school assembly and a school-organized extracurricular event. The term does not include:(1) a student religious organization's meeting or activity, if every school official present acts in a nonparticipatory capacity;(2) an activity at a school facility outside the presence of students, at which no school official acts in an official capacity; or(3) use of a school facility by a private party under a standard facility use agreement or written permission specifying the user, use period, facility, purpose and conditions of use, if the use:(i) occurs on the same terms available to other private users;(ii) involves no school official acting in an official capacity; and(iii) does not occur during the school day."School official." A teacher, administrator, coach, counselor, aide, contracted employee, substitute teacher employed by a school or supplied by a third-party contractor, volunteer, guest speaker, school resource officer, school board or governing board member or other individual employed by, under 20260HB2776PN3884 - 5 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 contract with or authorized to act on behalf of a school in a supervisory, instructional, ceremonial or policy-making capacity. The term does not include a student."School-sponsored activity." As follows:(1) An activity that:(i) is attributable to a school rather than to an individual student, employee or speaker; or(ii) a school official acting in an official capacity organizes, directs, leads or affirmatively adopts.(2) The term does not include an activity that is initiated by a student or is permitted, authorized or subject to:(i) routine supervision by a school official acting in a nonparticipatory capacity for purposes of safety, order or facility management;(ii) a school official's service as a required or optional adviser to a student organization where the official does not select or direct the organization's religious content or leadership; or(iii) age-appropriate permission or notification requirements applied consistent with section 503(c) (relating to age-appropriate protections for student religious expression)."Sincerely held religious belief." A genuine religious conviction held by an individual, without regard to whether the belief is required by the official doctrine of a religion or is held by other members of the same religion.§ 503. Age-appropriate protections for student religious expression.20260HB2776PN3884 - 6 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (a) No consent exception.--No student consent, parental or guardian permission, opt-out or characterization of attendance as voluntary shall authorize, excuse or cure conduct prohibited under section 504 (relating to prohibited acts) regardless of a student's grade level.(b) Protected expression at all grade levels.--Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to prohibit voluntary, student-initiated religious or nonreligious expression that constitutes private student speech, regardless of the student's grade level, in accordance with section 505 (relating to protected student and employee expression and accommodation).(c) Age-appropriate permission and supervision.--(1) A school may apply age-appropriate permission slip, parental notification or supervision requirements to student participation in a religious activity, or activity initiated by a student, provided the requirements are applied only on the same terms as comparable secular student organizations or activities of the same type. A requirement applied consistent with this subsection does not render the activity a school-sponsored activity.(2) In determining whether a religious activity is motivated by a sincerely held religious belief under this subsection or other provision of this chapter, a school official may not inquire into the validity, correctness or plausibility of the religious belief itself.(d) Equal Access Act compliance.--Nothing in this section shall be construed to prevent a public secondary school from complying with the Equal Access Act (Public Law 98-377, 20 U.S.C. Ch. 52 Subch. VIII), including permitting a student religious organization to meet on school premises during 20260HB2776PN3884 - 7 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 noninstructional time with a school employee present in a nonparticipatory capacity. The permission does not constitute school sponsorship for purposes of this chapter.§ 504. Prohibited acts.(a) Acting in official capacity.--(1) In determining whether a school official acted in an official capacity, the totality of the objective circumstances shall be considered, including:(i) whether the school created, commissioned or selected the specific communication of the school official;(ii) whether the school official was performing an assigned instructional, supervisory or ceremonial role;(iii) whether the school controlled or approved the content of the communication;(iv) whether the school official participated in an activity in which students were a captive audience subject to the school official's authority;(v) whether the school official communicated to students through an official school communication channel; and(vi) whether the school official was on personal or noninstructional time.(2) A school official does not act in an official capacity under paragraph (1) if the school official makes a genuinely personal expression, regardless of whether the school official is present on school property or otherwise on duty.(b) Proof of coercion.--(1) Coercion may be proven by conduct including:20260HB2776PN3884 - 8 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (i) conditioning a grade, privilege, honor or favorable treatment on participation or nonparticipation in religious activity;(ii) repeated solicitation of a student to participate after the student has declined;(iii) singling out a student for differential treatment based on participation, nonparticipation or religious belief; or(iv) subjecting a student to ridicule, exclusion or disciplinary consequence for declining to participate.(2) A finding of coercion does not require proof that a school official intended to coerce a student, provided the effect of the school official's conduct would cause a reasonable student of similar age and in similar circumstances to feel compelled to participate or refrain from participating against conscience.(c) School and school official actions.--A school or school official acting in an official capacity may not:(1) Discriminate against a student on the basis of religious belief or nonbelief. For purposes of this paragraph, discrimination includes conduct that would constitute discrimination on the basis of religious creed, as that term is defined under the act of October 27, 1955 (P.L.744, No.222), known as the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act.(2) Coerce a student to participate in or refrain from religious activity or direct, lead, require, solicit or knowingly use official authority to engage a student in religious activity. Student consent, parental or guardian permission or characterization of attendance as voluntary 20260HB2776PN3884 - 9 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 does not authorize conduct otherwise prohibited by this paragraph, in accordance with section 503(a) (relating to age-appropriate protections for student religious expression).(3) Sponsor, organize, direct, lead or affirmatively adopt religious activity at a school event or during instructional time or at any other time or place if the school official exercises governmental authority over students. This paragraph does not prohibit a school official from providing a reasonable accommodation under section 505(b) (relating to protected student and employee expression and accommodation) or engaging in personal expression protected under this chapter.(4) Incorporate religious doctrine or worship into required curriculum, including presenting creationism or intelligent design as scientific alternatives to evolution, or otherwise present a theological doctrine, a profession of religious faith or a disavowal of religious faith as the school's authoritative position. Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to require a student or school official to adopt, affirm or disavow a religious or nonreligious belief. This paragraph does not apply to academic study of religion and shall not prohibit a school official from:(i) providing evidence-based instruction consistent with applicable academic standards;(ii) responding to a student's question about a religious or philosophical viewpoint, including creationism or intelligent design, by accurately describing the viewpoint and its relationship to the current academic and scientific consensus without 20260HB2776PN3884 - 10 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 endorsing or disparaging the viewpoint; or(iii) declining to affirm or disavow the truth of a religious or nonreligious belief.(5) Maintain permanent or recurring school-sponsored religious displays on school property.(d) Graduation and promotion ceremonies.--(1) Religious activity that is a school-sponsored activity may not occur during a graduation or promotion ceremony, regardless of whether attendance at the ceremony is mandatory or voluntary.(2) Nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit or limit:(i) Private religious activity, including a student's wearing of religious dress or adornment in accordance with section 505(d).(ii) A school's authority to enforce its code of student conduct and other generally applicable, content-neutral standards applicable to student speakers, as permitted by Federal and State law.(e) No opt-out substitution.--The availability of an opt-out, alternative activity or absence from a ceremony shall not constitute consent or cure a violation of this chapter.§ 505. Protected student and employee expression and accommodation.(a) Existing student expression protections preserved.--Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to limit, and this chapter shall be construed consistently with, a student's rights to voluntary religious or nonreligious expression, including in coursework, student publications and peer interactions, in accordance with Federal and State law. This chapter does not 20260HB2776PN3884 - 11 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 create new restrictions on student expression beyond the prohibitions on school and school official conduct as provided in section 504 (relating to prohibited acts).(b) Accommodation.--(1) A school shall provide reasonable accommodation of a student's religious practice upon request, unless:(i) the school demonstrates that doing so would materially disrupt operations or compromise safety; or(ii) a request implicates a substantial burden on religious exercise and the school can demonstrate that denial is the least restrictive means of furthering a compelling governmental interest, consistent with the act of December 9, 2002 (P.L.1701, No.214), known as the Religious Freedom Protection Act.(2) An accommodation provided under this subsection, including the assignment of space in a school facility, time or routine supervision, does not by itself render the accommodation a school-sponsored activity.(3) A request under this subsection may be made by a student or by a parent or guardian on behalf of a student under 18 years of age.(4) A school shall decide a request within a reasonable time on events that are not imminent and on an expedited basis where the request concerns an imminent event.(5) If a school denies a request, the school shall state the reasons for any denial in writing and include whether a less restrictive alternative was considered.(6) A school may not retaliate against a student, parent or guardian for making a request under this subsection.(c) Employee personal expression.--20260HB2776PN3884 - 12 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (1) Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to prohibit a school employee from engaging in personal religious or nonreligious expression, including private prayer, if the school employee:(i) Is not acting in an official capacity.(ii) Does not direct, invite, require or pressure student participation.(iii) Complies with neutral rules governing time, place, manner and the performance of assigned duties.(2) This subsection does not authorize conduct otherwise prohibited under section 504.(d) Religious dress and adornment.--(1) A school may not prohibit, restrict or penalize a student or school employee for wearing religious dress or adornment unless the school demonstrates that the specific item:(i) poses a genuine and particularized safety risk that cannot be addressed through a valid, tailored and equally applied health or safety requirement;(ii) constitutes a true threat against, or unlawful harassment of, a specific individual or material and substantial disruption of school operations, as distinct from the wearing of religious dress or adornment; or(iii) is restricted under a nondiscriminatory health or safety requirement or bona fide occupational qualification applied equally to comparable nonreligious attire or adornment.(2) A school may not rely on the mere discomfort, disagreement or objection of a student, employee or member of the public to an individual's religious dress or adornment as 20260HB2776PN3884 - 13 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 the basis for a finding under paragraph (1).(3) A student or school employee who has been subject of bullying, harassment or misconduct by others because of the student's or employee's religious dress, adornment or private religious expression is not, by itself, grounds to find that the dress, adornment or expression is disruptive or creates a safety concern. A school shall address the misconduct of the individuals responsible for the bullying, harassment or misconduct and may not restrict or penalize the student or employee who is the target of the bullying, harassment or misconduct as a means of resolving the bullying, harassment or misconduct.§ 506. Enforcement by commission.(a) Violation.--A violation of this chapter constitutes an unlawful discriminatory practice under the act of October 27, 1955 (P.L.744, No.222), known as the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act.(b) Administrative enforcement.--A complaint alleging a violation of this chapter must be filed with, and shall be adjudicated by, the commission in accordance with the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act. The commission shall process a complaint under this chapter on an expedited basis consistent with regulation promulgated under section 509 (relating to regulations) and may award the following relief:(1) A cease-and-desist order.(2) An affirmative compliance order.(3) An order directing correction or expungement of school records.(4) An order restoring organizational recognition or standing.20260HB2776PN3884 - 14 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (c) Exhaustion requirement.--(1) A civil action may not be commenced until the administrative remedies under the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act are exhausted or are deemed exhausted by a court of competent jurisdiction. The administrative remedies are exhausted or deemed exhausted if the commission dismisses the complaint, issues a notice permitting a civil action or fails to resolve the complaint no later than one year after filing, whichever occurs first.(2) Filing a civil action under subsection (e) terminates the commission's jurisdiction over the merits of the same claim. If the commission first issues a final adjudication on the merits, the exclusive remedy is judicial review of the adjudication under section 507(c) (relating to judicial review and remedies).(3) This subsection does not apply to an action described in subsection (d).(d) Preliminary injunctive relief.--(1) Notwithstanding subsection (c), a covered person may seek preliminary injunctive relief in the court in which a civil action under subsection (e) is or would be filed or, if the named party is a Commonwealth agency in Commonwealth Court, without exhausting the administrative remedies if:(i) the alleged violation is ongoing or imminent; and(ii) administrative review would not provide an adequate remedy before the harm occurs, including a violation involving an imminent graduation or promotion ceremony, an imminent school event or an imminent denial of a requested accommodation.20260HB2776PN3884 - 15 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (2) A covered person proceeding under this subsection may also bring the civil action described in subsection (e) without exhausting the administrative remedies.(e) Private right of action.--A covered person who has satisfied subsection (c) or who qualifies under subsection (d), may bring a civil action in a court of common pleas alleging a violation of this chapter and seeking the relief described in section 507(a).(f) Limitations period.--(1) A complaint under subsection (b) must be filed no later than 180 days after the alleged violation or, for a continuing violation, no later than 180 days after its most recent occurrence.(2) A civil action under subsection (e) must be commenced no later than two years after the earliest event described in subsection (c) permitting the action or, for an action proceeding under subsection (d), no later than 180 days after the alleged violation.§ 507. Judicial review and remedies.(a) Relief.--Relief available for violations of this chapter shall be consistent with the remedies available under the act of October 27, 1955 (P.L.744, No.222), known as the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act, and:(1) In a civil action under section 506(e) (relating to enforcement by commission), a covered person who prevails may be awarded, as appropriate:(i) Declaratory relief.(ii) Temporary and permanent injunctive relief.(iii) Compensatory and nominal damages, reasonable attorney fees and costs.20260HB2776PN3884 - 16 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 (2) Notwithstanding 42 Pa.C.S. § 8541 (relating to governmental immunity generally), immunity is waived to the extent necessary to permit an award of the relief described in this subsection against a school for a violation of this chapter, provided that an award of damages against a school is subject to the limitations in 42 Pa.C.S. § 8553 (relating to limitations on damages). A school official found to have engaged in willful misconduct in violation of this chapter is not entitled to immunity for that conduct under 42 Pa.C.S. § 8550 (relating to willful misconduct) and may be individually liable for compensatory, nominal and punitive damages for such conduct.(3) The judicial remedies described in this section are available only through a civil action initiated under section 506(e).(b) Retaliation prohibited.--(1) A school or school official may not retaliate against a covered person for asserting a right established or making a request for accommodation or participating in a proceeding under this chapter.(2) A covered person may proceed in accordance with section 506, including under section 506(d), where applicable.(c) Judicial review of commission adjudications.--A final adjudication of the commission on the merits of a complaint under this chapter is subject to judicial review by Commonwealth Court in the manner provided by law for review of Commonwealth agency adjudications.(d) Whistleblower protection.--A school official is not subject to discipline or retaliation by a school for a good- 20260HB2776PN3884 - 17 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 faith report of a suspected violation of this chapter, regardless of the outcome of the report.(e) Definition.--As used in this section, "retaliation" means an adverse action taken against a covered person because the covered person filed, supported or was identified in connection with a complaint, request or proceeding under this chapter, including disciplinary action, exclusion from activities, reduction in academic recognition or interference with organizational status.§ 508. Guidance and training.The department, in consultation with the commission, shall issue, no later than 120 days after the effective date of this section, guidance, model policies and training materials to ensure compliance with this chapter, including an accommodation request procedure consistent with section 505(b) (relating to protected student and employee expression and accommodation) and consistent, objective criteria for determinations required under this chapter, to be applied uniformly by each school.§ 509. Regulations.(a) Duty of commission.--The commission shall promulgate, no later than 120 days after the effective date of this section, regulations governing complaints under this chapter, including complaint forms, investigation procedures, expedited review standards and any notice permitting a civil action under section 506(c) (relating to enforcement by commission), consistent with its existing authority to establish rules of practice under the act of October 27, 1955 (P.L.744, No.222), known as the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act.(b) Training by schools.--Each school shall provide training consistent with the regulation promulgated under this section to 20260HB2776PN3884 - 18 - 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 school officials no later than 90 days after the effective date of the regulation and annually thereafter.§ 510. Severability.If any provision of this chapter or its application to any person or circumstance is held invalid, the invalidity does not affect other provisions or applications of this chapter which can be given effect without the invalid provision or application and to this end the provisions of this chapter are declared severable.Section 2. This act shall take effect as follows:(1) The following shall take effect immediately:The addition of 24 Pa.C.S. § 509.This section.(2) The remainder of this act shall take effect 90 days after the publication of regulations under 24 Pa.C.S. § 509, or in one year, whichever is earlier.20260HB2776PN3884 - 19 - 12345678910111213141516
Official text from the Pennsylvania Legislature. Formatting has been adapted for reading on Ratifi.