Ratifi Español Sign in
Ratifi

Federal bills from Congress.gov. State bills from Open States.

SB 448Session 2025

Administrative Procedure

S 448 c1

Underlined text would be added to current law. Struck-through text would be removed.

Florida Senate - 2025 CS for SB 448 By the Committee on Governmental Oversight and Accountability; and Senator Burgess 585-02282-25 2025448c1 1 A bill to be entitled 2 An act relating to administrative procedure; amending 3 s. 120.52, F.S.; specifying that an agency’s issuance 4 of a guidance document or other statement interpreting 5 a statute without express statutory delegation to 6 issue such guidance is an invalid exercise of 7 delegated legislative authority; amending s. 120.536, 8 F.S.; prohibiting an agency from adopting a rule or 9 issuing a guidance document without statutory 10 delegation; reenacting and amending s. 120.541, F.S.; 11 requiring an agency to prepare a statement of 12 estimated regulatory costs for all proposed rules, 13 notices of change, and final rules; requiring 14 publication of materials used to produce estimates of 15 regulatory costs in a specified manner; providing 16 additional requirements for cost-benefit analyses for 17 certain rules; requiring an agency to conduct 18 retrospective cost-benefit analyses and assessment 19 reports for certain rules, subject to certain 20 requirements; requiring the Administrative Procedures 21 Committee to set a review schedule for existing rules 22 to undergo a retrospective cost-benefit analysis and 23 review; providing exceptions; requiring the committee 24 to separately review exempt rules; requiring the 25 agency to perform specified actions during such 26 reviews; amending s. 120.545, F.S.; revising 27 requirements for the review of rules by the 28 Administrative Procedures Committee; amending s. 29 120.55, F.S.; requiring that additional information be 30 published in the Florida Administrative Code; amending 31 s. 120.56, F.S.; specifying that guidance documents 32 are subject to specified provisions; providing that a 33 party subject to an enforcement action may challenge 34 the action on the basis that the agency lacked 35 statutory authority for the rule or guidance document; 36 providing for award of costs and attorney fees; 37 providing for challenges to rules on the grounds that 38 an agency failed to comply with specified provisions; 39 conforming a cross-reference; providing an effective 40 date. 41 42 Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida: 43 44 Section 1. Subsection (8) of section 120.52, Florida 45 Statutes, is amended to read: 46 120.52 Definitions.—As used in this act: 47 (8) “Invalid exercise of delegated legislative authority” 48 means action that goes beyond the powers, functions, and duties 49 delegated by the Legislature. A proposed or existing rule is an 50 invalid exercise of delegated legislative authority if any one 51 of the following applies: 52 (a) The agency has materially failed to follow the 53 applicable rulemaking procedures or requirements set forth in 54 this chapter; 55 (b) The agency has exceeded its grant of rulemaking 56 authority, citation to which is required by s. 120.54(3)(a)1.; 57 (c) The rule enlarges, modifies, or contravenes the 58 specific provisions of law implemented, citation to which is 59 required by s. 120.54(3)(a)1.; 60 (d) The rule is vague, fails to establish adequate 61 standards for agency decisions, or vests unbridled discretion in 62 the agency; 63 (e) The rule is arbitrary or capricious. A rule is 64 arbitrary if it is not supported by logic or the necessary 65 facts; a rule is capricious if it is adopted without thought or 66 reason or is irrational; or 67 (f) The rule imposes regulatory costs on the regulated 68 person, county, or city which could be reduced by the adoption 69 of less costly alternatives that substantially accomplish the 70 statutory objectives; or 71 (g) The agency has issued a guidance document or other 72 statement interpreting a statute without express statutory 73 delegation to issue such guidance. 74 75 A grant of rulemaking authority is necessary but not sufficient 76 to allow an agency to adopt a rule; a specific law to be 77 implemented is also required. An agency may adopt only rules 78 that implement or interpret the specific powers and duties 79 granted by the enabling statute. No agency shall have authority 80 to adopt a rule only because it is reasonably related to the 81 purpose of the enabling legislation and is not arbitrary and 82 capricious or is within the agency’s class of powers and duties, 83 nor shall an agency have the authority to implement statutory 84 provisions setting forth general legislative intent or policy. 85 Statutory language granting rulemaking authority or generally 86 describing the powers and functions of an agency shall be 87 construed to extend no further than implementing or interpreting 88 the specific powers and duties conferred by the enabling 89 statute. 90 Section 2. Subsection (1) of section 120.536, Florida 91 Statutes, is amended to read: 92 120.536 Rulemaking authority; repeal; challenge.— 93 (1) A grant of rulemaking authority is necessary but not 94 sufficient to allow an agency to adopt a rule; a specific law to 95 be implemented is also required. An agency may adopt only rules 96 that implement or interpret the specific powers and duties 97 granted by the enabling statute. An agency may not adopt any 98 rule or issue any guidance document unless the agency has been 99 expressly granted the power to do so by a specific statutory 100 delegation. No agency shall have authority to adopt a rule only 101 because it is reasonably related to the purpose of the enabling 102 legislation and is not arbitrary and capricious or is within the 103 agency’s class of powers and duties, nor shall an agency have 104 the authority to implement statutory provisions setting forth 105 general legislative intent or policy. Statutory language 106 granting rulemaking authority or generally describing the powers 107 and functions of an agency shall be construed to extend no 108 further than implementing or interpreting the specific powers 109 and duties conferred by the enabling statute. 110 Section 3. Subsection (1), paragraph (g) of subsection (2), 111 and subsection (5) of section 120.541, Florida Statutes, are 112 amended, paragraph (h) is added to subsection (2) of that 113 section, subsection (6) is added to that section, and subsection 114 (4) of that section is reenacted, to read: 115 120.541 Statement of estimated regulatory costs.— 116 (1)(a) An agency shall prepare a statement of estimated 117 regulatory costs for each proposed rule, notice of change, or 118 final rule, regardless of whether the proposed rule, notice of 119 change, or final rule will have an adverse impact on small 120 business or is likely to increase regulatory costs. The 121 statement must include a cost-benefit analysis that clearly 122 demonstrates that the projected benefits of the proposed rule, 123 notice of change, or final rule exceed its projected costs. 124 (b)(a) Within 21 days after publication of the notice 125 required under s. 120.54(3)(a), a substantially affected person 126 may submit to an agency a good faith written proposal for a 127 lower cost regulatory alternative to a proposed rule which 128 substantially accomplishes the objectives of the law being 129 implemented. The proposal may include the alternative of not 130 adopting any rule if the proposal explains how the lower costs 131 and objectives of the law will be achieved by not adopting any 132 rule. If such a proposal is submitted, the 90-day period for 133 filing the rule is extended 21 days. Upon the submission of the 134 lower cost regulatory alternative, the agency shall prepare a 135 statement of estimated regulatory costs as provided in 136 subsection (2), or shall revise its prior statement of estimated 137 regulatory costs, and either adopt the alternative or provide a 138 statement of the reasons for rejecting the alternative in favor 139 of the proposed rule. 140 (c)(b) If a proposed rule, notice of change, or final rule 141 will have an adverse impact on small business or if the proposed 142 rule, notice of change, or final rule is likely to directly or 143 indirectly increase regulatory costs in excess of $200,000 in 144 the aggregate within 1 year after the implementation of the 145 rule, the agency shall prepare a statement of estimated 146 regulatory costs as required by s. 120.54(3)(b). 147 (d)(c) The agency shall revise a statement of estimated 148 regulatory costs if any change to the rule made under s. 149 120.54(3)(d) increases the regulatory costs of the rule. 150 (e)(d) At least 21 days before filing the rule for 151 adoption, an agency that is required to revise a statement of 152 estimated regulatory costs shall provide the statement to the 153 person who submitted the lower cost regulatory alternative and 154 to the committee and shall provide notice on the agency’s 155 website that it is available to the public. 156 (f)(e) Notwithstanding s. 120.56(1)(c), the failure of the 157 agency to prepare a statement of estimated regulatory costs or 158 to respond to a written lower cost regulatory alternative as 159 provided in this subsection is a material failure to follow the 160 applicable rulemaking procedures or requirements set forth in 161 this chapter. 162 (g)(f) An agency’s failure to prepare a statement of 163 estimated regulatory costs or to respond to a written lower cost 164 regulatory alternative may not be raised in a proceeding 165 challenging the validity of a rule pursuant to s. 120.52(8)(a) 166 unless: 167 1. Raised in a petition filed no later than 1 year after 168 the effective date of the rule; and 169 2. Raised by a person whose substantial interests are 170 affected by the rule’s regulatory costs. 171 (h)(g) A rule that is challenged pursuant to s. 172 120.52(8)(f) may not be declared invalid unless: 173 1. The issue is raised in an administrative proceeding 174 within 1 year after the effective date of the rule; 175 2. The challenge is to the agency’s rejection of a lower 176 cost regulatory alternative offered under paragraph (b) (a) or 177 s. 120.54(3)(b)2.b.; and 178 3. The substantial interests of the person challenging the 179 rule are materially affected by the rejection. 180 (2) A statement of estimated regulatory costs shall 181 include: 182 (g) In the statement or revised statement, whichever 183 applies, a description of any regulatory alternatives submitted 184 under paragraph (1)(b) (1)(a) and a statement adopting the 185 alternative or a statement of the reasons for rejecting the 186 alternative in favor of the proposed rule. 187 (h) All documentation, assumptions, methods, and data used 188 in preparing the statement of estimated regulatory costs must be 189 published on a publicly accessible website and, where relevant, 190 in a machine-readable format readily available to the public, 191 including any supporting calculations, documents, data, 192 databases, or data tables, so that the results of the analysis 193 can be replicated. Uncertainties pertaining to these estimates 194 must be reported. 195 (4) Subsection (3) does not apply to the adoption of: 196 (a) Federal standards pursuant to s. 120.54(6). 197 (b) Triennial updates of and amendments to the Florida 198 Building Code which are expressly authorized by s. 553.73. 199 (c) Triennial updates of and amendments to the Florida Fire 200 Prevention Code which are expressly authorized by s. 633.202. 201 (5) For purposes of subsections (2) and (3), adverse 202 impacts and regulatory costs likely to occur within 5 years 203 after implementation of the rule include adverse impacts and 204 regulatory costs estimated to occur within 5 years after the 205 effective date of the rule. However, if any provision of the 206 rule is not fully implemented upon the effective date of the 207 rule, the adverse impacts and regulatory costs associated with 208 such provision must be adjusted to include any additional 209 adverse impacts and regulatory costs estimated to occur within 5 210 years after implementation of such provision. However, an agency 211 may include longer periods of review but must, at a minimum, 212 provide a cost-benefit analysis that projects the first 5 years 213 after the rule goes into effect. If a discount rate is used in 214 the analysis, its use must be justified. The agency must also 215 provide an analysis without the use of discount rates. 216 (6)(a) An agency shall conduct a retrospective cost-benefit 217 analysis for each adopted rule 4 years after the rule’s 218 effective date. The analysis must compare the actual costs and 219 benefits of the rule to those projected in the initial statement 220 of estimated regulatory costs prepared under paragraph (1)(a). 221 (b) An agency shall conduct a retrospective assessment 222 report for each adopted rule 8 years after the rule’s effective 223 date. The report must compare the initial projected cost-benefit 224 analysis, the retrospective analysis conducted under paragraph 225 (a), and the outcomes observed up to this time. The agency shall 226 incorporate the findings and lessons learned from this 227 comparison into the standards for future statements of estimated 228 regulatory costs and apply them to similar rules. 229 (c) For all rules in effect on July 1, 2025, the committee 230 must set a schedule for agencies to conduct the analysis and 231 report as required by paragraphs (a) and (b), taking into 232 consideration the time and resources agencies will expend to 233 perform such review. Such reviews must be scheduled to begin 234 between July 1, 2027, and July 1, 2037. 235 (d) An amendment to a rule through subsequent rulemaking 236 does not affect the agency’s duty to perform the reviews as 237 required by paragraphs (a) and (b), unless the amendment 238 completely repeals and adopts a new rule as described in s. 239 120.54. In such case, the rule’s review dates must be determined 240 based on the effective date of the subsequent rule. 241 (e) The following rules are exempt from the review 242 processes described in paragraphs (a) and (b): 243 1. Rules required to comply with federal law or to receive 244 federal funds. 245 2. Rules adopted pursuant to authority granted under the 246 State Constitution. 247 3. Rules of agencies that are headed by an elected 248 official. 249 (f) Rules exempt under paragraph (e) must be reviewed by 250 the agency according to the schedule set by the committee. The 251 agency may not begin its review more than 1 year before the 252 rule’s scheduled review date. 253 (g) During the review, including any review under paragraph 254 (f), the agency shall: 255 1. Notify the public of the review, including making the 256 text of the notice, the text of the rule, and all analyses 257 associated with the review available on the agency’s website. 258 2. Hold a public comment period for at least 30 days. 259 3. Conduct all analyses that would be required if the rule 260 were being readopted pursuant to s. 120.54. 261 4. Provide a reasoned response to unique public comments. 262 5. Publish a report on the agency’s website which includes 263 the analyses and the agency’s response to public comments. 264 Section 4. Paragraphs (m) and (n) are added to subsection 265 (1) of section 120.545, Florida Statutes, to read: 266 120.545 Committee review of agency rules.— 267 (1) As a legislative check on legislatively created 268 authority, the committee shall examine each proposed rule, 269 except for those proposed rules exempted by s. 120.81(1)(e) and 270 (2), and its accompanying material, and each emergency rule, and 271 may examine any existing rule, for the purpose of determining 272 whether: 273 (m) The agency is timely complying with the review 274 requirements described in s. 120.541(6)(a) and (b). 275 (n) The agency has properly reviewed exempt rules as 276 required under s. 120.541(6)(f). 277 Section 5. Paragraph (a) of subsection (1) of 120.55, 278 Florida Statutes, is amended to read: 279 120.55 Publication.— 280 (1) The Department of State shall: 281 (a)1. Through a continuous revision and publication system, 282 compile and publish electronically, on a website managed by the 283 department, the “Florida Administrative Code.” The Florida 284 Administrative Code shall contain all rules adopted by each 285 agency, citing the grant of rulemaking authority and the 286 specific law implemented pursuant to which each rule was 287 adopted, including the effective date of each rule, all history 288 notes as authorized in s. 120.545(7), complete indexes to all 289 rules contained in the code, and any other material required or 290 authorized by law or deemed useful by the department. The 291 electronic code shall display each rule chapter currently in 292 effect in browse mode and allow full text search of the code and 293 each rule chapter. The department may contract with a publishing 294 firm for a printed publication; however, the department shall 295 retain responsibility for the code as provided in this section. 296 The electronic publication shall be the official compilation of 297 the administrative rules of this state. The Department of State 298 shall retain the copyright over the Florida Administrative Code. 299 2. Rules general in form but applicable to only one school 300 district, community college district, or county, or a part 301 thereof, or state university rules relating to internal 302 personnel or business and finance shall not be published in the 303 Florida Administrative Code. Exclusion from publication in the 304 Florida Administrative Code shall not affect the validity or 305 effectiveness of such rules. 306 3. At the beginning of the section of the code dealing with 307 an agency that files copies of its rules with the department, 308 the department shall publish the address and telephone number of 309 the executive offices of each agency, the manner by which the 310 agency indexes its rules, a listing of all rules of that agency 311 excluded from publication in the code, and a statement as to 312 where those rules may be inspected. 313 4. Forms shall not be published in the Florida 314 Administrative Code; but any form which an agency uses in its 315 dealings with the public, along with any accompanying 316 instructions, shall be filed with the committee before it is 317 used. Any form or instruction which meets the definition of 318 “rule” provided in s. 120.52 shall be incorporated by reference 319 into the appropriate rule. The reference shall specifically 320 state that the form is being incorporated by reference and shall 321 include the number, title, and effective date of the form and an 322 explanation of how the form may be obtained. Each form created 323 by an agency which is incorporated by reference in a rule notice 324 of which is given under s. 120.54(3)(a) after December 31, 2007, 325 must clearly display the number, title, and effective date of 326 the form and the number of the rule in which the form is 327 incorporated. 328 5. The department shall allow adopted rules and material 329 incorporated by reference to be filed in electronic form as 330 prescribed by department rule. When a rule is filed for adoption 331 with incorporated material in electronic form, the department’s 332 publication of the Florida Administrative Code on its website 333 must contain a hyperlink from the incorporating reference in the 334 rule directly to that material. The department may not allow 335 hyperlinks from rules in the Florida Administrative Code to any 336 material other than that filed with and maintained by the 337 department, but may allow hyperlinks to incorporated material 338 maintained by the department from the adopting agency’s website 339 or other sites. 340 Section 6. Subsection (1) and paragraph (a) of subsection 341 (2) of section 120.56, Florida Statutes, are amended to read: 342 120.56 Challenges to rules.— 343 (1) GENERAL PROCEDURES.— 344 (a) Any person substantially affected by a rule, a guidance 345 document, or a proposed rule may seek an administrative 346 determination of the invalidity of the rule or guidance document 347 on the ground that the rule or guidance document is an invalid 348 exercise of delegated legislative authority. All of the 349 provisions in this section apply to guidance documents as well 350 as adopted rules. 351 (b) The petition challenging the validity of a proposed or 352 adopted rule under this section must state: 353 1. The particular provisions alleged to be invalid and a 354 statement of the facts or grounds for the alleged invalidity. 355 2. Facts sufficient to show that the petitioner is 356 substantially affected by the challenged adopted rule or would 357 be substantially affected by the proposed rule. 358 (c) The petition shall be filed by electronic means with 359 the division which shall, immediately upon filing, forward by 360 electronic means copies to the agency whose rule is challenged, 361 the Department of State, and the committee. Within 10 days after 362 receiving the petition, the division director shall, if the 363 petition complies with paragraph (b), assign an administrative 364 law judge who shall conduct a hearing within 30 days thereafter, 365 unless the petition is withdrawn or a continuance is granted by 366 agreement of the parties or for good cause shown. Evidence of 367 good cause includes, but is not limited to, written notice of an 368 agency’s decision to modify or withdraw the proposed rule or a 369 written notice from the chair of the committee stating that the 370 committee will consider an objection to the rule at its next 371 scheduled meeting. The failure of an agency to follow the 372 applicable rulemaking procedures or requirements set forth in 373 this chapter shall be presumed to be material; however, the 374 agency may rebut this presumption by showing that the 375 substantial interests of the petitioner and the fairness of the 376 proceedings have not been impaired. 377 (d) Within 30 days after the hearing, the administrative 378 law judge shall render a decision and state the reasons for his 379 or her decision in writing. The division shall forthwith 380 transmit by electronic means copies of the administrative law 381 judge’s decision to the agency, the Department of State, and the 382 committee. 383 (e) Hearings held under this section shall be de novo in 384 nature. The standard of proof shall be the preponderance of the 385 evidence. Hearings shall be conducted in the same manner as 386 provided by ss. 120.569 and 120.57, except that the 387 administrative law judge’s order shall be final agency action. 388 The petitioner and the agency whose rule is challenged shall be 389 adverse parties. Other substantially affected persons may join 390 the proceedings as intervenors on appropriate terms which shall 391 not unduly delay the proceedings. Failure to proceed under this 392 section does not constitute failure to exhaust administrative 393 remedies. 394 (f) Any party subject to an enforcement action may 395 challenge the enforcement action based solely on the grounds 396 that the agency lacked express statutory authority to adopt the 397 rule or issue a guidance document upon which the enforcement 398 action is based. Any party that prevails on such a challenge 399 shall be entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorney fees. 400 (g)1. A person may challenge a rule on the grounds that the 401 agency failed to comply with s. 120.541 by: 402 a. Failing to prepare a statement of estimated regulatory 403 costs as required; 404 b. Preparing a statement of estimated regulatory costs that 405 does not include all the information required by s. 120.541(2); 406 c. Failing to make the statement or the underlying data and 407 analysis publicly available as required by s. 120.541(2)(h); or 408 d. Failing to conduct the retrospective analyses required 409 by s. 120.541(1)(i) and (j). 410 2. If an administrative law judge finds that the agency has 411 materially failed to comply with s. 120.541, the rule must be 412 declared invalid and void. 413 (2) CHALLENGING PROPOSED RULES; SPECIAL PROVISIONS.— 414 (a) A petition alleging the invalidity of a proposed rule 415 shall be filed within 21 days after the date of publication of 416 the notice required by s. 120.54(3)(a); within 10 days after the 417 final public hearing is held on the proposed rule as provided by 418 s. 120.54(3)(e)2.; within 20 days after the statement of 419 estimated regulatory costs or revised statement of estimated 420 regulatory costs, if applicable, has been prepared and made 421 available as provided in s. 120.541(1)(e) s. 120.541(1)(d); or 422 within 20 days after the date of publication of the notice 423 required by s. 120.54(3)(d). The petitioner has the burden to 424 prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the petitioner 425 would be substantially affected by the proposed rule. The agency 426 then has the burden to prove by a preponderance of the evidence 427 that the proposed rule is not an invalid exercise of delegated 428 legislative authority as to the objections raised. A person who 429 is not substantially affected by the proposed rule as initially 430 noticed, but who is substantially affected by the rule as a 431 result of a change, may challenge any provision of the resulting 432 proposed rule. 433 Section 7. This act shall take effect July 1, 2025.

Official text from the Florida Legislature. Formatting has been adapted for reading on Ratifi.