Bill Text
|
SPONSOR: |
Sen. Sokola & Sen. Townsend & Sen. Lockman & Rep. Romer |
DELAWARE STATE SENATE
153rd GENERAL ASSEMBLY
SENATE BILL NO. 350
AN ACT TO AMEND TITLE 9 AND TITLE 14 OF THE DELAWARE CODE RELATING TO REAL PROPERTY TAXATION, CLASSIFICATION, AND SPLIT-RATE TAX AUTHORITY.
BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE:
WHEREAS, judicial decisions interpreting Article VIII, § 1 of the Delaware Constitution recognize that the General Assembly may authorize different property-tax rates for reasonably defined classes of real property, provided that rates are uniform within each class and that the classifications are reasonable and not arbitrary; and
WHEREAS, judicial decisions interpreting Article VIII, § 1 of the Delaware Constitution further recognize that the Uniformity Clause does not require all real property to be treated as a single class of subjects and permits the establishment of multiple classes of taxable real property; and
WHEREAS, after New Castle County reassessment and the temporary split-rate system authorized for the 2025-2026 school tax year, multifamily residential properties were grouped with non-residential properties and bore materially higher tax burdens than one-to-four-family residential properties in multiple New Castle County school districts; and
WHEREAS, t h e General Assembly finds that property used to house individuals, including both one-to-four-family homes and multifamily housing, is residential in character and should not be treated as commercial or industrial property for purposes of ad valorem real-property taxation; and
WHEREAS, the General Assembly further finds that the 2025-2026 temporary split-rate structure imposed on multifamily residential property a materially disproportionate school-tax burden relative to one-to-four-family residential property and that a statutory cap limiting the multifamily school - tax rate to not more than 120% of the one - to - four - family residential rate, applied uniformly within class and conditioned on existing statutory revenue limitations, is a reasonable and necessary legislative response; and
WHEREAS, the purpose of this Act is to establish a permanent, statewide framework for classifying real property; authorize counties, school districts, and vocational-technical school districts to impose different tax rates on different classes of real property consistent with Article VIII, § 1 of the Delaware Constitution; treat multifamily housing as part of Delaware's residential housing sector; provide that no school district or vocational-technical school district may impose on Class B multifamily residential real property a tax rate greater than 120% of the rate imposed on Class A one-to-four family residential real property in the same jurisdiction and tax year; and require any rate reset under this Act to be revenue neutral.
Section 1. Amend § 8002, Title 9 of the Delaware Code by making deletions as shown by strike through and insertions as shown by underline as follows:
§ 8002. Tax rate. County real property tax rate; classifications.
(a) After the budget has been adopted, the respective county governing bodies shall fix their county tax rates rate, or rates, based upon the most recent assessment made by the county governing bodies as follows:
(1) The county tax rate shall be stated in terms of a certain rate on every $100 of assessed evaluation.
(2) Subject to the limitations of subsection (b) of this section, the county tax rate shall rate, or rates, must be such as will produce sufficient tax revenues to meet the budget requirement of the county for all purposes other than those that are not to be paid for out of the general county tax revenues.
(3) The county tax rate shall may not include special assessments, tax specially levied to pay principal of and interest on bonds, or taxes levied for the benefit of local districts established in accordance with statutes authorizing such special taxation.
(4) a. A county governing body may adopt different tax rates for real property based on different real property classifications adopted by the county governing body.
b. Tax rates established under paragraph (a)(4)a. of this section must be uniform for all real property in the same classification, as required under § 1 of Article VIII of the Delaware Constitution.
(4) A county governing body may adopt different tax rates for real property based on different real-property classes adopted by the county governing body, including the statewide classes established under § 8305A of this title and any additional reasonable classes of property that the county may create by ordinance in accordance with § 8305B of this title. Tax rates established under this paragraph must be uniform within each class for all real property in the same class, as required under Article VIII, § 1 of the Delaware Constitution.
(5) For purposes of this chapter, “county tax rate” means a single tax rate adopted for all classes of real property or a tax rate adopted under paragraph (a)(4) of this section.
(f) In exercising the authority granted by paragraph (a)(4) of this section, and in addition to the requirements of § 8305B of this title, the governing body of each county may, by ordinance, impose different real-property tax rates on 1 or more of the classes of property established under § 8305A of this title and on any additional reasonable classes created by ordinance, provided that:
(1) Each class is based on objective differences in use, density, regulatory status, occupancy restrictions, affordability covenants, or other relevant characteristics and is reasonably related to the purposes described in § 8305A(a) of this title.
(2) The tax rate is uniform within each class and complies with Article VIII, § 1 of the Delaware Constitution and judicial decisions interpreting that provision.
(g) Any county tax rate imposed on Class B multifamily residential real property may not exceed the county tax rate imposed on Class A one-to-four-family residential real property in the same fiscal year.
(h) Nothing in this section requires a county to establish multiple tax rates. A county may elect to impose a single uniform rate on all taxable real property within the county, consistent with Article VIII, § 1 of the Delaware Constitution and this title.
(i) Nothing in this section alters any limitation on the overall county tax rate, any rolled-back-rate requirement, or any post-reassessment revenue limitation otherwise provided by law, including the 15% county post-reassessment cap set forth in subsection (c) of this section.
Section 2. Amend Chapter 83, Title 9 of the Delaware Code by making deletions as shown by strike through and insertions as shown by underline as follows and by redesignating accordingly:
§ 8305A. Statewide classification of real property for county tax purposes; renter-homeowner parity.
(a) The purpose of this section is to do all of the following:
(1) Recognize residential use as a constitutionally relevant basis for classifying taxable real property used to house individuals and ensure that property used to house individuals, including multifamily rental and affordable-housing properties, is classified and taxed as residential in character, rather than as commercial or industrial.
(2) Preserve reasonable distinctions between residential and non-residential uses, consistent with Article VIII, § 1 of the Delaware Constitution and judicial decisions interpreting that provision.
(3) Provide a uniform, statewide framework for classifying taxable real property for county, school-district, and vocational-technical-school-district taxation.
(b) For purposes of county real-property taxation under this title, taxable real property is classified, by use, into the following classes:
(1) Class A — One-to-four-family residential real property. Real property improved with 1 to 4 dwelling units used predominantly for permanent or temporary housing by individuals, including single-family, 2-family, 3-family, and 4-family structures, whether owner-occupied or rented.
(2) Class B — Multifamily residential real property. Real property improved with 5 or more dwelling units within a single parcel or commonly assessed group of parcels and used predominantly for rental or cooperative residential occupancy, including property subject to recorded affordability covenants, regulatory agreements, or income-restricted occupancy requirements.
(3) Class C — Non-residential real property. All taxable real property that is not Class A or Class B real property, including commercial, industrial, utility, and institutional property.
(4) Class D — Mixed-use real property. Taxable real property that contains both residential uses, including Class B multifamily residential uses, and non-residential uses.
(c) For Class D mixed-use real property, the county shall allocate the total assessed value among Classes A, B, and C, as applicable, in proportion to floor area or another uniform, objectively verifiable measure of use specified by county ordinance. The portion of assessed value allocated to each class must be taxed at the rate applicable to that class. The county may not use different allocation methods for similarly situated properties within the same class. The county may adopt implementing rules or guidance to promote reasonable and consistent application of this subsection.
(d) For purposes of policy and statutory construction under this title and Title 14, the General Assembly finds that Class A one-to-four-family residential real property and Class B multifamily residential real property together comprise Delaware's residential housing sector, and that both classes provide housing for individuals and may not be treated as commercial or industrial property for real-property tax purposes.
§ 8305B. Additional classes of real property.
(a) The General Assembly may, by law, establish additional statewide classes of real property for ad valorem tax purposes, including additional residential, affordable-housing, mixed-use, or neighborhood-commercial classes, provided that:
(1) Each class is reasonable and based on uniform, objectively verifiable criteria, including use, density, regulatory status, occupancy restrictions, affordability covenants, floor area, gross income, square footage, or other relevant characteristics.
(2) Any differences in tax rates among classes are reasonable and based on use, density, regulatory status, occupancy restrictions, affordability covenants, or other objectively verifiable characteristics, and are designed to promote stable and predictable tax burdens across residential and nonresidential uses.
(3) Tax rates remain uniform within each class, consistent with Article VIII, § 1 of the Delaware Constitution.
(b) A county may, by ordinance, establish local classes within the framework of § 8305A of this title and § 8002 of this title, provided that:
(1) Each local class is based on uniform, objectively verifiable criteria described in subsection (a) of this section, is not adopted to favor identified parcels, taxpayers, or neighborhoods, and is reasonably related to the purposes described in § 8305A(a) of this title.
(2) The county applies a uniform tax rate within each local class and complies with all constitutional and statutory limitations on property-tax classification and rates, including limitations on the overall county tax rate and post-reassessment revenue growth.
(c) The General Assembly may, by law, establish 1 or more statewide affordable-housing classes defined by reference to recorded affordability covenants, regulatory agreements, income-restricted occupancy, or participation in specified federal, state, or local housing programs, and may authorize counties, school districts, and vocational-technical school districts to apply to those classes a rate that is equal to or lower than the rate applied to other residential classes.
Section 3. Amend Chapter 19, Title 14 of the Delaware Code by making deletions as shown by strike through and insertions as shown by underline as follows:
§ 1916A. Real property classes and tax rates for school districts; multifamily cap and revenue neutrality.
(a) For purposes of school district real property taxation under this chapter, taxable real property must be classified in accordance with the classes established under § 8305A(b) of Title 9.
(b) When levying its local school tax under § 1916 of this title, a school district may impose distinct tax rates on 1 or more of those classes, and on any additional classes authorized by law, provided that:
(1) The tax rate is uniform within each class.
(2) The rates and resulting revenues comply with § 1916 of this title and any other applicable law, including the post reassessment rate and revenue limitations in § 1916(b) of this title.
(c) A school district tax rate imposed on Class B multifamily residential real property may not exceed 120% of the tax rate imposed on Class A one-to-four-family residential real property in the same school district and school tax year.
(d) If a school district resets its local school tax rates to implement subsection (c) of this section, the total amount of revenue projected to be collected through use of the revised class tax rates may not exceed the total amount of revenue the district was projected to collect under the tax warrant otherwise applicable for that school tax year.
(e) Compliance with subsection (d) of this section must be determined at the time the district adopts and delivers its warrant, using the assessment, classification, and other tax roll data then officially provided by the county. Later changes to the tax roll, including corrections of classification errors, assessment appeals, supplemental assessments, demolitions, parcel changes, delinquencies, or similar administrative adjustments, do not invalidate the district’s compliance with subsection (d) of this section.
(f) Nothing in this section requires a school district to establish multiple tax rates. A school district may elect to impose a single uniform rate on all taxable real property within the district, consistent with Article VIII, § 1 of the Delaware Constitution and § 1916 of this title.
(g) Nothing in this section alters the 10% post reassessment limit on actual revenue otherwise applicable under § 1916(b) of this title.
Section 4. Amend Chapter 26, Title 14 of the Delaware Code by making deletions as shown by strike through and insertions as shown by underline as follows:
§ 2601A. Real property classes and tax rates for vocational-technical school districts; multifamily cap and revenue neutrality.
(a) For purposes of vocational-technical school district real property taxation under this chapter, taxable real property must be classified in accordance with the classes established under § 8305A(b) of Title 9.
(b) When levying any ad valorem tax on real property under this chapter, a vocational-technical school district may impose distinct tax rates on 1 or more of those classes, and on any additional classes authorized by law, provided that:
(1) The tax rate is uniform within each class.
(2) The rates and resulting revenues comply with § 2601 of this title and any other applicable law, including the post reassessment rate and revenue limitations in § 2601(c).
(c) A vocational-technical school district tax rate imposed on Class B multifamily residential real property may not exceed 120% of the tax rate imposed on Class A one-to-four family residential real property in the same district and school tax year.
(d) If a vocational-technical school district resets its class tax rates to implement subsection (c) of this section, the total amount of revenue projected to be collected through use of the revised class tax rates may not exceed the total amount of revenue the district was projected to collect under the tax warrant otherwise applicable for that tax year.
(e) Compliance with subsection (d) of this section must be determined at the time the district adopts and delivers its warrant, using the assessment, classification, and other tax roll data then officially provided by the county. Later changes to the tax roll, including corrections of classification errors, assessment appeals, supplemental assessments, demolitions, parcel changes, delinquencies, or similar administrative adjustments, do not invalidate the district’s compliance with subsection (d) of this section.
(f) Nothing in this section requires a vocational-technical school district to establish multiple tax rates. A vocational-technical school district may elect to impose a single uniform rate on all taxable real property within the district, consistent with Article VIII, § 1 of the Delaware Constitution and this chapter.
(g) Nothing in this section alters the 10% post reassessment limit on actual revenue otherwise applicable under § 2601(c) of this title.
Section 5. This Act is severable. If any provision of this Act or its application to any person, property, or circumstances is held invalid, the invalidity does not affect the provisions or applications of this Act that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SYNOPSIS
This Act establishes a uniform statewide framework for classifying taxable real property and explicitly grants split-rate tax authority to counties, school districts, and vocational-technical school districts.
The Act defines four baseline, statewide property classes based on use: Class A (one-to-four-family residential property); Class B (multifamily residential property, including affordable and income-restricted housing); Class C (non-residential commercial, industrial, utility, and institutional property); and Class D (mixed-use property, which must have its assessed value allocated proportionally among the other classes based on floor area or another objective measure). The Act explicitly declares that Class A and Class B properties together comprise Delaware’s residential housing sector and protects multifamily housing from being treated as commercial or industrial property for tax purposes.
To protect renters and affordable housing developments from disproportionate tax burdens following property reassessments, this Act implements statutory tax caps on multifamily properties. Any county tax rate imposed on Class B multifamily residential real property may not exceed the rate imposed on Class A one-to-four-family residential real property in the same fiscal year. Furthermore, local school and vocational-technical district tax rates imposed on Class B multifamily residential real property are strictly capped at 120% of the rate applied to Class A residential property within the same jurisdiction and tax year.
The Act requires that if a county, school district, or vocational-technical school district resets its tax rates to implement these classifications, the restructuring must be completely revenue-neutral, meaning total projected revenue cannot exceed the amount originally projected under the applicable tax warrant. Finally, the Act clarifies that jurisdictions are not required to adopt multiple tax rates and may choose to maintain a single uniform rate across all property types, while preserving all existing statutory post-reassessment revenue limits, such as the 15% county cap and 10% school district limits.
Author: Senator Sokola
Official text from the Delaware Legislature. Formatting has been adapted for reading on Ratifi.