Ratifi Español Sign in
Ratifi

Federal bills from Congress.gov. State bills from Open States.

HB 75Session 153

What changed between versions

89 paragraphs changed+1613 words added−1016 removed

Highlighted text was added in the newer version. Struck-through text was removed.

SPONSOR:

Rep. Dukes & Rep. Griffith & Rep. Minor-Brown & Sen. Poore

Reps. Gorman, Hilovsky, K. Johnson, Phillips, Romer, Ross Levin, Snyder-Hall, Shupe, Lambert, Postles; Sens. Hansen, Hocker, Hoffner, Paradee, Pettyjohn, Wilson, Sokola, Pinkney

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

Sen. Sokola

DELAWARE STATE SENATE

153rd GENERAL ASSEMBLY

SENATE AMENDMENT NO. 3

TO

HOUSE BILL NO. 75

AN ACT TO AMEND TITLE 10 OF THE DELAWARE CODE RELATING TO THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR CIVIL CLAIMS BASED ON SEXUAL ABUSE OF A MINOR.

WHEREAS, in June of 2007, the 144 th General Assembly unanimously passed Senate Bill 29, which gave victims of childhood sexual abuse a two year “window,” allowing them to bring a civil action against their abusers in cases previously barred by the law. The bill, known as the Child Victim’s Act of 2007, was signed into law on July 10, 2007; and

WHEREAS, in enacting the bipartisan Child Victim’s Act, Delaware was one of two states at the forefront of a revolution for children; and

WHEREAS, following the enactment of SB 29, opponents of the bill challenged it in the Delaware Supreme Court in Sheehan v. Oblates of St. Francis de Sales, 15 A.3d 1247 (Del. 2011) (en banc), claiming that retroactivity and changes to the statute of limitation were unconstitutional; and

WHEREAS, the Delaware Supreme Court unanimously upheld the constitutionality of the Child Victim’s Act of 2007; and

WHEREAS, 22 states have now followed the pioneering examples of Delaware and California in enacting Child Victim’s Act legislation for survivors of childhood sexual abuse, most recently in the State of Maryland where SB 686 (“The Child Victim’s Act of 2023”) was signed by its Governor on April 11, 2023, to retroactively remove the statute of limitations for all claims of sexual abuse of a minor in that State; and

WHEREAS, while all victims of childhood sexual abuse were covered by the Child Victim’s Act of 2007, many were too young to avail themselves of the opportunity to sue their abusers during the two year “window” provided by the Act; and

WHEREAS, for example, an 8-year-old child sexually abused in 1999 was only 16 when Delaware had its two year window for legal claims; and

WHEREAS, victims of child sexual abuse face significant barriers to disclosure such that the average length of time before disclosure is around 20 years and significantly longer for those who experience institutional abuse; and

WHEREAS, most victims do not acknowledge or understand their abuse and its consequences until well into adulthood, long after the statute of limitations has expired on their claims; and

WHEREAS, it is the intent of this legislature and the purpose of this legislation to give full access to justice for victims of childhood sexual abuse regardless of when it occurred.

NOW, THEREFORE:

BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE:

Section 1. Amend § 8145, Title 10 of the Delaware Code by making deletions as shown by strike through and insertions as shown by underline as follows:

§ 8145. Civil suits for damages based upon sexual abuse of a minor by an adult.

(a) A cause of action based upon the sexual abuse of a minor by an adult may be filed in the Superior Court of this State at any time following the commission of the act or acts that constituted the sexual abuse. A civil cause of action for sexual abuse of a minor shall be based upon sexual acts that would constitute a criminal offense under the Delaware Code.

(b) For a period of 2 years following July 9, 2007, victims of child sexual abuse that occurred in this State who have been barred from filing suit against their abusers by virtue of the expiration of the former civil statute of limitations, shall be permitted to file those claims in the Superior Court of this State. If the person committing the act of sexual abuse against a minor was employed by an institution, agency, firm, business, corporation, or other public or private legal entity that owned a duty of care to the victim, or the accused and the minor were engaged in some activity over which the legal entity had some degree of responsibility or control, damages against the legal entity shall be awarded under this subsection only if there is a finding of gross negligence on the part of the legal entity. Victims of child sexual abuse who have been barred from filing a cause of action based upon the sexual abuse of a minor by an adult by virtue of the expiration of a civil statute of limitation, notice of claim, presentation deadline, or any other time limit that had expired, or for which a final judgment was rendered based on the expiration of any time limitation or other procedural bases, are permitted to file those claims in the Superior Court at any time.

(c) No action relating to the sexual abuse of a minor by an adult that is filed or pending after [the effective date of this act] may be dismissed by virtue of the expiration of a civil statute of limitations.

(d) This section applies to any actions for damages against any person, institution, public or private entity, including any charitable organization, educational institution, hospital, and the government. The State waives sovereign immunity in a cause of action based upon the sexual abuse of a minor by an adult.

(c) (e) A person against whom a suit is filed may recover attorneys’ fees where the Court determines that a false accusation was made with no basis in fact and with malicious intent. A verdict in favor of the accused shall not be the sole basis for a determination that an accusation was false. The Court must make an independent finding of an improper motive to award attorneys’ fees under this section.

AMEND House Bill No. 75 on line 31 by deleting “A cause of action based upon the sexual abuse” and inserting in lieu thereof “A civil cause of action based upon the for sexual abuse”.

FURTHER AMEND House Bill No. 75 on line 32 by deleting “the act or acts that constituted the sexual abuse” and inserting in lieu thereof “ the act or acts that constituted the an act constituting sexual abuse ”.

FURTHER AMEND House Bill No. 75 on line 33 by deleting “ minor shall be based upon sexual acts ” and inserting in lieu thereof “minor shall must be based upon sexual acts on a sexual act ”.

FURTHER AMEND House Bill No. 75 by deleting lines 40 through 44 in their entirety and inserting in lieu thereof the following:

“ only if there is a finding of gross negligence on the part of the legal entity. (1) For purposes of this section:

a. “Alleged abuser” means the individual the victim alleges committed the sexual abuse .

b.1. “Person” means a corporation, business trust, statutory trust, estate, trust, partnership, limited liability company, association, joint venture, government or governmental subdivision, agency, or instrumentality, or any other legal or commercial entity.

2. “Person” includes a protected, registered, or other series, however denominated, of a legal or commercial entity under paragraph (b)(1)b.1. of this section if the series is established under law that limits, or limits if conditions specified under law are satisfied, the ability of a creditor of the legal or commercial entity under paragraph (b)(1)b.1. of this section or of any other series of the legal or commercial entity under paragraph (b)(1)b.1. of this section to satisfy a claim from assets of the series.

3. “Person” does not include an individual , including a sole proprietor.

c. “Employed” or “Employee” includes a volunteer or independent contractor.

d. “Sexual abuse” means a sexual act that would constitute a criminal offense under the Delaware Code.

(2) A victim of sexual abuse of a minor who has been barred from filing a civil cause of action against the victim’s alleged abuser based on the expiration of a civil statute of limitation may file the civil cause of action in the Superior Court at any time.

(3) A victim of sexual abuse of a minor may be awarded damages from a person if all of the following apply:

a. The person owed a duty of care to the victim.

b. The person employed the victim’s alleged abuser or the person had some degree of responsibility or control over the victim’s alleged abuser.

c.1. If the sexual abuse occurred on or before July 9, 2007, there is a finding of gross negligence on the part of the person.

2.If the sexual abuse occurred after July 9, 2007, there is a finding of negligence on the part of the person. ”.

FURTHER AMEND House Bill No. 75 on line 45 by deleting “ No action relating to the ” and inserting in lieu thereof “ A civil cause of action for ”.

FURTHER AMEND House Bill No. 75 on line 46 by deleting “ this act] may be dismissed by virtue of ” and inserting in lieu thereof “ this Act] may not be dismissed because of ”.

FURTHER AMEND House Bill No. 75 by deleting lines 47 through 49 in their entirety and inserting in lieu thereof the following:

“ (d)(1) Notwithstanding a law of this State to the contrary, this section applies to a civil cause of action for sexual abuse of a minor by an adult against any person, including any of the following:

a. A charitable organization.

b. An educational institution.

c. A hospital.

d. This State and a county or other political subdivision of this State, including a school district and a charter school.

e. A public officer or employee of this State or a county or other political subdivision of this State, including a school district and a charter school.

(2) In a civil cause of action for sexual abuse of a minor by an adult, this State or a county or other political subdivision of this State, including a school district and a charter school, is not entitled to the privileges or immunities provided under Chapter 40 of this title or sovereign immunity under Section 9 of Article I of the Delaware Constitution.

(3) The defense of sovereign immunity is waived and may not be asserted by this State or a county or other political subdivision of this State, including a school district and a charter school, in a civil cause of action for sexual abuse of a minor by an adult. ”.

FURTHER AMEND House Bill No. 75 on line 50 by deleting “A person against whom a suit” and inserting in lieu thereof “ A person against whom a suit An alleged abuser against who, or a person against whom, a civil cause of action for sexual abuse of a minor by an adult ”.

FURTHER AMEND House Bill No. 75 on line 50 by deleting “where the Court” and inserting in lieu thereof “ where if the Court”.

FURTHER AMEND House Bill No. 75 on line 51 by deleting “A verdict in favor of the accused shall not be” and inserting in lieu thereof “A verdict in favor of the accused shall the alleged abuser or a person may not be”.

FURTHER AMEND House Bill No. 75 by inserting the following after line 53:

“ (f) For purposes of this section, the following are not “joint tortfeasors”, as defined under Chapter 63 of this title, the Uniform Contribution Among Tortfeasors Law:

(1) The alleged abuser of a victim of sexual abuse of a minor.

(2) A person that employed the victim’s alleged abuser and owed a duty of care to the victim.

(3) A person that had some degree of responsibility and control over an activity in which the victim and the victim’s alleged abuser were engaged and owed a duty of care to the victim.

(g) A victim of sexual abuse of a minor may seek both economic and non-economic damages, including compensation for emotional distress, medical and counseling expenses, and other losses resulting from the sexual abuse.

(h)(1) Except as provided under paragraph (h)(2) of this section, the total amount of monetary damages that may be awarded under this section for injuries arising from a civil cause of action for sexual abuse of a minor by an adult may not exceed the following:

a. $500,000, from the victim’s alleged abuser.

b. $500,000, from a person found liable under paragraph (b)(3) of this section.

(2) The limits on liability provided under paragraph (h)(1) of this section do not include any of the following:

a. Damages awarded for health care expenses, including medical and counseling expenses.

b. Interest accrued on a judgment.

(i)(1) Except as provided under paragraph (i)(2) of this section, a civil cause of action for sexual abuse of a minor by an adult may be maintained only if the alleged abuser of the victim is living and sufficiently competent to participate in the defense of the sexual abuse allegations.

(2) A civil cause of action under this section for sexual abuse of a minor by an adult may be maintained against a victim’s alleged abuser that is deceased or not sufficiently competent to participate in the defense of the sexual abuse allegations on a prima facie showing of evidence to the Superior Court of any of the following:

a. That the victim’s alleged abuser acknowledged or admitted the sexual abuse.

b. Contemporaneous records documenting the sexual abuse.

(j) Subsections (f) through (i) of this section apply only to sexual abuse that occurred on or before July 9, 2007. ”.

SYNOPSIS

A victim of child sexual abuse that occurred in this State who has been barred from filing suit against the victim’s abuser by virtue of the expiration of a former civil statute of limitations are permitted to file these claims in the Superior Court of this state at any time. This is intended to apply retroactively.

This Amendment does all of the following:

(1) Provides definitions of terms used throughout this Act, including a definition of “person” for use when describing the employer of the victim’s alleged abuser.

(2) Provides requirements for obtaining damages from a person that employed the victim’s alleged abuser, or had some degree of responsibility and control over the victim’s alleged abuser.

(3) Specifically waives the sovereign immunity of this State or a county or other political subdivision of this State, including a school district and a charter school.

(4) Provides that the victim’s alleged abuser and a person that employed the victim’s alleged abuser and owed a duty of care to the victim, or had some degree of responsibility and control over an activity which the victim and the victim’s alleged abuser were engaged in, are not joint tortfeasors.

(5) Establishes limits on the damages that may be recovered by the victim.

(6) Establishes evidentiary criteria for a civil cause of action for sexual abuse of a minor by an adult when the adult is deceased or not sufficiently competent to participate in the defense of the sexual abuse allegations.

(7) Makes technical corrections to conform existing law to the standards of the Delaware Legislative Drafting Manual, including by making words that are plural into words that are singular as § 304 of Title 1 provides that the singular includes the plural.

This Amendment differs from Senate Amendment No. 1 by doing the following:

(1) Redrafting for clarity the provisions related to scope and sovereign immunity, including clarifying that the waiver of sovereign immunity includes charter schools.

(2) Clarifying that health care expenses include medical and counseling expenses

(3) Providing that § 8145(f) through (i) of Title 10 applies only to sexual abuse that occurred on or before July 9, 2007.

Author: Senator Sokola

Back to the full text